Vintage Steak House

433 N Country Rd, St James
(631) 862-6440

Recent Reviews

Matthew Rivera

One of the best meals I've had. Everything we ordered was amazing. The chicken cutlet special was out of this world.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tomahawk Steak with Onion Straws, Bread Basket, Parmesan Truffle Fries, Chicken Parmigiana, Crispy Onion Strings

jerry cicio

Always a great meal… the crab cakes are delicious.. Ashley makes a great drink.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DaveS

Great food every time we go and we have dined there many times over the years. We always enjoy the service there as they are attentive but not overbearing and allow you to enjoy the food and company while enjoying your meal.

Dani DeLongis

Steak houses can be difficult for veggies, but this one didn’t disappoint. Our server was excellent and didn’t blink an eye at my order consisting of all the delicious salads and sides. My carnivore hubby goes here regularly with colleagues and thought I would enjoy and I definitely did. Nice ambiance and everything was delicious.Vegetarian options: Salads, sautéed broccoli, sautéed spinach, baked potato, mashed sweet potatoes, yummy bread basket.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bread Basket, Creamed or Sauteed Spinach

JoeR

Fantastic meal. Everything from appetizers (grilled pear salad and clams casino), dinner (tomahawk steaks for two with mixed mushrooms and cream spinach) to desert (New York cheesecake) was fabulous. Server Melvin was attentive and engaging. Great night out!

My husband and I went for the first time to celebrate our 32nd wedding anniversary! Was an overall very pleasant experience! Our waiter and service were excellent! We ordered the tomahawk for 2 and the meat and flavor were incredible! Sooooooo good!!!! A little disappointed we had no table side show as website said. We ordered 3 sides: mashed potatoes, truffle fries and asparagus parmigiana. The fries were very good as was the asparagus! As for the mashed potatoes, they honestly were terrible! Very bland, not creamy at all! Tasted like they could have been boxed! I make home made mashed potatoes and these were awful!!! Very small portion also!!! Again, I liked fries and asparagus, however, didn't love enough to order again! We also got a dozen clams on a half shell and they were delicious with an amazing tasty sauce!!!!! I would come back, and would love to try the lobster!!! Also French onion soup!!!! Our waiter brought us a delicious piece of cheesecake with whipped cream and strawberries and a candle for our anniversary! Very nice evening!!!!

Perry Boatswain

The Steak lacked taste. Literally needed salt. The pork chops were smothered with something that tasted like BBQ sauce. Not good! They also don't make a smoked old fashioned drink. Which is the standard right now. However, the appetizers were good. The French onion soup was solid, Crab cocktail and the calamari.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

I had made an appointment for an 8pm seating there were later times also. We walked in before our reservation time and was told that the people at the table we would be getting were just starting dessert. I would have preferred to get a text or call since they do ask for your number which I would like would be used to contact me. And just let me know that they were running a minimum of 1/2 hour late which would have given us other options. They room was so loud when we finally did sit that none of us heard the waiter say the specials we all laughed. We couldn't even have a normal conversation. Food took way too long to come out that I had to ask the hostess if they could go check our food. The food was delicious and the waiter was nice I guess even though we couldn't hear him. I would suggest they invest In sound proofing. Would I recommend sure but I would tell people to call to see if your reservation time is on point..

Tanner Obrien

Overpriced and not as good as it used to be !

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

JoeR

Vintage is a Top Notch Steakhouse The Appetizers were delicious and the steaks were phenomenal. Our Server Mario was top notch My wife is Gluten Free and Mario answered all of her Questions he was Very Helpful!! I would definitely recommend this Place to anyone!!???????

MicheleD

From the appetizers to the main courses, the food is delicious. The Steak Oskar was cooked perfect! The Porterhouse for two was the best. Even the Cocktail's, French Martini and Kettle Cosmos were on point. The waiter, Christian made sure everything was Perfect. A must try!

MSReid

Delicious! I have never been disappointed by a meal here. The food is outstanding and wait staff is attentive and has never gotten my order wrong. The rooms can get pretty loud.  It iis common place to see several large parties of men enjoying a steak and having a good time. There is no need to go anywhere else for an outstanding steak. 

CathyS

The food, service, dessert and drinks were outstanding. Our only issue was that we were by a table of 8 and they were very loud. Upon their departure the whole room was relieved. Each table commented how they could not have a conversation without raising their voice. It was a sin that this put a damper on the evening.

RichardA

Very nice dining experience with good food and service. As seems to be the case in nearly all restaurants, the patrons are not always courteous with respect to their level of chatter/noise.

RonDa1969

My husband favorite spot for great steak! He gets his filet mignon with onion a, Bernese sauce and a side of truffle French fries and he LOVES IT! I already shared that I am vegan and this is my favorite place too!! As everything is cooked at the moment they are very flexible. Special kudos and thank you to Marvin and Mario. They are amazing and they always make us feel as part of the family!! Great place!!!

Load More