High Street Bagels Sayville
217 N Main St, Sayville
(631) 319-1540
Customers' Favorites
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
Bacon Lovers Chicken Panini
Breakfast Burritos
Chicken Salad
Potato Salad
Tex-Mex Wrap
Turkey Club
French Toast
Home Fries
Vegetarian
Egg Sandwiches
Eggs Sandwich
Eggs & Cheese Sandwich
Eggs & Meat Sandwich
Bacon, ham, turkey, or sausage.
Eggs, Cheese, & Meat Sandwich
Breakfast Heroes
Batman Hero
2 eggs, bacon ham, and sausage.
Robin Hero
3 eggs bacon, sausage, and cheese.
The Hungry Man Hero
3 eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, and cheese.
Breakfast Burritos
Classic Burrito
Eggs, onions ham, and American cheese.
Spicy Burrito
Eggs, home fries bacon, swiss, and jalapeno peppers.
Veggie Burrito
Eggs, mushrooms, grilled onions, and peppers.
Healthy Burrito
Eggs whites, spinach, swiss cheese, and onions.
No Cheese Burrito
Eggs, peppers, ham, bacon, and onions.
Omelets
American Omelet
Onions and bacon and American cheese. Made with 3 eggs and served with toast or bagel.
Calorie Counter Omelet
Egg whites and oven gold turkey and Swiss. Made with 3 eggs and served with toast or bagel.
Western Omelet
Ham, peppers and onions, and American. Made with 3 eggs and served with toast or bagel.
Greek Omelet
Egg whites, spinach feta, and onions. Made with 3 eggs and served with toast or bagel.
Mexican Veggie Omelet
Bacon, swiss, tomato, jalapeno peppers. Made with 3 eggs and served with toast or bagel.
Signature Sandwiches
The Commuter Sandwich
Maple honey turkey, bacon, and melted Vermont cheddar cheese and honey mustard on a hero.
The Beast Sandwich
Hot roast beef, and melted mozzarella on a roll.
The Station Sandwich
Roast beet jalapeno pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato onions, and horseradish sauce on a hero.
Sayville Mom's Sandwich
Maple honey turkey, bacon, melted Swiss cheese, and honey mustard on a roll.
All Aboard Sandwich
Hot roast beef melted provolone, and Russian dressing on a hero.
Vegetarian Sandwich
Roasted eggplant, tomato, mozzarella, and jalapeno on a roll.
The Runaway Sandwich
Roast beef, bacon, mated cheddar, and BBQ sauce on a hero.
Gone Fishing Sandwich
Bologna and American with mayo or mustard on a roll.
The Boone Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, and bacon with Russian dressing on a rod.
South Shore Sandwich
Oven gold turkey, pepperoni, American, lettuce, tomato, and served on a bagel.
The Works Sandwich
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, and tomato a heroes.
Cherry Avenue Elementary Sandwich
Deluxe ham, swiss cheese, lettuce, and mayo on a roll.
The Rail Sandwich
Grilled pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, and coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a roll.
Lincoln Avenue Elementary Sandwich
Oven gold turkey, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a roll.
The Traveler Sandwich
Maple honey turkey, bacon, mozzarella, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a roll.
Sunrise Drive Elementary Sandwich
Oven gold turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and oil a vinegar on a roll.
Signature Burgers
Classic Hamburger (1/2 Lb)
Deluxe Burger
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, fries and or rings.
Classic Cheese Burger (1/2 Lb)
Mushroom Swiss Burger (1/2 Lb)
Sauteed mushroom and melted Swiss.
Bacon Blue Cheese Burger (1/2 Lb)
Bocan and cheese.
Deutschandler (1/2 Lb)
Bacon, pickles, mustard, and muenster cheese.
Classic Sandwiches
Classic Reuben Sandwich
Corned beef, swiss, 1000 island, and grilled marbled rye. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
The Carnegie Sandwich
Hot pastrami, mustard, and marbled rye. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
American Hero Sandwich
Roast beef, ham, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato and hero. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Italian Hero Sandwich
Ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, and oil and vinegar. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Shaved beef grilled with onions, and peppers, and smothered with cheese on a hero. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Pub Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheddar, honey mustard, BBQ sauce, and pretzel bun. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, bacon, swiss, lettuce, tomato, yellow BBQ sauce, and brioche roll. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken, peppers, onion, jack, cheddar cheese, and grilled tortilla. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Southern Italian Wrap
Ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar and mustard. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Classic Blt Sandwich
Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato toast. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Signature Chicken Cutlet Hero
Chicken cutlets, BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and hero. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Classic Gyro Sandwich
Beef or lamb broiled, tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion and pita. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich
Grilled chicken marinated tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pita. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Turkey Club Sandwich
Oven gold turkey bacon, lettuce, and tomato triple stacked on toast. Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Classic Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Our sandwiches are made exclusively with boar's head cold cuts and or the very highest quality ingredients available and include a side of macaroni, potato salad, or cole slaw, and a pickle wedge.
Boars Head Cold Cut Sandwiches
Oven Gold Turkey Sandwich
Deluxe Ham Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Bologna Sandwich
Genoa Salami Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich
American Cheese Sandwich
Swiss Cheese, Provolone Cheese, and Muenster Cheese Sandwich
Cheddar Cheese Sandwich
Salad Sandwiches
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Fresh Egg Salad Sandwich
Smoked White Fish Salad Sandwich
Fresh Salads
House Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, cucumbers, green peppers, tomatoes, and carrots.
Greek Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, feta cheese, black olives, Bermuda onion, red and green peppers, tomatoes, and cucumber.
Chef Salad
Turkey, ham provolone, mixed greens, hard-boiled eggs, and tomatoes.
Signature Salad With Grilled Chicken
Grilled chicken, fresh romaine, Parmesan, and croutons.
Paninis and Wraps
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken, ham, and swiss.
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo chicken, cheddar bean, lettuce, tomato, and ranch.
Sides
Bacon
Sausage
Ham
Fries and Waffle Fries
Grilled Chicken or Cutlet
Pickle
Cheese Fries
Home Fries
Vegetarian/Vegan Suggestions
The Greek Inspiration
Red roasted peppers, cucumber, pepperoni, kalamata olives, radish, tomatoes, red onions, and feta cheese with tzatziki sauce (optional).
The Cardoon Bomber
Red roasted peppers, spinach, fresh mozzarella cheese, salt and pepper, and basil pesto spread.
The Hummus Hummer
Hummus, cucumber, tomato, red onion swiss cheese, and cheddar cheese.
The Vegan Frenchie
Sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, and sauteed spinach with tofu spread.
The Sweet Sensational
Avocado, apple slices, spinach, honey mustard, salt and pepper. On a bagel, roll, white, wheat, rye bread, wrap or hero. Served with 2 pickle spears.
Fruit Smoothies And Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Fruit Smoothies
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Bagels
Bagel with plain cream cheese
bagel with butter
One Bagel
dozen bagels
choose 12 bagels
Bagel with flavored cream cheese
choose a bagel and flavor
bagel with cream cheese and lox
beverages
Snapple 16 oz
choose from peach, raspberry tea, lemon tea, apple
Tropicana 12 oz
Choose from pulp or no pulp
small hot coffee
medium hot coffee
large hot coffee
small ice coffee
medium ice coffee
large ice coffee
20 oz soda
choose flavor coke, Diet Coke, Pepsi, diet Pepsi, ginger ale
Gatorade
choose from flavors fruit punch, lemon-lime, orange
Monster
redbull 8 oz
spreads and salads by pound
1/2 lb butter
1/2 lb plain cream cheese
1/2 lb flavored cream cheese
1/2 lb lox spread
1/2 lb tuna salad
1/2 lb chicken salad
1/2 lb egg salad
1/2 lb egg white spinach salad
1/2 lb macaroni salad
1/2 lb potato salad
1/2 lb coleslaw salad
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Best bagels in the town. I had other day egg sandwich and it was so delicious. I definitely recommended. Customer service is best. I believe her name is dazy helped me that day made my lunch so good and fast.
July 2025
Clean and very fast! Had a sunflower seed bagel with BEC and was very content. Great selection of drinks and snacks. My one gripe was after eating, I took my garbage and bag of chips (already paid for with my original order) and went to buy another drink, the woman wrung up my juice as $3.25 and I gave her $20.25. She quickly gave me $12 in change. I walked out and quickly checked my change to see it was clearly missing $5. I went in and told the cashier. She asked how I paid...
May 2025
BEST BAGEL "DELI" IN AREA .
FRESH FOOD, POLITE STAFF.
LARGE VARITY OF CHICKEN SALDS PLUS BURGER PLATTERS AS WELL.
FRESH MADE SALADS AND THE BEST HOME FRIES ANYWHERE !!!
April 2025
You May Also Like
Sayville Bait & Tackle - 220 N Main St
![]()
Pubs, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar
TOA Asian Fusion (Sayville) - 239 N Main St
![]()
Asian Fusion, Sushi Bar, Chinese, Vegan, Vegetarian
Ramen Ramen - 185 N Main St
![]()
Ramen, Chinese, Gluten-Free