Restaurants in Sayville

Best Restaurants in Sayville

The Barbeque King 371 Lakeland Ave, Sayville Barbeque • $$$

“What a pleasure to be able to enjoy our own party from start to finish! Keith was a pleasure to work with planning the event and his staff were absolutely amazing from set up, preparation serving and clean up! The abundance of delicious food and amazing selection made the party! Everyone was asking “who are these guys I need their number!” We cannot express our happiness enough and look forward to our next event with them! Thank you Keith and crew!”

5 Superb207 Reviews
Redefine Meals 223 N Main St, Sayville Health Food • $

Customers` Favorites

Honey Garlic Chicken w Mac \u0026 Cheese
Gluten-Free Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Grass-Fed Burger Bowl
Hibachi Chicken Bowl

“I love the dinners they so good and so easy I willy do not like to cook so they are so good and the staff are great I get so excited when new ones come out”

5 Superb87 Reviews
Brunch Sayville 32 Foster Ave, Sayville Cafe • $$

Customers` Favorites

Morning Potatoes
Scrambled Eggs
Drip Coffee

“Excellent spot for awesome comfort food with a flare and the best espresso and lattes . Food was delicious. The atmosphere was like going to grandma‘s house for brunch excellent portions and if you leave hungry, it’s your own fault. I highly recommend a spot. ✨🤙🏼”

4.8 Superb104 Reviews

“Ryan and her staff are excellent at their jobs. They know every cat and all their traits and behaviors. Everyone is extremely kind and attentive in answering any questions one might have. And we had a lot. They made adopting our girls easy and stress free for the cats.”

4.7 Superb236 Reviews
Metros on Main 60 W Main St, Sayville American • $$

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp in Garlic Sauce
Coconut Shrimp
Chicken Piard
Baby Clam Pie
Regular Pie
Margherita
Calamari
Baby Clam Bar Pie
Baked Clams 12
Grilled Salmon

“A must go to you will not be disappointed!!!!”

4.7 Superb79 Reviews
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe 45 Foster Ave, Sayville American • $$

Customers` Favorites

Sauerbraten
Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Bruschetta
Scallops
Chicken Panzanella
Chocolate Lava Cake
Pretzel Bites
Chicken Jules
BBQ Peirogies

“My new favorite restaurant! Everything is delicious and the staff is incredible.”

4.5 Superb313 Reviews
Sayville Sandwich 291 W Main St #2543, Sayville Sandwich Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Bunk Specialty
Flaming Arrow
Hungry Man
Bunger

“Great food, amazing lunch specials, and the best iced tea and spices in town”

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
Parlor House Grill 298 W Main St, Sayville American • $$

Customers` Favorites

Mashed Potatoes
Greek Salad
Chicken Marsala
French Dip
Coconut Shrimp
Fish and Chips
Eggplant Chips
Chicken Wings
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Seafood Macaroni

“The food is always fresh and deliciously prepared. Staff and owners are very friendly and accomodating for dietary restrictions (gluten free). Good bar too.”

4.5 Superb199 Reviews
The Greenery 289 Railroad Ave, Sayville Health Food • $

Customers` Favorites

The Greenery
Nourishing Bowl
Chicken Ceasar
Veghead Bowl

“You need to open up at least 20 more stores on Long Island because your food is amazing. Finally a place that understands how to pair herbs and veggies together in a way where they actually taste good. I am obsessed!!!”

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
Friendly's 210 County Rd 85, Sayville American • $

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Hamburger
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Little Kids' Cheesywich with Apple Slices or Your Choice of Side
Ice Cream Sundaes
Friend-Z
Jim Dandy
Turkey blt
French Fries
Munchie Mania

“good burger. clean. friendly. nobody annoyed me. that's a miracle”

4.4 Superb254 Reviews
Butera's 100 S Main St, Sayville Italian • $$

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Tiramisu
Cutlet
Chicken Parmigiana
Seafood
Cheesecake
Mixed Salad
Bread Basket
Broccoli Rabe
Veal Parmesan

“Friendly service and delicious food.”

4.1 Good444 Reviews
The Sayville Inn 199 Middle Rd, Sayville Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup
Hamburger Swiss English Muffin and Fries
Middle Road Burger
Cajun Chicken
Calamari

“Nice spot. Quaint, good food, lovely staff… attended some great Sayville reunions here…. Really really wish you were open for lunch.”

4.5 Superb135 Reviews
Five Points Cafe 1 N Main St, Sayville Bar & Grill • $$

Customers` Favorites

Waffle Fries
Burgers
Hamburger
Veggie Burger
Pulled Pork Sandwich
French Fries
Steak Sandwich
Parmesan Crusted Chicken Sandwich w Mac N Cheese
Fiesta Bowl
Cali Burger

“Food was great and our waitress Chloe was wonderful”

4.4 Superb235 Reviews
Ramen Ramen 185 N Main St, Sayville Ramen • $

Customers` Favorites

Sauce
Spring Roll
Pork Gyoza
Original Ramen Add Triple Egg Double Noodles and Chicken Teriyaki
White Rice Bowl Add Korean Beef Chicken Teriyaki and Broccoli
California Rice Bowl Add Chicken Teriyaki and Broccoli
Original Ramen Add Pork Belly and Baby Bok Choy
California Rice Bowl Add Korean Beef
Fried Rice Add Chicken Teriyaki
Noodle Soup Yaki Soba Noddle

“After having tried a majority of the Asian restaurants on Long Island, I can confidently declare that Ramen Ramen has achieved something extraordinary. Tonight's takeout order was nothing short of spectacular. The fried rice with Korean beef and baby bok choy was a delight – each grain perfectly seasoned and tender, elevated by fluffy scrambled eggs and aromatic fresh shallots. The Korean beef, glazed in a sublime sweet and savory marinade, paired beautifully with crisp baby bok choy that retained its vibrant color and satisfying crunch. The bulgogi beef bao buns were incredible. These pillowy-soft steamed buns cradled succulent beef, crisp lettuce, and their signature sauce that creates an addictive harmony of flavors. Each bite delivered layers of texture and taste that left me craving more. The service was impeccable – warm, yet professional, and clearly passionate about their craft. Sayville has found its culinary gem. This isn't just Asian food; it's an authentic, expertly executed experience that rivals the finest establishments anywhere; I couldn't recommend this restaurant enough.”

4.4 Superb100 Reviews
Cherry Grove Pizza 179 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove Pizza • $$

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knot Slices
Garlic Knot
Siciliano Cheese Pizza Slice
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Garlic Knots Pizza Slice
Meatball
Lasagna

“Best pizza and service ever. And best on Long Island.”

4.4 Superb111 Reviews

More Restaurants in Sayville

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen 4836 Sunrise Hwy, Sayville Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

blt
-
Blueberry Scone
Giddy Up Sandwich
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Vegan Chicken Wrap
House Salad
Almond Croissant
Maple Bacon Toast
Fresh Mozz & Pesto

“The Dark Horse has a chill environment and an amazing staff the food and coffee was delicious! I highly recommend this cool relaxing spot!!!”

4.8 Superb171 Reviews
sweetFrog 5640-35 Sunrise Hwy, Sayville Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt
1 Oz Caramel Sea Salt Gelato
Pineapple Raspberry Dole
1 Oz Blue Cotton Candy
Chocolate Hazelnut
Acai Bowl

“Delicious and the best toppings!!! Always a special time with my granddaughter!🍨”

4.4 Superb123 Reviews
Blackbirds' Grille 553 Old Montauk Hwy, Sayville Bar & Grill • $$

Customers` Favorites

Sauce
Steak Sandwich
Gator Bites
Fried Green Tomatoes
Goat Cheese Salad
At the Bar
Fish Tacos
Baked Clams
Fried Pickles
Stuffed Shrimp

“This place just does it right! We keep stopping in and diving deeper into the menu and trying different things, we love all of them. Our 11 month old was with us this weekend and our server was awesome with him as well. Five stars for the food, the staff, the menu, the beer choices, and the local watering hole type of vibe the whole atmosphere has!”

4.3 Superb301 Reviews
Station Pub 3 Lakeland Ave, Sayville Bar • $

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings
Bone in Wings
Hot Pretzel
Quesadillas

“What can i say is this is a friendly local pub with great people inside . Steve is a wonderful gentleman who is loved by his patrons simply because he cares about you ❤️.Kim behind the bar is a warm and charming lady who again makes you feel at home.I recommend this place based on the people who patronize the place and people who work there.Karoke is the bomb every Thursday night you wont be disappointed !!!!!!”

4.6 Superb75 Reviews
Portly Villager 261 W Main St, Sayville Bar • $$

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Macaroni Salad
Roasted Peppers Sun-Dried Tomatoes Guacamole Spread
New England Clam Chowder
Cuban Sandwich
Corn Fritters
Wings
Soup

“Had a great time and the bartender Jason was friendly! Will definitely be back again!”

4.4 Superb122 Reviews
Sayville Athletic Club 209 Railroad Ave, Sayville Sports Bar • $

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Sandwich
All-Star Brisket Sandwich
The Classic

“A true local sports bar with small-town vibes, cold beers, and TVs always tuned to the game — but don’t let the no-frills atmosphere fool you. This might be the best pub food on Long Island, and that’s a hill worth dying on.

The brisket sandwich is smoky and stacked, the Philly cheesesteak hits all the greasy, glorious notes you want… but let’s be clear: the pastrami sandwich is the main event. It’s piled high, ridiculously flavorful, and good enough to make you forget whatever team you’re rooting for is probably losing.

Come hungry, leave happy, and don’t expect anything fancy — just great food, strong local energy, and zero pretension. This is the kind of place that turns first-timers into regulars.”

4.4 Superb76 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Baked Ziti
Salad with Chicken Cutlet
Grandma Pizza
White Pizza
Caesar Salad
Garlic Knots
Baked Ravioli
Fried Calamari
Stuffed Shells
Penne Alla Vodka Pizza

“Absolutely love this place. Definitely the best pizza in town!”

4.3 Superb151 Reviews
Cornucopia Health Foods 35 N Main St, Sayville Health Food • $$$

“I moved out of the area for a few years and recently moved back. Cornucopia was one of my first stops. I missed the staff and the awesome food they make so much. Chicken Waldorf Salad and a Banana Date Smoothie were of course my first order of business. Both absolute must haves! There was a girl named Tina who used to work there, who made a summer specialty smoothie called Tina Colada. Obviously it had no liquor (☹️), but if you closed your eyes, you’d swear you were sipping it on a beach in Jamaica! It was so good! Wish they’d put it back on the menu. I was sorry to see that Sweet Soul Bakery had closed, because their brownies and homemade soups were to die for. But a new bakery makes a mini vegan coffee cake, mini vegan cheesecake, and mini vegan carrot cake - all very good! The Cole slaw is still awesome, and I highly recommend the Buffalo cauliflower!!!”

4.3 Superb129 Reviews
Koi Sushi 136 W Main St, Sayville Asian Fusion • $$

Customers` Favorites

L Sashimi Special
Sashimi Deluxe 18
Sushi Rolls
Miso Soup
Salad

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I recently had the pleasure of dining at this phenomenal Asian fusion restaurant, and it exceeded all of my expectations in every way possible. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a memorable culinary journey. The restaurant's ambiance was a perfect blend of modern sophistication and a warm, inviting atmosphere. The decor was tastefully done, creating a cozy yet upscale setting that was ideal for a special night out. Now, let's talk about the food. Wow! The Asian fusion menu was a delightful fusion of flavors and cultures, and every dish we ordered was a masterpiece. From sushi tacos that tantalized our taste buds with their innovative combinations to perfectly executed traditional dishes with a modern twist, each plate was a work of art. It's evident that the chefs here are true culinary artists who take immense pride in their craft. The extensive drink menu perfectly complemented the food. The cocktail selection was creative, and I was particularly impressed with their signature drinks that paired flawlessly with the diverse flavors of the dishes. What truly sets this restaurant apart, though, is the exceptional service. The staff was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, and their recommendations were spot-on. They were attentive without being intrusive, making us feel like valued guests throughout our dining experience. And let's not forget about dessert! The sweet offerings were the perfect ending to our meal. I can't stop thinking about the fusion-inspired desserts that left us craving for more. In conclusion, this Asian fusion restaurant is a culinary gem that should not be missed. It offers an extraordinary dining experience with its impeccable food, superb service, and stylish ambiance. Whether you're an adventurous foodie or simply looking for a fantastic meal, this restaurant has it all. Five stars are well-deserved, and I can't wait to return to explore more of their tantalizing menu!”

3.8 Good115 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knot
Grandma Pie
Buffalo Chicken
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Grandma Vodka Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
Vegan Sicilian
Vegan Eggplant
Vegan Regular
Regular Pizza

“Excellent service and slice! Fresh, hot and ready immediately. Clean and plenty of seating.”

4.2 Good241 Reviews

“So So So yummy! Just stopped by with our girls and one of our daughter’s friends and this hit the spot (a little before dinner treat 😉) for us all!! Between the 7 of us, we got lots of different flavors and every single one was delicious. Not only is this place so sweet, adorable and quaint, the two girls working were so so kind and accommodating. I know for sure this will be one of our favorite places to come for a sweet & yummy treat throughout the summer!! 😋☀️”

4.3 Superb23 Reviews
Aegean Cafe 35 N Main St, Sayville Greek • $$

Customers` Favorites

Fried Zucchini
Gyro Sandwich
Gyro Meat
Hummus
Greek Salad w Lamb Shwarma Side
Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich
Pita Melt with Chicken
French Fries
Gyro Dinner
Baklava

“Been coming here for years. The food is consistently good and the waitresses are all warm and welcoming.”

4.2 Good222 Reviews
Sayville Bean Coffee House 59 W Main St, Sayville Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwiches
Original Crumb Cake
Rainbow Cookie
Scones

“Awesome place to chill and get some work done. Great coffee, as always.”

4.2 Good81 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Local Burger
Cajun Fries
Cookies
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Side Honey Mustard
Skin on Fries
Cannonball
Side BBQ

“The burgers are to die for!”

4.2 Good58 Reviews
Jade Garden 29 N Main St, Sayville Chinese • $

Customers` Favorites

Broccoli
Wonton Soup
Beef with Garlic Sauce
Roast Pork Fried Rice
Sesame Chicken
Egg Roll
Dumpling

“I have ate at a couple of Chinese restaurants in the area. But this restaurant tops all the rest. The food tastes fresh. Their customer service is excellent. I moved out of the area but I still drive the distance for good Chinese food.😋🫶🏽”

4.1 Good71 Reviews

“I am always happy when my train and ferry schedule give me a little time to eat here. I have to have their burger it’s grilled perfectly. It’s just so old-school burger, fries, ranch dressing and a cranberry and vodka and I’m ready to start my weekend. I love Heather. She has been there as long as I can remember and yesterday when I asked to take a picture with her, she said that was the first time anyone had ever asked her for one”

4.1 Good36 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Spinach Pinwheel
Chicken Caprese
Slice of Pizza
Grandma Slice
2 Liter

“A must go to you will not be disappointed!!!!”

4.1 Good157 Reviews
The Cull House 75 Terry St, Sayville Seafood • $$

Customers` Favorites

Scallops
New England Clam Chowder
Fish and Chips
Cull House Lobster Clam Bake GF
Key Lime Mousse
Baked Clams
Fish & Chips
Basket Shrimp
Clams Casino
Shrimp Tacos

“Food is always delicious !”

4.1 Good275 Reviews

“great severice and good food”

4 Good47 Reviews
Fritzsche's Bakery 56 W Main St, Sayville Bakery • $

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Buns and Pastries

“I used Fritzsche's as the baker for my wedding cake and they were fantastic to work with! The cake was so delicious and gorgeously decorated. It had 3 tiers; 2 vanilla cake tiers with strawberry mousse and 1 chocolate cake tier with chocolate mousse, with a buttercream frosting on the outside of it. All of our guests loved the cake and everyone was asking who our baker was. I'm so happy we decided to go with my hometown's baker as our wedding cake baker! Thanks so much!”

4 Good94 Reviews
Beijing Kitchen 291-I W Main St, Sayville Chinese • $

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Chicken
Roast Pork Lo Mein
Wonton Soup
Dumplings

“My first visit today for their General Tso lunch special, and the food is delicious!!!!
Very nice staff as well! I will be back soon and often! Thank you!”

4 Good96 Reviews
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville) 239 N Main St, Sayville Asian Fusion • $$

Customers` Favorites

Poke Bowl
Spicy Tuna Roll
Pineapple Fried Rice
Pad Thai
California Roll
Miso Soup
Crispy Rice Spicy Tuna
Wonton Soup
Jumbo Shrimp Teriyaki
Kani Salad

“I’ve been coming here for years, always loved the food & service. Tonight i tried the tuna tataki, it’s the best I’ve ever had. Thats the dish that introduced me to sushi a decade ago, and tonight was the best I’ve ever had!”

4 Good224 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices 153 Main St, Sayville Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Triple Choc Ralphie Mint Madness Cake Batter
Birthday Cake
Strawberry
Quart Ice
Pint Ice
Sundaes
Creme

“Love love love Ralph's! All of them. This location had great staff, and service.
Hands down the BEST softserve. And if you've never had Italian ices, let this be the place you try them. So many flavor options, made so smooth and delicious.
And absolutely go for Twister tuesday - buy one get one free 🥳”

3.8 Good63 Reviews
Starbucks Coffee Company 90 W Main St, Sayville Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

Double-Smoked Bacon Cheddar & Egg Sandwich

“Mothersday 2025. Went into the starbucks for the 1st time ever. I have only ever been through the drive-through on a rare weekend morning with my wife. When it was my turn at the counter, The guy asked me if I’m having a good day and I showed him a picture of my wife and said do you know this woman and he said yes and I said yes I am having a good day and then I said do you know her order and he said yes and I said now I’m having an even better day And then he noted. He should probably leave out the espresso shot as it’s the weekend. Turns out he mailed that too five stars.

Happy Mother’s Day”

3.8 Good119 Reviews
Hot Bagels DeLox 372 N Main St, Sayville Bagels • $

Customers` Favorites

Bagels
2 Eggs with Meat and Cheese on a Bagel Roll
Sliced Lox and Cream Cheese Bagel
Hungry Man on a Bagel Roll
Buttered Bagel
Linzer Tart
Rugelach

“I ordered egg salad, lox spread and scallion cream cheese with a dozen bagels for the office. Everything was delicious and fresh. The new owner Sabira is so friendly and really makes sure you are being taken care of. The bagel store is so clean and they are really organized. We are so happy to have such a great place for bagels in town!!”

3.8 Good149 Reviews
Texas Taco 21 N Main St, Sayville Mexican • $

Customers` Favorites

Texas Taco
Likely These Are Two Fish Tacos
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Homemade Chips with Salsa
Black Bean Burrito
Texas Quesadilla
Ground Beef Taco
Chips and Salsa
Fire Island Taco
Shrimp Burrito

“I did Texas Taco in Sayville and jad their food truck the summer prior to COVID hit and it was great! They pulled right up to house for a few hours, you can pick from different plan options and prices. If I remember correctly I think I picked an option that had up to 40 people even though I had 30 to be safe incase anyone else extra stopped by. We picked out some menu items with the owner ahead of time to be served. We set a time slot( thenowner came with truck like an hour early to prep food and get ready ahead if my start time and each guest was able to go back and forth to the truck as many times as they wanted within the few hours the truck was hired to be here. Great service( the owner and one other guy worked the truck the whole time they were here) everything made to order fresh and very good. Nothing but compliments from all my guests that day. I tipped at end and even tho I did a final tip some guests were so impressed a few threw them a few bucks during one of their many trips to the truck in my driveway that day too, even though i said I tipped they were so satisfied they wanted to top a few dollars too. It was deeelish!”

3.6 Good167 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

blt Grilled Cheese
Blueberry Parfait
Hungry Man Hero

“Great service great food!
I was sick in bed and they don’t normally do delivery but they made a exception for me. I really really appreciate you guys. Thank you”

3.6 Good127 Reviews