32 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sayville

Friendly's American • $
210 County Rd 85, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Little Kids' Cheesywich with Apple Slices or Your Choice of Side
Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup
Bacon Mac N Cheese Burger
Large Chocolate Fribble
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Cheese Skirt Burger
Crispy Chicken Salad
Ice Cream Sundaes
Munchie Mania
Turkey blt

“Honestly this Friendly’s location is my favorite they always make the food fresh and everybody it’s always friendly. I ordered three kids meals and they were made with such care. I will certainly be coming back to this location. Thank you and have a good night. I’ll see you soon. Again, good night sleep well sleep well. I’ll see you again soon. Good night again. See you soon. OK? Good night!! What are you still doing up?“

4.1 Good70 Reviews
sweetFrog Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
5640-35 Sunrise Hwy, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Raspberry Dole
Frozen Yogurt

“Awesome yogurt and toppings! I came here almost every night when I was younger, and I still want to come here. I was here last in June, and ate their yogurt that tasted very delicious. However, I think they should renovate the eatery, it’s a little dirty and old, but overall it’s very nice!“

4.1 Good25 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $$
153 Main St, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Triple Choc Ralphie Mint Madness Cake Batter
Birthday Cake
Strawberry
Quart Ice
Pint Ice
Sundaes
Creme

“They are closed during winter, makes sense. But, food is decent for a nice cold treat. But, wish ley had more dining tables outside!Dietary restrictions: Def don't recommend if you're lactose intolerant or can't have milk, dairy.Parking: Behind or right out front!Kid-friendliness: Kids LOVE IT, especially the ages of 11-18 and 6-9.“

4 Good16 Reviews

4
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$
25 Montauk Hwy, Sayville

“Solid Carvel location. The man behind the counter was helpful and friendly to both me and my daughter. The ice cream was great. We came to pick up some prepared sundaes for a party this past weekend and they were tasty. I love that they had a few designs to choose from.“

3.8 Good8 Reviews
Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen & Space Ice Cream Shop • $$
370 Lake Ave, St James - 10.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mini Mick-Wich Ice Cream Sandwich
Topping - Crushed Waffle Cone
Topping - Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Overload
Shakes & Floats
Icecream Cakes
Cookies 'Cream
Sorbets

“Great venue for a kids party! The staff are very helpful and kind, making the experience easy for the parents. I’d recommend Mikey’s for any parent looking to do a party for up to 15 kids. The fact they have an outdoor area is great for letting the kids run off their sugar rush after the party is over. Thanks to the team.“

4.8 Superb83 Reviews
Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
2229 Rte 112, Coram - 10.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chunky Monkey Special Swirl
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Ice Cream Swirl
Toasted Coconut
Fruity Pebbles
Cookie Monster
Cocoa Pebbles
Rice Krispies
Silly Rabbit
Strawberry

“Patrick is such an amazing employee and so attentive! He literally stopped everything to take care of what I wanted when my ice cream cone fell, instead of saying “too bad” he made me another cone free of charge! Literally I love this store and their employees! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND “

4.8 Superb64 Reviews
Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen Ice Cream Shop • $
1315 Middle Country Rd Ste 5, Centereach - 8.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Cookie & Cookies and Dream
Chocolate Chips Dark Choc Sauce
Chocolate Sprinkles Hot Caramel
Large Waffle Cone
Campfire S'Mores
Root Beer Float
Dream Ice Cream
Cherry Amaretto
Caramel Crunch
Whipped Cream

“Fantastic ice cream spot with truly authentic, homemade ice cream, and flavors that I guarantee you have never seen or heard of before.Owner was kind enough to let us sample several options. Kids were happy, we were happy, and we will most definitely be coming back. Be sure to check this place out!“

4.6 Superb94 Reviews
Cosmos Burgers Creamery Hamburger • $
876 Connetquot Ave, Islip Terrace - 5.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hard Ice Cream Milky Way Shakes
Galactic Grilled Cheese
Soft Ice Cream Small
Small Hard Ice Cream
Hard Ice Cream Pint
Small Soft Ice Cream
Over the Moon Fries
Large Cosmic Shake
Cosmic Swirl Pint
Pickles Jalapenos

“When it comes to eating, this place has that Sonic Drive-In/Friendly's vibe; the food (burgers, fries, chicken, etc.) may not be something to write home about (much of it is "alright" at best) but the desserts (ice cream, shakes, malts, floats, etc.) is where the menu truly shines! Each ice cream concoction (including one of my faves, Rocky Road) is stuffed to the brim with mix-ins and the shakes are just the right kind of thickness.The girls who served my friends and I were very friendly with warm smiles and polite suggestions to get the most out of our eating experience. They even let me sample a flavor of their ice cream (after which I knew I was getting dessert with my meal!) so I knew what I was in for.The ambiance has that charming Pizza Planet vibe to it (If you've seen the movie "Toy Story" you get it!) filled with outer space decor and space-themed names for the menu items making it very family-friendly. If it had an arcade (or at least just a few cabinets), that would be pretty cool! (I'm not knocking points off for that one btw!)The place is definitely a good place for quality desserts and customer experience. As for lunch or dinner, it's good but I'm pretty sure your local diner may satisfy you a bit more. Overall, I highly recommend anyone to give Cosmos a visit!Kid-friendliness: The outer-space decor screams kid-friendliness and so does the customer service of the employees.“

4.7 Superb56 Reviews
Cafe Lahooti Bubble Tea • $
96 E Main St, Village of the Branch - 10 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate
Cookies & Cream
Smores

“I have tried alot of bubble tea places and this one is REALLY good! My friends and I got the Rose Milk Tea, Taro, and Earl Grey Milk Tea. The Rose & Earl grey were the best in my opinion! The boba was also really well made, soft and chewy. Service was great as well! Overall a great place for bubble tea, I will be coming back soon!!“

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Strong Island Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 8.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan
Waffle Cone
Strawberry

“They serve sundaes, cakes, shakes, ice cream and so much more. It is family owned and operated and is a very easy going and laid back place. They make you feel like family and the ice cream is to die for. It definitely tastes homemade. $8 for 2 scoops $5 for 1 “

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $
1370 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 8.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Ice Cream
Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy
Italian Ice
Hot Fudge
Brownie

“This is our favorite icecream and ices place to go! The variety is great. Servers are kind and cost is good . The only 'bad' thing I can say about this place is they close in the winter months.Vegetarian options: All water based ices are vegan“

4.7 Superb36 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices Of Smithtown Ice Cream Shop • $$
316 Maple Ave, Smithtown - 9.15 miles

“My boyfriend & i went to this ralph’s and now we can confidently say this will be the only ralph’s we go to. John, the extremely nice & attentive owner, was the sweetest person we have ever met. he had been closed for an hour and still gave our order to us with a huge smile and great conversation. we were extremely apologetic since we came so late but he didn’t care, he talked to us for 10 minutes and made our day brighter. we love ralph’s but we love this ralph’s A LOT!! his staff is amazing and we couldn’t help but tip them for there amazing work.sincerely danielle & mike“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $
623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.12 miles

“There are different kinds of ice cream to get here. I got the hard ice cream to try and I really enjoyed the consistency and the taste. The mint chocolate chip tastes really good. It does not taste toothpastey at all which i enjoy a lot! It tastes very good. I also tried the coffee hard ice cream and it was very flavorful. It had a strong coffee flavor which I liked. I am excited to try new flavors here and new ice cream types. The workers are very kind as well which is memorable.“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Pam's Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
195 Carleton Ave, East Islip - 5.76 miles

“This place was pretty good. It could definitely use some tidying up, but other than that the ice cream was amazing. It was a really good spot for us to visit while we were visiting Long Island. The service was great and the ambience of the ice cream shop was definitely old school. we will definitely be back again when visiting the area.“

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
Supreme Salads Health Food • $
2460 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook - 9.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Plant Based Chocolate Protein Shake
Build Your Own Salad
Mediterranean Salad
Mediterranean Wrap
Grilled Chicken
Large Salad
BYO Panini
Southwest

“I just ordered from this place, I used to go to proportions all the time to get my salads, or meals before this place came around. I’m not too sure if they changed things around or if they updated the place but it’s exactly like proportions! The salads were absolutely delicious, and the size portions were massive! Can’t get any better than this place, it’s a little costly but it’s worth it for its size and quality! It’s super fresh, and I love how they give you a lot of options when it comes to toppings making it gluten free, and vegan friendly!I highly recommend!“

4.3 Superb55 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
50 Montauk Hwy, East Islip - 5.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

2 Scoop Sundae Nuts over Carmel and Vienna Mocha Chunk with Carmel Syrup and Whipped Cream
Scoop of Nuts over Carmel with Carmel Syrup Whipped Cream and a Cherry
Hunka Chunka Peanut Butter Cup Sundae with Chocolate Lava Cake
Grilled Cheese and Waffle Fries
Hunka Chunka PB Fudge Sundae
Honey BBQ Chicken Super Melt
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Crispy Chicken Salad
Royal Banana Split

“Waitress was really nice and accommodating.The food came out pretty fast.But even without extra jalapeños and BBQ sauce it was pretty bland.Think most of the food is from frozen so it's ok for the price. But my the kids Mac and cheese was dry and had no real cheese or flavor.The blackberry fribble was great I'm lactose intolerant and I suffered for it but I finished it haha.Overall great for dessert. But even with the kids menu and options, the food is lacking. Also the Mac and cheese bites are basically little mozzarella Nugs. Not Mac and cheese!Kid-friendliness: Great options for kids. But taste isn't great. I have a picky Eater she's eat plain foods but even hers was too bland. Dry Mac and cheese with no cheese at all. Basically just yellow macaroni. She added water to it. And asked where the cheese was ?“

4.2 Good67 Reviews

17
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
290 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 5.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocochip Double Layer Chocolate Fudge
Birthday Cake

“I love all the ladies that work at this Carvel. They’re so nice whoever’s doing the hiring there is definitely choosing the best candidates for customer service. They always have a smile on their face or a suggestion for when I’m not sure what I wanna get.Parking: There is a parking lot to park in but if you happen to be there on a busy day, there is a side road and a gas station across the street that has plenty of parking that you are allowed to park on for free. There’s no restrictions. But I’ve never had an issue with parking.Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly! What kid wouldn’t love an ice cream shop plus they have like the sweetest staff that works there“

4.5 Superb24 Reviews

18
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$
680 Middle Country Rd, St James - 9.39 miles

“The staff here are all great people. The prices at Carvel are still good too! $7 and change for a large sundae with toppings. Hope this review gets people a raise. Always experience great service and the employees here deserve all the positive recognition they get.“

4.6 Superb19 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
2220 Rte 112, Coram - 10.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hunka Chunka PB Fudge Sundae
A Disaster of French Toast
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Ice Cream Sundaes
Honey BBQ Burger

“They are literally always so friendly when we go there! This time I had submitted a pickup order, and I was literally in and out in 30 seconds. Food is always good. Great place!Vegetarian options: My go-to is the veggie burger but there are other options as well!“

4.2 Good56 Reviews

20
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
2195 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 8.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“I ordered a custom cake for my brothers 16th birthday and it was amazing ! The woman who helped me was so friendly , and honest. When I told her I wanted black icing, she advised that black is difficult because it needs a bunch of different food coloring and doesn't taste good, so we ended up going with red. She really took her time to make sure we were on the same page and had everything correct. I was worried the picture would look tacky or blurry because its printed but it looked like it was drawn right on the cake. Definitely recommend this service !“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews

21
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
553 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Hauppauge - 9.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone

“I highly recommend this Carvel! Overall they are a great location. I have had 1 small issue and the owner reached out to me personally. I truly appreciate a owner that puts their customers first. The staff has always been super friendly and the store always looks clean. I will definitely be going back for many years to come.“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews
Coyles Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
509 Main St, Islip - 6.92 miles

“The town of islip is your typical Main Street. The best part is the very popular homemade ice cream shop. You name the flavor- they have it. Even mini ice cream Sunday’s. Seating was limited, the staff was friendly and the ice cream delish. ?“

4.3 Superb33 Reviews

23
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$$
400A Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone

“I started going to this location 2 years ago, for a while I thought that the man helping me was rude and hated his job but once I got him to open up I realized he is hysterical and isn’t much for talking haha. He packs the cones with whatever ice cream and topping your taste buds desire( you can tell this is his favorite part), the service is quick and the facility is clean- what more can you ask for! Give this location and it’s staff members a chance and you won’t be sorry!!“

4.4 Superb23 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $
54 W Main St, East Islip - 5.84 miles

“Always a nice time when I go with the family. So many options and the customer service is awesome. Only wish they would clean up the tables outside. They are old and rusty. And preferably get some that can withstand the elements. Sometimes prefer to go to the ronkonkoma location just to be able to sit down and enjoy without needing to rush back home because the the outdoor seating isn’t really clean.“

4.3 Superb23 Reviews
County Wide Ice Cream Distributors Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
1600 N Ocean Ave, Holtsville - 6.15 miles

“Love everything about this place. From the novelty ice cream to the high end tartufos and gelato. They also sell popular candy and some old school such as razzels. Sparklers , cotton candy. Its like reliving my childhood from the ice cream truck but less expensive. Friendly staff & owners. Highly recommend shopping here.“

4.8 Superb10 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
628 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.07 miles
4.2 Good20 Reviews
Bubble Waffle Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop •
52 N Country Rd, Smithtown - 10.03 miles

“There is nothing better than walking into an absolutely beautiful place that takes you a little bit outside this world we live in and provides the best in teas Ice cream and incredible coffees I am so glad they built this place it is warm inviting the staff is fantastic and if you can remember please tip well because these people work their butts off and they deserve it“

4 Good40 Reviews

28
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
386 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 6.45 miles

“I stopped in for ice cream, and my card kept getting declined, despite there being plenty of money on it. I kept asking the girls to scan the card at the top of the POS machine, and they kept telling me they cannot scan the card until the card was entered into the machine three times. I have never encountered this before.I really think there is a mistake, because the scan option was implemented to protect consumers from having to enter or swipe their cards at a POS machine. I never scan my card at retail establishments anymore; I always scan my card at the top of the machine, and my payment is always accepted. I am never told I need to enter my card three times before scanning.It ends up some lovely woman paid for my ice cream anyway, which I am highly appreciative of.“

3.9 Good62 Reviews
Swirls & Twirls Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
248 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 7.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt

“Honestly the best frozen yogurt and the best toppings anywhere! Employees are nice and courteous!!!Kid-friendliness: Always come here after my son and daughter's school concerts. Filled with parents and a lot of kids. The owner and the employees are super professional even with 30+ kids running around .“

4.1 Good20 Reviews
5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles Chicken • $
530 Medford Ave, Patchogue - 5.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Lamb over Rice with Salad and Sauce
Fried Chicken and Waffles
Philly Cheese Steak
Sweet Corn Nuggets
Chicken & Waffles
Side Pasta Salad
Onion Rings
Curly Fries
Quesadilla
Cole Slaw

“Good place service is professional lots of choices. The chicken is delicious. The waffles are freshly made as you order. They come in a paper box with syrup. They also give you some kind of red sauce for the chicken I didn't explore. The chicken didn't need anything, in my opinion. Perfect as is. The downside is parking, only two spots, and on a busy road, it's hard to get in. Finding an alternative and walking a few feet for this chicken is my answer. The cost was under $10 for three pieces and a waffle. They have been the for many years and directly across from KFC, so they are definitely doing something right. It's worth a try.“

3.9 Good58 Reviews
Blue Bean Cafe Coffee Shops • $$
52 N Country Rd, Smithtown - 10.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon and Egg Avocado Toast
Ultimate Avocado Toast
Regular Brewed Coffee
Blue Bean Burger
Drip Coffee
Mocha Latte

“COFFEE SO STRONG YOU’LL BE FUELED ALL DAY. Single origin, roasted in house using a zero emission coffee roaster. OMG All the bells and whistles a cafe could have, they have. Love the friendly and knowledgeable baristas. Quick and efficient service. Also an amazing place to work all day. Bathrooms are clean and well decorated. They open early and close late. The best in SMITHTOWN!! A must visit.“

3.9 Good55 Reviews

32
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
217 E Main St, Patchogue - 4.37 miles

“A great ice cream ?? parlor that's open year round nice service smells good and they have every flavor you want..So many stores are limited Carvel has what other stores don't..Plus the prices aren't that bad considering how often do we really go for ice cream. The shopping center this Carvel is in is also very busy has lots of stores.“

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Loading...
map Map