Butera's

100 S Main St, Sayville
(631) 563-0805

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maggie

My husband and I enjoyed celebrating our anniversary with dinner and it was just wonderful! The staff were exceptional, the food was divine, and we enjoyed a fine chilled bottle of wine with our meal. We're already looking to do a double date with our friends soon. The family style portions are generous and prefect for a group to enjoy. Thank you for making our special night that much more lovely!

kathleen

Everything was good.very bright lighting for a Saturday nite. It was also especially warm. Paul off that day. He was missed

Frances

Good food nice atmosphere. Chairs are a bit uncomfortable. The service was adequate it took a long time for things to arrive. It is to be expected on a busy Saturday evening. The food could have been served hotter. All in all a great place for dinner. It's family style.

Michael Carrington

Great family-style restaurant!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane

My family and I have haven't been to Butera's in a while, so we decided to go for my birthday. I had made a reservation for 6 and we were promptly seated. Our waitress, Liz, arrived promptly and took our drink orders. She was friendly and smiling and made us feel very welcome. The food came out expeditiously, was hot and very good. I have no complaints about the service or the food, the restaurant itself is another story. Our table seemed to have pad under the tablecloth which made bottles of beer very tippy. The vent above our heads was thick with dust and I was happy I didn't see it until the end of our meal. The ladies room looked like it could be from a gas station. My conclusion is, the food was great, service was on point, but the restaurant itself needs an overhaul. I would absolutely eat there again and hope that maybe, the interior got an upgrade from my last visit.

Michele Dussault

Huge portions even for the individual sizes. Service was great and the food was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michele

Our meal was outstanding. My husband had the Seafood Risotto special and it was packed with delicious lobster, shrimp, calamari and more. I had the Veal Francese and it was amazing! We treated ourselves to tiramisu and the almond cake. Both made onsite and both worth the calories!!

Kimberly Hellmers

My family and I have been coming to Buteras for years and they are just the best. Jerry is the best manager, always goes above and beyond. Made my dad feel so special for his birthday this week. Thank you Jerry and Buteras team! Always friendly and delicious, we are lifetime fans <3

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimberly

The waitress was amazing the food was delicious the service was a little slow. I would definitely come back

Lisa E

Food was plentiful and delicious!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ben Flamio

Best Italian food on the island

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rosemary Gandolfo

Food was good for Family style.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kim

Service and food were outstanding! We did not feel rushed and were able to enjoy a nice family dinner together! Always a pleasure to dine at your restaurant.

Rich

I don't understand family size meals. And single price is 60% off. Portion size was adequate but should be at 50%. And don't nickel/dime over pasta and salad which are the cheapest things on an Italian menu.

William

Great service, incredible food, and very reasonably priced for the amount of food that we received. We will definitely return to eat here again.

Loading...