Main Street Diner

229 W Main St, Sayville
(631) 567-5376

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Francis Dipalo

My order; 2 eggs over easy, home fries and Link Sausage.My waitress brinks me Breakfast Sausage. I explained I ordered Link Sausage. She replied we don’t have that! I answered, but I have ordered it here a few times. She replied, we’re out of that!Then she came back to tell me I’ll take the sausage off the bill. I replied, it would have been nice if you told me they were out of it, maybe I would have ordered something else.She replied again telling me the Breakfast sausage are link sausage!I answered breakfast sausage are different!There home fries were just about warm temperature.Beware; I will never go back, or refer this diner to anyone!!!

Lij T

Friendly and courteous staff, fast service reasonable prices. Steak Pannini was excellent

Parking: The French fries were unusually delicious.Steak Pannini was very good.

Almudena Gómez

Amazing food and outstanding personnel. Thank you so much! Gracias.

BODHI

The white waitress who thinks she knows everything about Latin americans ran her mouth the entire time. Maybe it's just not my cup of tea, but it was in such an unfunny smoker-laugh kind of way.Breakfast was 2, maybe 3/5? Sausage was inedible, eggs had no fluff to them, and home fries were reheated/greasy. No wonder why places like Toast get away with charging $20 for eggs and bacon!

SMSC

Waited a very long time for our food and it was 8pm and not busy. After long wait we were told they didn't have French fries for the burger platter. No apologies for anything. Will not return.

CM

1st X here w my honey. We just happened to be driving & came across this diner with purple outside decor (looks like maybe lights up in pm?) While asking customers on the way out/us way in about this diner they said "we just come for the corn muffins a snack" see pics what we ordered...everything was delish! Waitress was right on point & great too. Would Definitely go again!MANAGEMENT: ONLY thing I said to staff as walked in was with it raining their tile floor (mats not big enough to edge) someone going to get hurt as women coming out said one them slipped.

Kashia Corley

i went there to pick up a to-go order nobody acknowledged me for over 15 minutes other people walked in after me they got set they got spoken to and then another guy came in after me and was there for it to go order he got acknowledged not until I said something was then hate to say that I was the only black person in this whole situation and I was the one that was ignored over 15 minutes I will spend my money somewhere else i left they can keep there food

jason trompeter

They really improved this place. Gave it a facelift. Very friendly waitstaff and accommodating. Good strong coffee!

Gwen Pidgeon

Gleaming clean floors and quaint country with a modern twist decor greet customers. Waitress was very professional, genuinely happy and welcomed us. We felt like valued customers. Food was served quickly and was prepared as per my special order.

David Mattera

Giving this 4 stars on the DINER Scale (not to be confused with "fine dining".They say you can judge a restaurant by its bathrooms. Well the bathrooms were spotless but the doorknobs on both restrooms were broken... It's a $12 fix ($6 per doorknob)... Just fix them.The cheeseburger deluxe was fine. Not "amazing" and not "terrible", and the coffee was "coffee". The staff were friendly and attentive.I can see this being a Great place for breakfast... But use the restroom before you arrive.

Phillip Alonso

Service good Food ok Price average

Stas Nick

Whatever you do don't order the chicken noodle soup because you might as well go to a supermarket buy a box of Lipton noodle soup in a packet boil some water and it will be the same.

Pasquale Fortunato

We’ve been coming here for years. Food is good but the day staff (with the exception of the Male waiter and the hostess) openly talk badly about customers right in front of other customers. We generally try to avoid the daytime hours because of this. We’re used to Deb and her amazing attitude! I’d get if it were a once in a while thing due to a bad customer but it’s every single time. Not every day can be a bad day.

arlene z

Same group of friends were at the diner a few weeks ago for breakfast. At that time the eggs were cold, bacon was like rubber and the sausage was dried out also. It was 9:30 in the morning so it should have been fresh. We decided to give it another chance. We asked the waitress how fresh the meats were and she assured us they’d be freshly made. Not! Same today. Canadian bacon, eggs, toast and sausage cold. Potatoes burnt and cold. We gave it a second chance and didn’t find it any better. We won’t be back.

Gabriel Aldana

Loved this place. Perfect lowkey diner in town to get your day trip or weekend started before hitting up Fire Island.

Loading...