Read the reviews and was a bit disappointed with the bagels.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Jonathan Sonnenberg
Bagels are OK nothing special. Very overpriced for how little cream cheese and/or lox you get.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Elizabeth McLaughlin
Extremely helpful, patient, and kind with amazing bagels :)
Nechemiah seltzer
Great sandwiches, not impressed that they don’t except Credit Cards, impressive
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Mordechai Michael Clapman
Sammy's Bagels offers a delightful experience with their delicious spicy tuna bagel. Despite the small size of the location, the inviting aroma upon entry adds to the overall charm. The seating, though limited, provides a cozy atmosphere to savor their flavorful creations. A must-try for tuna enthusiasts!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Salad, Fresh Bagels
Gary C.
I work at a temple in Scarsdale. So I figured there must be good bagels, right? I think the bagels are very good. They don't upcharge for bialys which is nice. Some places do. They don't charge for freezer bags which is nice. I like the Sammy's stick, which is a long straight bagel stick. Perfect for eating on the drive home. Cash only. They do have an atm which I think charges $2.75 transaction fee which seems too high. I've never tried anything but the bagels which I liked very much. No seating. Counter service. Fast friendly efficient. Clean.
Dan McWilliams
Worlds Best Bagels
Jennie Ryder
Was craving a bagel, went on a whim and got a cinnamon raisin with cream cheese and jelly, the bagel is perfect and they got the proportions just right! Very happy!!!
Saj Popat
Cash only bagel shop with fresh coffee, delicious bagels and cream cheese options.
Susan J.
Smoked salmon not thin sliced. Whitefish salad mushy:(Bagels not like ny bagels. Herring eh. I removed from sauce and made my own. All this for $100! Shameful. The following day, bagels firm despite being bagged in ziplock. I phoned store and the person with whom i spoke wasn't interested. Naturally, no intention of returning to Sammy's.
My family’s favorite bagel shop in the area. If you go early in the morning, the bagels are warm and fresh and taste amazing. All of the cream cheese and spreads are very good as well.
John Nash
Small weak bagels that cost us an arm and a leg in cramped dim lit poorly decorated room with hostile staff. Scary!
Jeremy Kessler
The bagels are pricey but they have been here for a long time. The staff is nice and they make good food
Sadri B.
a decent bagel shop in scarsdale to grab a dozen assorted bagels and a small container of cream cheese. the blueberry muffins are also good as i got a few for later on but for now its a pumpernickel bagel with egg salad and coffee. no sit down seating but a front window counter area is a good place to lean on while munching. overall this bagel shop is simple with its easy to understand menu so order your bagels and spreads and enjoy.
Jamie Cassara
My family gets bagel every Saturday. You can't go wrong.
Read the reviews and was a bit disappointed with the bagels.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Bagels are OK nothing special. Very overpriced for how little cream cheese and/or lox you get.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Extremely helpful, patient, and kind with amazing bagels :)
Great sandwiches, not impressed that they don’t except Credit Cards, impressive
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Sammy's Bagels offers a delightful experience with their delicious spicy tuna bagel. Despite the small size of the location, the inviting aroma upon entry adds to the overall charm. The seating, though limited, provides a cozy atmosphere to savor their flavorful creations. A must-try for tuna enthusiasts!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Salad, Fresh Bagels
I work at a temple in Scarsdale. So I figured there must be good bagels, right? I think the bagels are very good. They don't upcharge for bialys which is nice. Some places do. They don't charge for freezer bags which is nice. I like the Sammy's stick, which is a long straight bagel stick. Perfect for eating on the drive home. Cash only. They do have an atm which I think charges $2.75 transaction fee which seems too high. I've never tried anything but the bagels which I liked very much. No seating. Counter service. Fast friendly efficient. Clean.
Worlds Best Bagels
Was craving a bagel, went on a whim and got a cinnamon raisin with cream cheese and jelly, the bagel is perfect and they got the proportions just right! Very happy!!!
Cash only bagel shop with fresh coffee, delicious bagels and cream cheese options.
Smoked salmon not thin sliced. Whitefish salad mushy:(Bagels not like ny bagels. Herring eh. I removed from sauce and made my own. All this for $100! Shameful. The following day, bagels firm despite being bagged in ziplock. I phoned store and the person with whom i spoke wasn't interested. Naturally, no intention of returning to Sammy's.
Restaurantji Recommends
My family’s favorite bagel shop in the area. If you go early in the morning, the bagels are warm and fresh and taste amazing. All of the cream cheese and spreads are very good as well.
Small weak bagels that cost us an arm and a leg in cramped dim lit poorly decorated room with hostile staff. Scary!
The bagels are pricey but they have been here for a long time. The staff is nice and they make good food
a decent bagel shop in scarsdale to grab a dozen assorted bagels and a small container of cream cheese. the blueberry muffins are also good as i got a few for later on but for now its a pumpernickel bagel with egg salad and coffee. no sit down seating but a front window counter area is a good place to lean on while munching. overall this bagel shop is simple with its easy to understand menu so order your bagels and spreads and enjoy.
My family gets bagel every Saturday. You can't go wrong.