Absolutely love this place as a child and as a over 50 I love it still!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leon Shelhamer
The pizza is seriously delicious and surprisingly inexpensive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ayden Woods
It's a nice little place to eat. They tend to do a wing buffet on Saturdays and it's surprising how good the wings are when all you have to pay is ~$20 to eat as many as you want. The service was very nice and I liked the atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Dave G.
We have not been here in years but are so glad we went. We heard about their new buffet specials and decided to go to tonight's wing buffet. 10 different kinds of BONE IN wings, all you can eat, with a beer, wine, or soda included for $17.95. How can you beat it? Sue, our server, was the best and nicest person we have met in years and definitely made our visit awesome! They also have Tuesday night pasta buffet and Thursday night pizza buffets all with the same kind of reasonable prices!! You have to try it out! 4:30-pm. You won't be disappointed!!
Christopher Mills
Great food and staff. The buffets are great, especially the wings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Wings
A
I’ve been dying for some great local wings. I like my wings cooked, crispy and flavorful. Lately at other local pizza establishments wings are soft and seem undercooked and doused in vinegar more than the hot sauce flavor. I ordered online extra crispy and this place delivered! It was my first time here so don’t know if I got lucky. Pizza was perfect combo of sweet sauce and salty cheese.The service was very nice. There’s parking in back of the building so don’t be discouraged if the front lot seems full.The dining area is very nice and surprisingly big. Can’t wait to try their weekly all you can eats.
Mike McWilliams
I ordered a large calzone and it was like a small from the other place I get them from and it Didn't have any regatta cheese, who makes a calzone that way and the sub I got was short on meat. Would not ever order from them again. I'll stick with Glenville deli.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza king 7120
Fantastic authentic Italian foodBest sausage pizza around uses homemade sausage and grande
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Criscone
Pizza was the worst I have ever been served. Extremely flat with hardly any cheese. It reminded me of Ellio's Pizza but not as good. My friend ordered the Chef Salad and what he got was a bed of wilted greens with some cut up lunch meat on top. As far as service goes, there was basically none. One server took our order and another delivered it. Neither of them EVER checked back to see if we liked our meals. When I was paying for the meals, I told the server our situation and she just blew me off. This establishment also charges an additional $2 to use a credit card. NEVER will my friend and I go back there.Parking: The parking lot is filled with unattended pot holes and mud.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rob Johnson
Ordered a massive order for over 200 people... took less than 5 minutes over the phone! Super easy and convenient to do business with. Chris was awesome. Thank you!
Had the Veal Parm sandwich this time. Meat was a little tough, sauce was good, and the bread had a nice crunch. Cheese was a bit lacking but the price was right $12 not a bad quick lunch.
omelette du fromage
We hadn't been to Carms since pre pandemic. The dining room has been very nicely updated. We were excited to try the new wing buffet, and were very pleased. Eight varieties to choose from. I liked the hotter offerings. Even though the restaurant was full, our server was great and the kitchen kept up with demand for the wings. My son was very happy with his tuna melt that came w bacon and tomato. Will be going back again soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Kh Margo
Wing buffet. Very busy. Wait staff busting a hump trying to cater. Wing flavors excellent. Needed more help with staff. Celery and carrots would come out and customer's were like starving beasts and would wipe them out in 10 seconds.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings
Num Nutz
Carms has the best Pizza around, so happy they made it through the plandemic. Good old fashion NY pizza.You don't stay in business for over 50 years serving frozen meals. One of the few pizzerias that actually still put real sausage on the pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Chicken Wings
Michael P.
Absolutely love this place. The fresh rolls and bread are absolutely stunning. Jimmy, the chef/owner has a really amazing approach to his old school authentic family recipes. He is the third generation owner operator and you can tell he's passionate about what his family has started. The thick crust Sicilian style pizza hits the spot every time.
Absolutely love this place as a child and as a over 50 I love it still!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is seriously delicious and surprisingly inexpensive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a nice little place to eat. They tend to do a wing buffet on Saturdays and it's surprising how good the wings are when all you have to pay is ~$20 to eat as many as you want. The service was very nice and I liked the atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
We have not been here in years but are so glad we went. We heard about their new buffet specials and decided to go to tonight's wing buffet. 10 different kinds of BONE IN wings, all you can eat, with a beer, wine, or soda included for $17.95. How can you beat it? Sue, our server, was the best and nicest person we have met in years and definitely made our visit awesome! They also have Tuesday night pasta buffet and Thursday night pizza buffets all with the same kind of reasonable prices!! You have to try it out! 4:30-pm. You won't be disappointed!!
Great food and staff. The buffets are great, especially the wings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Wings
I’ve been dying for some great local wings. I like my wings cooked, crispy and flavorful. Lately at other local pizza establishments wings are soft and seem undercooked and doused in vinegar more than the hot sauce flavor. I ordered online extra crispy and this place delivered! It was my first time here so don’t know if I got lucky. Pizza was perfect combo of sweet sauce and salty cheese.The service was very nice. There’s parking in back of the building so don’t be discouraged if the front lot seems full.The dining area is very nice and surprisingly big. Can’t wait to try their weekly all you can eats.
I ordered a large calzone and it was like a small from the other place I get them from and it Didn't have any regatta cheese, who makes a calzone that way and the sub I got was short on meat. Would not ever order from them again. I'll stick with Glenville deli.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fantastic authentic Italian foodBest sausage pizza around uses homemade sausage and grande
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was the worst I have ever been served. Extremely flat with hardly any cheese. It reminded me of Ellio's Pizza but not as good. My friend ordered the Chef Salad and what he got was a bed of wilted greens with some cut up lunch meat on top. As far as service goes, there was basically none. One server took our order and another delivered it. Neither of them EVER checked back to see if we liked our meals. When I was paying for the meals, I told the server our situation and she just blew me off. This establishment also charges an additional $2 to use a credit card. NEVER will my friend and I go back there.Parking: The parking lot is filled with unattended pot holes and mud.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered a massive order for over 200 people... took less than 5 minutes over the phone! Super easy and convenient to do business with. Chris was awesome. Thank you!
Restaurantji Recommends
Had the Veal Parm sandwich this time. Meat was a little tough, sauce was good, and the bread had a nice crunch. Cheese was a bit lacking but the price was right $12 not a bad quick lunch.
We hadn't been to Carms since pre pandemic. The dining room has been very nicely updated. We were excited to try the new wing buffet, and were very pleased. Eight varieties to choose from. I liked the hotter offerings. Even though the restaurant was full, our server was great and the kitchen kept up with demand for the wings. My son was very happy with his tuna melt that came w bacon and tomato. Will be going back again soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Wing buffet. Very busy. Wait staff busting a hump trying to cater. Wing flavors excellent. Needed more help with staff. Celery and carrots would come out and customer's were like starving beasts and would wipe them out in 10 seconds.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings
Carms has the best Pizza around, so happy they made it through the plandemic. Good old fashion NY pizza.You don't stay in business for over 50 years serving frozen meals. One of the few pizzerias that actually still put real sausage on the pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Chicken Wings
Absolutely love this place. The fresh rolls and bread are absolutely stunning. Jimmy, the chef/owner has a really amazing approach to his old school authentic family recipes. He is the third generation owner operator and you can tell he's passionate about what his family has started. The thick crust Sicilian style pizza hits the spot every time.