Calvert Manor Bagels

1242 Hicksville Rd, Seaford
(516) 798-9540

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Hillary Brown (Hilly)

It was very busy, the line went to the door. The people were in good spirits, especially as it smelled so heavenly in there. The staff was friendly and so helpful. The bagels were excellent and so delicious. Thanks especially to the Calvert Manor staff.

Kathleen Carlsen

Great Bagels!

Kalliope Lios

i’ve had many bagels in long island but these are the best!! always so fresh and fluffy. love y’all

steven orandello

I’m going into this Bagel place for the last 15 years never disappoints if you’re looking for great Bagels this is the place to go

John D'Amico

Great bagel place. First time there service was excellent and food was delicious

Lonnie Goldman

Excellent spot for excellent bagels. And more.

RAY URENA

One of the most delicious bagels and the most important very clean place!

Syra Sparkle

The line as quite long but I didnt mind waiting because I was waiting for a ride. I also figured if this many people are waiting it must be good. The line moved fairly quickly but ordering and paying at the front was quite chaotic. I ordered a Chicken ranch sandwich on a roll, a side of potato salad(that comes with the sandwhich) a blueberry muffin and Bottled Soda. I decided to break into my sandwhich while waiting for my ride. There was two pieces of grilled chicken on the sandwich, was so dry and too tough I couodnt even chew it.. It was like they gave me a day old reheated chicken, parts were so rubbery I had to remove it from the sandwhich. Which is really sad cuz otherwise it wouldve been a perfect sandwhich. And being charged $1 more than it was priced at the menu def. was not worth it.. I wiuld like to go back again maybe just dont have the grilled chicken next time cuz that really disappointed me.. I saved the muffin for later but it looked really good and felt very fresh and fluffy.

Yesica Villatoro

The best of the best is Ester, the three best in service, attention and promptness, but the best is the quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bobby Aiello

Great tasty bagels made on their premise, BEC sandwich are delicious .Friendly service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Dozen Bagels Special

hector rivera

Always fresh bagels, excellent customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Bagel with Cream Cheese, Dozen Bagels Special

Zach Gunusen

Amazing food, very friendly staff and clean atmosphere. My only recommendation is that staff either pay a little more attention to customers food orders. On many occasions I order a bagel with a specific cream cheese and I end up getting a different kind of cream cheese. I don't mind, it still tastes great, but maybe staff could have the food signs on their end as well so they know which cream cheese is what. You never know what people are allergic to

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Gianna Picariello

Every time I come here they are so stingy with the butter. I even ask for extra butter. Does this look like extra butter or even a normal amount to you? This is what I get time after time. Might as well go somewhere else or just butter it yourself at home. I would not recommend this place and I will not be returning

Matt F

Honestly a disgrace to food service. Imagine in 2024, workers not changing gloves between customers, handling cash, change, and everything in between. I realized after I ordered my bagels and gave the worker my cash. I watched all of the workers and they were all doing something similar. Not to mention the man who helped me seemed like he couldn’t be bothered with being there. Threw the bagels out when I got home, picked up different bagels down the road. Will not be coming back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Morra

Everytime I go here there's a line. Because the bagels are good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel with Cream Cheese

Loading...