Love Crabby Amy's! It is a hidden gem, tucked away in Seaford. If you're on the water, or arriving by boat, do not miss out! Food is always fresh and wonderful, and the atmosphere is amazing! Outdoor seating only and of course, when the weather permits!
Gabriel Torres
A quick bit to eat that was very delicious! It is definitely a place to try if you're in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Lobster Roll, Classic Caesar Salad, Fried Calamari, Locally Dug L I Steamers, Seafood Omelet, Tuna Taco Sandwich, Whole Baked Clams, Chowder and Fish Tacos
Jerry Sully
Food was expensive I kept getting bit by bugs there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
LaurenJose
we were in town to see a show at Jones Beach and looking for a place on the water for dinner and decided on Amy's. boy are we glad we did! our dinner was absolutely delicious. my husband had the lobster BLT. he said he'd be dreaming about it, best he's ever had. I had the soft shell crab and it was perfection. the crabs were huge, perfectly fried and super juicy. our server was sweet and our meal was quick and hot. we live in Jersey and will gladly make the trip back for another incredible meal.
Mara Schwartz
Hidden Gem! Nice , quiet, and relaxing outdoor eating..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janet J.
This was our first time here and found the place randomly. We have two frenchies which they gladly allowed us to eat with. Even though we went at the end of the season and they didn't have a lot of food options, the food we had was cooked to perfection. The service was 10 stars hands down. All the staff were friendly and professional. The ambiance was nice it was on the water. If you want great service and food stop in. They are fur baby friendly.
Phil W
First time there and the food and service were excellent. Staff is friendly. Great atmosphere and reminds me of a great little hole on the wall fish fry type restaurant... But with the extra added perk of being right on the water...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bubba T.
A really nice place to sit outside and enjoy the weather. Service was supper great, drinks were nice and not too expensive. Baked clams were delicious but you only get 4. Crab cake was ok but a bit dark. I had the fish and chips and both were over cooked. Friend had popcorn shrimp and said it was very nice. The wraps also were good. Overall not too expensive and nice. Don't expect much and you will be pleased. At dusk the bugs were heavy and you had to ask for a bud torch but bug spray is what was needed.
Victor C.
Nice atmosphere and attentive service . As we are eating our food we see a hand-truck with the delivery of fish, most of the cases were from Asia . Very disappointed that with all the fishing boats they rely on cheap and toxic fish imports . What was the most disappointing is the way they sneak a 4% credit card processing fee. On the menu it says "4% discount if paid by cash" . No mention of a 4% CCPF after I paid the charge was added. When I questioned it and complained that they must disclose it they insisted it was normal and all credit cards charge a processing fee . I'm in the hospitality business and well aware of the rules and disclosure . This establishment was not compliant or polite when it was brought to their attention . If you encounter this you can dispute the charge with your credit card company and complain to Better Business Bureau.
I went there for dinner tonight with my friend. The food and service is always amazing! If you're looking for a casual place on the water; I definitely recommend it!
Ann L.
Water view, inexpensive. The food is fresh since they had run out of soft shell crabs and crab cakes by 2 pm. They serve breakfast.
Chris H.
I almost never write negative reviews, or actually take the time to write a review, however, I feel compelled to tell you about my experience on Sunday. Before going to Crabby Amy's, I called and asked if they had steamers, in which they replied, Yes, we have steamers tonight. So we headed out to meet another couple, when we arrived, they were already seated. When the server finally got to the table, we ordered our drinks and our food which was one softshell crab, 2 lobster dinners and a tuna wrap. The server came back after about 10 minutes and informed us that they had no more softshell crab. The person that ordered the softshell crab decided they would have the lobster roll. the server then went back i'm assuming to the kitchen and after about 10 minutes returned and Indy us that they no longer had live lobsters. She did state that they still had lobster rolls 3 hot and 3 cold so we ordered the lobster rolls. After about 10 minutes or so the server came back and said that they are now out of hot lobster rolls(you cannot make this up I swear to you) So I ordered the ribs special, reluctantly, after confirming that they do in fact have ribs, mind you, we came here for seafood, the other person who did not get the lobster dinner or lobster roll ordered the tuna, medium rare. After about half an hour or so, they brought our meals, the tuna was well done and like a piece of rubber, my ribs were something you would get an Applebee's on a bad night, the one lobster roll was good except the server forgot to bring sides, this was after we asked her for the sides more than once. After waiting for 15 min. After asking, we got the check, paid and left. To say the service was bad is an understatement. It was then compounded by the server making the excuse of, "well this is not the regular chef" I should've asked her if she was the regular server. The best part was, and what should have given us a clue is when I ordered the steamers for an appetizer, the server said sorry, the owner had just finished the last order! Amy, I hope you enjoyed those steamers! Needless to say, we will never return to this establishment, even though we live locally, and would love to have a nice place to eat by the water, what a shame. P.S. does anyone know how to give less than one star for a review?
Stew Ladd
Good seafood as always. Giant jumbo shrimp and great New England clam chowder. Shrimp basket is smaller than it used to be.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bruce C.
Great location, atmosphere, and beer. Place was busy for a Wednesday late lunch. Was disappointed by the food though. Fish was paper thin and clams looked like what you get in the frozen section of the grocery store.
As of 3/16 it has not opened for the season.
Love Crabby Amy's! It is a hidden gem, tucked away in Seaford. If you're on the water, or arriving by boat, do not miss out! Food is always fresh and wonderful, and the atmosphere is amazing! Outdoor seating only and of course, when the weather permits!
A quick bit to eat that was very delicious! It is definitely a place to try if you're in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Lobster Roll, Classic Caesar Salad, Fried Calamari, Locally Dug L I Steamers, Seafood Omelet, Tuna Taco Sandwich, Whole Baked Clams, Chowder and Fish Tacos
Food was expensive I kept getting bit by bugs there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
we were in town to see a show at Jones Beach and looking for a place on the water for dinner and decided on Amy's. boy are we glad we did! our dinner was absolutely delicious. my husband had the lobster BLT. he said he'd be dreaming about it, best he's ever had. I had the soft shell crab and it was perfection. the crabs were huge, perfectly fried and super juicy. our server was sweet and our meal was quick and hot. we live in Jersey and will gladly make the trip back for another incredible meal.
Hidden Gem! Nice , quiet, and relaxing outdoor eating..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first time here and found the place randomly. We have two frenchies which they gladly allowed us to eat with. Even though we went at the end of the season and they didn't have a lot of food options, the food we had was cooked to perfection. The service was 10 stars hands down. All the staff were friendly and professional. The ambiance was nice it was on the water. If you want great service and food stop in. They are fur baby friendly.
First time there and the food and service were excellent. Staff is friendly. Great atmosphere and reminds me of a great little hole on the wall fish fry type restaurant... But with the extra added perk of being right on the water...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A really nice place to sit outside and enjoy the weather. Service was supper great, drinks were nice and not too expensive. Baked clams were delicious but you only get 4. Crab cake was ok but a bit dark. I had the fish and chips and both were over cooked. Friend had popcorn shrimp and said it was very nice. The wraps also were good. Overall not too expensive and nice. Don't expect much and you will be pleased. At dusk the bugs were heavy and you had to ask for a bud torch but bug spray is what was needed.
Nice atmosphere and attentive service . As we are eating our food we see a hand-truck with the delivery of fish, most of the cases were from Asia . Very disappointed that with all the fishing boats they rely on cheap and toxic fish imports . What was the most disappointing is the way they sneak a 4% credit card processing fee. On the menu it says "4% discount if paid by cash" . No mention of a 4% CCPF after I paid the charge was added. When I questioned it and complained that they must disclose it they insisted it was normal and all credit cards charge a processing fee . I'm in the hospitality business and well aware of the rules and disclosure . This establishment was not compliant or polite when it was brought to their attention . If you encounter this you can dispute the charge with your credit card company and complain to Better Business Bureau.
Restaurantji Recommends
I went there for dinner tonight with my friend. The food and service is always amazing! If you're looking for a casual place on the water; I definitely recommend it!
Water view, inexpensive. The food is fresh since they had run out of soft shell crabs and crab cakes by 2 pm. They serve breakfast.
I almost never write negative reviews, or actually take the time to write a review, however, I feel compelled to tell you about my experience on Sunday. Before going to Crabby Amy's, I called and asked if they had steamers, in which they replied, Yes, we have steamers tonight. So we headed out to meet another couple, when we arrived, they were already seated. When the server finally got to the table, we ordered our drinks and our food which was one softshell crab, 2 lobster dinners and a tuna wrap. The server came back after about 10 minutes and informed us that they had no more softshell crab. The person that ordered the softshell crab decided they would have the lobster roll. the server then went back i'm assuming to the kitchen and after about 10 minutes returned and Indy us that they no longer had live lobsters. She did state that they still had lobster rolls 3 hot and 3 cold so we ordered the lobster rolls. After about 10 minutes or so the server came back and said that they are now out of hot lobster rolls(you cannot make this up I swear to you) So I ordered the ribs special, reluctantly, after confirming that they do in fact have ribs, mind you, we came here for seafood, the other person who did not get the lobster dinner or lobster roll ordered the tuna, medium rare. After about half an hour or so, they brought our meals, the tuna was well done and like a piece of rubber, my ribs were something you would get an Applebee's on a bad night, the one lobster roll was good except the server forgot to bring sides, this was after we asked her for the sides more than once. After waiting for 15 min. After asking, we got the check, paid and left. To say the service was bad is an understatement. It was then compounded by the server making the excuse of, "well this is not the regular chef" I should've asked her if she was the regular server. The best part was, and what should have given us a clue is when I ordered the steamers for an appetizer, the server said sorry, the owner had just finished the last order! Amy, I hope you enjoyed those steamers! Needless to say, we will never return to this establishment, even though we live locally, and would love to have a nice place to eat by the water, what a shame. P.S. does anyone know how to give less than one star for a review?
Good seafood as always. Giant jumbo shrimp and great New England clam chowder. Shrimp basket is smaller than it used to be.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great location, atmosphere, and beer. Place was busy for a Wednesday late lunch. Was disappointed by the food though. Fish was paper thin and clams looked like what you get in the frozen section of the grocery store.