Crabby Amy's,

Name: Crabby Amy's,
Address: 2880 Ocean Ave, Seaford, New York, 11783, US
Telephone: (516) 783-2554
Price range: $$
Rating: 4

$$ • Seafood, Pet Friendly

Hours:
2880 Ocean Ave, Seaford
(516) 783-2554

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

take-out

delivery

Customers' Favorites

Locally Dug L I Steamers

Chowder and Fish Tacos

Classic Caesar Salad

Tuna Taco Sandwich

Whole Baked Clams

Fried Calamari

Seafood Omelet

Catfish Wrap

Lobster Roll

Fish & Chips

Crabby Amy's, Reviews

4 (45)

Write a review

January 2024

Love Crabby Amy's! It is a hidden gem, tucked away in Seaford. If you're on the water, or arriving by boat, do not miss out! Food is always fresh and wonderful, and the atmosphere is amazing! Outdoor seating only and of course, when the weather permits!

September 2023

we were in town to see a show at Jones Beach and looking for a place on the water for dinner and decided on Amy's. boy are we glad we did! our dinner was absolutely delicious. my husband had the lobster BLT. he said he'd be dreaming about it, best he's ever had. I had the soft shell crab and it was perfection. the crabs were huge, perfectly fried and super juicy. our server was sweet and our meal was quick and hot. we live in Jersey and will gladly make the trip back for another...read full review

September 2023

This was our first time here and found the place randomly. We have two frenchies which they gladly allowed us to eat with. Even though we went at the end of the season and they didn't have a lot of food options, the food we had was cooked to perfection. The service was 10 stars hands down. All the staff were friendly and professional. The ambiance was nice it was on the water. If you want great service and food stop in. They are fur baby friendly.

More Reviews(201)