South Shore Bagels
3451 Merrick Rd, Wantagh
(516) 804-9626
Customers' Favorites
Martinelli's Gold Medal Apple Juice 10 Oz
1 Egg Bagel Sandwich
2 Eggs - Bagel
Roll
Flat
Picked for you
2 Eggs with Ham and Cheese
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
The Warrior Panini
Breaded chicken cutlet, Muenster cheese, bacon, romaine lettuce, and mayonnaise. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Sliced Nova and Flavored Cream Cheese
Sliced Nova and Plain Cream Cheese
Tuna Melt Hot Sandwich
Cold Cuts & Cheeses
Lacey Swiss
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Genoa Salami
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Ovengold Turkey
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Honey Maple Turkey
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Peppermill Turkey
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Salsalito Turkey
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Ham
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Virginia Ham
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Buffalo Chicken
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Roast Beef
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Corned Beef
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Pastrami
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Prosciutto
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Bologna
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Liverwurst
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Pepperoni
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
American Cheese
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Swiss
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Muenster
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Cheddar Cheese
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Monterey Jack
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Provolone
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Mozzarella
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Cappi Ham
Served on a bagel, bialy, or roll (twist, flat, or hero).
Homemade salads
Chicken Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Craisin Chicken Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Tuna Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Veggie Tuna Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Shrimp Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Seafood Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Whitefish Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Egg Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Lite Tuna Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Lite Chicken Salad
Served with hellman mayonnaise.
Salads to Go
Tossed Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots.
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red peppers, cucumbers, black olives, and feta cheese with Greek dressings.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, garlic, herb, and croutons with Caesar dressing.
Chefs Salad
Romaine lettuce with ham, Turkey, roast beef, American cheese, Swiss cheese, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, and cucumbers.
Hot Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Hot Sandwich
Fried Chicken Cutlet Hot Sandwich
B.L.T Hot Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Hot Sandwich
Grilled Cheese and Bacon Hot Sandwich
Tuna Melt Hot Sandwich
Homemade Cream Cheese and Spreads
Plain Cream Cheese
Lite Plain Cream Cheese
Lite Vegetable
Butter
Vegetable
Scallion
Walnut Raisin
Olive
Bacon and Onion
Strawberry
Lox Spread
Sliced Nova
Jelly
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Plain Cream Cheese and Jelly
Butter and Jelly
Plain Cream Cheese and Bacon
Plain Cream Cheese and Ham
Sliced Nova and Butter
Sliced Nova and Plain Cream Cheese
Sliced Nova and Flavored Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel with Butter
Mini Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel with Lox Spread
Mini Bagel with Sliced Nova and Plain Cream Cheese
Bagel Chips
Assorted Bagel Chips; Baked Daily
Wraps
The Wild Bill Wrap
Buffalo chicken, melted monterey jack cheese, lettuce, and bleu cheese dressing. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Bootlegger Wrap
Roastbeef, melted cheddar, lettuce, and tomato. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Little Italy Wrap
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, red roasted peppers, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Classic Wrap
Chicken salad bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The All American Wrap
Fried chicken cutlet, melted American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Frisco Wrap
Salsalito turkey, melted pepper jack cheese, bacon, romaine lettuce, and bleu cheese dressing. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Godfather Wrap
Genoa salami, cappi ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian dressing. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, Caesar dressing, romaine lettuce, and parmesan cheese. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Gobbler Wrap
Ovengold turkey, muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Southwest Wrap
Pepper Turkey, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Pastrami Classic Wrap
Pastrami, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and mustard. Served with potato 1/4 lb, macaroni or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Paninis
The Warrior Panini
Breaded chicken cutlet, Muenster cheese, bacon, romaine lettuce, and mayonnaise. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Veggie Delight Panini
Fresh mozzarella, red roasted peppers, artichoke hearts, and pesto sauce. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Monte Cristo Panini
Honey maple turkey, Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and honey mustard. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Alpine Panini
Corned beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Italian Night Club Panini
Genoa salami, Cappi ham, pepperoni, mozzarella, romaine lettuce, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
27A Melt Panini
Grilled chicken, melted mozzarella, red roasted peppers, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Chicken Fajita Panini
Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, roasted red peppers, onions, and salsa. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Mama Mia Panini
Breaded eggplant with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
The Harbor Panini
Roast beef, oven-gold turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and mustard. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb. Comes with 1/4 lb. potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and a slice of pickle.
Fresh Hot Bagels
Bagel
Rainbow
Roll
Bialy
Mini Bagel
Twists
Flats
Hero
French Toast Bagel
From The Bakery
Crumb Cake
Asst Danish
Regular Muffins
Apple Turnover
Large Asst Cookies
Brownies
Egg Specials
2 Eggs with Ham and Cheese
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
3 Eggs with Ham, Bacon, and Sausage
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
2 Eggs with Cheese
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
3 Eggs with Potato on a Hero
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
Hungry Man (Hero)
Three eggs, bacon three pieces, ham two pieces, sausage, and cheese. Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
1 Egg
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
1 Egg with Cheese
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
1 Egg with Ham
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
1 Egg with Ham and Cheese
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
2 Eggs
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
2 Eggs with Ham
Consuming raw or uncooked fresh shell eggs or meat can lead to foodborne illness.
Beverages
Iced Coffee
Iced Tea
Coffee
Decaf Coffee
Flavored Coffee
Tea
Herbal Tea
Hot Chocolate
Cappuccino
French Vanilla
Lemonade
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Very kind workers, very good customer service. I asked for day-old bagels to give to volunteers for a service project, and they gave them to me without hesitation. South Shore Bagels has very good deals to buy bagels in bulk and I would recommend South Shore Bagels to anyone across Long Island.
June 2025
Just stopped off here on my way to work. I pass Seaford bagel on my way in but wasn't crazy about their bagels. I decided to stop off here instead and omg what a difference the bagels I had a egg everything with scallion cream cheese it was outstanding and the staff is very friendly and polite. This is my go to place on my way in to work when I'm in the mood for a great bagel.
February 2025
Yeah this place was fantastic. Went here for lunch after having done ceramics for my son’s birthday. The bagels themselves were really good, but the bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches were loaded and tasted excellent. I say this as a self proclaimed bagel connoisseur, I have these bagel sandwiches multiple times a week usually, and these were about as good as I’ve had, really.
February 2025
You May Also Like
Bel Posto - 3453 Merrick Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegan, Vegetarian
The Original Salpino’s of Wantagh - 3457 Merrick Rd
![]()
Meat Shops, Grocery, Deli
Escorza's - 3463 Merrick Rd
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian