Sweet Spot Cafe Long Island

3787 Merrick Rd, Seaford
(516) 308-3843

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Cake Whipped Cream
Red Velvet Cake Slice
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Ice Cream Milkshake
Belgian Waffles
Gelato

Menu

Gelato
Gelato

Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Chocolate or vanilla.

Swirly Freeze
Ice Cream Swirly Freeze
Ice cream mixed with your favorite toppings or cereals! Includes 2 mix ins/toppings.
Gelato Swirly Freeze

Milkshakes
Ice Cream Milkshake
Includes 2 mix-ins/ toppings
Gelato Milkshake

Soda Floats
Ice Cream Soda Float
Gelato Soda Float

Sweet Spot Signatures
Smart Cookie
Vanilla ice cream with Oreos and cookie crisp topped with cookie dough, Oreos, and chocolate syrup.
Plain Jane
Vanilla ice cream with frosted flakes and cinnamon toast crunch, topped with cinnamon toast crunch, caramel, and vanilla drizzle.
Cereal Killer
Vanilla ice cream with fruity pebbles, crunch berries, and lucky charms topped with all 3 cereals.
Peanut Butter Dream
Chocolate ice cream with Reese's puffs, topped with peanut butter, P.B. cups, and Reese's pieces.
Campfire Crunch
Chocolate ice cream with cinnamon toast crunch, topped with vanilla and chocolate drizzle and a smore's bite.
Coconuts About You
Vanilla ice cream with cinnamon toast crunch, wafers, and coconut topped with caramel and coconut flakes.
Loco for Cocoa
Chocolate ice cream with cocoa puffs and chocolate sprinkles, topped with Kit Kats, brownie bites, and chocolate drizzle.
Dirt In A Cup
Vanilla ice cream mixed with oreos & chocolate crunchies. Topped with Chocolate syrup & gummy worms.
Over The Rainbow
Vanilla ice cream mixed with rainbow sprinkles & fruit loops, topped with nerds & gummy bears
Frozen PB&J
Vanilla ice cream mixed with wafer pieces & peanuts, topped with peanut butter & raspberry syrup
Berries & Chocolate
Chocolate ice cream mixed with fruit loops & crunch berries, topped with raspberry & marshmallow syrup
Road Work
Chocolate ice cream mixed with brownie bites & peanuts, topped with marshmallows, caramel & marshmallow syrup

Beverages
Single Espresso
Double Espresso
Single Macchiato
Double Macchiato
Latte
Cappuccino
Caffe Americano
Iced Espresso
Iced Latte, Cappuccino, Macchiato, Americano. Please specify
Cold Brew
Nitro Cold Brew
American coffee
Hot chocolate

Other Desserts
Tiramisu Cake
Rainbow Cookie Cake
N.Y. Cheesecake
Lava Cake
Chocolate Cake
Oreo Mousse Cake
Red Velvet Cake
Carrot cake
Crumb cake
M&M Pretzel
White Chocolate Oreo Pretzel
Pretzel covered in white chocolate and Oreos!
Reese's Pieces Pretzel
Kit Kat covered pretzel
Rainbow Sprinkle Pretzel
Black & white cookie
S'mores bite
Marshmallows on a graham cracker covered in chocolate
Apple Turnover
Ice cream sandwich
Vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiched between chocolate chip cookies
Cookies and cream cookie
8 oz Cookie stuffed with Oreos
Rainbow cookie stuffed cookie
8 ozCookie stuffed with a rainbow cookie and covered in sprinkles
S'mores stuffed cookie
Chocolate chip cookie
8oz choc. chip cookie, a classic.
Hot Chocolate Cookie
Hot chocolate cookie topped with marshmallows
Brownie
Salted caramel Pretzel cookie
cookie filled with caramel and pretzel pieces
Double chocolate PB cookie
Vampire Cookie
Dark chocolate & Red Velvet Cookie
PB Brownie Cookie
Snicker doodle cookie

Cannoli
Chocolate Cannoli
Plain Cannoli

Affogato
Affogato
A shot of espresso poured over gelato, a perfect match!

Candy
1/2lb bag of candy
Randomly selected bags of candy

Belgian Waffles
Plain waffle

Specialty Sodas
Boylan Cola
Boylan Creme Soda
Boylan Orange
Boylan Black Cherry
Boylan Root Beer
Boylan Birch Beer
Boylan Shirley Temple
Boylan Ginger Ale
Boylan Sparkling Lemonade
Ramune Original
Japanese Soda that you pop that marble into
Ramune Melon
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
Ramune Orange
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
Ramune Peach
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
Ramune Grape
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
Ramune Strawberry
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
avery's Unicorn Yak
Raspberry Orange Cream Soda
Avery's Toxic Slime
Blue Raspberry Orange Soda
Bazooka Soda
Classic bubblegum flavor
Ramune Lychee
Japanese soda that you pop marble into
Warhead Soda Blue Raspberry
Sour soda from the classic candy brand
Warhead Soda Green Apple
Sour soda from the classic candy brand
Warhead Black Cherry
Toxic Waste Green Apple Soda
sour soda from the hottest sour candy brand
Slime Licker Soda Strawberry
Slime Licker Soda Blue Razz

Holy Cannoli
Stuffed Regular cannoli
Large regular Cannoli filled with gelato, includes a topping
Stuffed Chocolate cannoli
Large chocolate cannoli filled with gelato, includes 1 topping

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: grubhub
+35 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This gelato shop is truly special! The owner’s passion for what he creates shines through in every scoop. You can tell he puts so much care and pride into the quality and flavors. On top of that, he’s kind and generous, he always makes my son smile and makes you feel like more than just a customer. A place you’ll want to keep coming back to again and again!
September 2025
Came here with my 8 year old daughter after her soccer game. The place is beautiful and super clean. The service was friendly and attentive. Best of all, gelato that was insanely good! This will be our regular post soccer spot! Be warned, plenty of candy here to keep your kids' permanent attention.
September 2025
By far the best pistachio flavored gelato I've tasted in 30 years. Authentic flavors, smooth texture. Their espresso is legit. I had a straight espresso last night and came back for an iced latte today. They have a regular customer in me now.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dang BBQ - 3864 Merrick Rd #11
Barbecue, Barbeque, Chicken Wings
Pastrami Express - 3882 Merrick Rd
Sandwich Shop
Charred Brick Oven - 3915 Merrick Rd
Pizza, Italian

Sweet Spot Cafe Long Island

3787 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783
(516) 308-3843