Pizza itself was great, but I wasn't a fan of the crust. It was too burnt for my liking.
Samantha R.
Super unfriendly staff. I felt very unwanted here, being I was the only one in the restaurant at the time. I felt rushed to leave and got home with cold food. Never again.
Valerie Vault
I am definitely going to rate this 4 stars...Margherita pizza Absolutely delicious With the Sesame seed crust....A+++++BUT: It arrived very cold (brrrrr)We had to air fry it...for $25 it should arrive hot n ready to eat.I hope The owners can take some constructive criticism because I have to admit The Taste was absolutely delicious! Happy Healthy New Year!!!-
Dan W.
Prices went up, the pies have been getting smaller (even when Tom owned it). It is thin, and the sesame seeds are a nice differentiator, but its not alot of pizza for $17.50. They look like first time owners and a little overwhelmed, frazzled. My son doesn't like going there anymore.........
Roger Rothman
I took my family for diner. The food was really good. The portions were great. Anthony is a wonderful guy and great cook. I’m going to go back for sure.
Marshall Rothman
Awesome food.. great chicken parm, owner is a great guy! Best pizza around
Ruben Velasquez M.
This is the most delicious pizza in the Nassau I recommend 100%
Joseph Giampapa
Best pizza around! Love the sesame crust, closest to Brooklyn style that I’ve found. If I’m not eating Tarallo’s pizza, I’m not eating pizza!!!
Kimberly MacDonald
I'm from Brooklyn, and since living on LI, we have searched for similar pizza... Tarallo"s is awesome, and not just the pizza. Have NEVER been disappointed with anything we've ordered.
Nick P.
Came here for the first time yesterday to grab a slice with a friend, it was so good that I came back today with my dad and we split a pie. There wasn't a slice left between the both of us....might be the best regular slice in the area. They put sesame seed in the crust which is go good. This will be my new go to for a regular slice. Also all the workers behind the counter are awesome down to earth people!
Go here often - sometimes after Mass. Nice pizza - recently went under an interior redesign and new management.
Bryan Blaha
Great local pizza spot with solid pizza! Sicilian was ?
tim nicholson
Great cheese pizza and excellent family specials
Joe P.
Ordered a regular pie last week and again this week both times with sesame crust. I really want to love this pizza but the sauce has been sour both times almost to the point of being inedible. This has been our 4th order from them after a friend put us onto it. I really want to love your pizza but there's something going on with your pizza sauce you need to look into and address...
Jennifer Marie
My family and I ordered a couple of pizzas yesterday, and let me tell you it was DELICIOUS! By far the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Thank you, we will definitely be back for more!
Pizza itself was great, but I wasn't a fan of the crust. It was too burnt for my liking.
Super unfriendly staff. I felt very unwanted here, being I was the only one in the restaurant at the time. I felt rushed to leave and got home with cold food. Never again.
I am definitely going to rate this 4 stars...Margherita pizza Absolutely delicious With the Sesame seed crust....A+++++BUT: It arrived very cold (brrrrr)We had to air fry it...for $25 it should arrive hot n ready to eat.I hope The owners can take some constructive criticism because I have to admit The Taste was absolutely delicious! Happy Healthy New Year!!!-
Prices went up, the pies have been getting smaller (even when Tom owned it). It is thin, and the sesame seeds are a nice differentiator, but its not alot of pizza for $17.50. They look like first time owners and a little overwhelmed, frazzled. My son doesn't like going there anymore.........
I took my family for diner. The food was really good. The portions were great. Anthony is a wonderful guy and great cook. I’m going to go back for sure.
Awesome food.. great chicken parm, owner is a great guy! Best pizza around
This is the most delicious pizza in the Nassau I recommend 100%
Best pizza around! Love the sesame crust, closest to Brooklyn style that I’ve found. If I’m not eating Tarallo’s pizza, I’m not eating pizza!!!
I'm from Brooklyn, and since living on LI, we have searched for similar pizza... Tarallo"s is awesome, and not just the pizza. Have NEVER been disappointed with anything we've ordered.
Came here for the first time yesterday to grab a slice with a friend, it was so good that I came back today with my dad and we split a pie. There wasn't a slice left between the both of us....might be the best regular slice in the area. They put sesame seed in the crust which is go good. This will be my new go to for a regular slice. Also all the workers behind the counter are awesome down to earth people!
Restaurantji Recommends
Go here often - sometimes after Mass. Nice pizza - recently went under an interior redesign and new management.
Great local pizza spot with solid pizza! Sicilian was ?
Great cheese pizza and excellent family specials
Ordered a regular pie last week and again this week both times with sesame crust. I really want to love this pizza but the sauce has been sour both times almost to the point of being inedible. This has been our 4th order from them after a friend put us onto it. I really want to love your pizza but there's something going on with your pizza sauce you need to look into and address...
My family and I ordered a couple of pizzas yesterday, and let me tell you it was DELICIOUS! By far the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Thank you, we will definitely be back for more!