Luigi's Pizzeria

Tucked in a shoping center off Route 25A, I found a pizzeria/diner that served an awesome Chicken Marsala, with mushrooms, and a wine sauce. The chicken was hot, tender, and full of the mushroom and wine flavor. The salad was fresh and crisp. I found the staff friendly and provided me with directirons to my hotel. If I am on Long Island again, I will search out Luigi's Pizzeria.

$30 for an inedible wilted garden salad and a dry chicken parm hero on stale bread. this place has fallen hard.

The food is always great there as well as the staff, especially Victor❣

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve tried so many different spots on the island throughout my life, and i can’t believe i had never tried Luigi’s. Their pizza is just classic LI pizza, and I don’t understand the one-star reviews. The amount of sauce is perfection, and the crust is nice and light. I have some best friends who live out-of-state. When they visit, we’re going here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am a New Yorker now living in Florida. The first food I craved when visiting was a slice of pizza , crusty and yummy. Luigi's pizza was mushy with too much cheese. I should have asked for 2 more slices. I was very disappointed. Try another place for pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Ordered from this pizza shop and had my pizza delivered in this horrible condition !!! Was my FIRST time ordering from them and it will be my last.

Food: 1

Pizza was ok and chicken parm hero was ok. Not a fan of getting my $7 slice on a paper plate with plastic fork and knife

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

This pizza is absolutely horrendous. This is the most un edible pizza in the setauket area. 4/5 times the pizza is burnt, stale or lacks flavor. I was at the moment when almost nobody was at the pizzeria, and the pizza still came burnt. This shows the lack of effort and laziness of the employees. I do not recommend going here unless you’re desperate for over priced, low effort, burnt, and tasteless pizza. I would recommend avoiding this place there are so many more better options within a 10 minute drive.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amazing margherita pie!!!

I haven't been able to eat pizza in a pizza place in over 15 years since I became lactose intolerant, Luigis has a vegan cheese option and I was finally able to enjoy pizza again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Solid pizza place and my favorite in Setauket

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Hero completely wrong and thrown together, despite the correct order being printed on receipt!! Third time this has happened. Food is good, when it’s what we actually ordered. Get it together guys.

Came here to leave a review and was surprised by all the 1 star reviews. I had heard of them because they just introduced vegan pizza (9/12/24) so I wanted to give it a try. Got a vegan Sicilian with olives and peppers and thought it was really good. I'd certainly order it again.

Moved to Port Jeff in May and a friend recommended Luigi's. Hands down my favorite pizzeria, I get it once a week. Great specials and always consistent. Can't say enough good things!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing pizza, always happy with the quality & taste. The only reason why I am giving 4 stars was for service today. Nothing major, but the cashier (a younger girl) was a little standoffish & I was nothing but polite. The man who was handing me my pizza was calling my sisters name because she called it in under her name (I had multiple orders to pick up.) It took me only like 10 seconds to realize they were calling my personal order under my sisters name (which is not the issue) but the cashier started laughing at me. Not professional. I really like this place but at least the workers at Colosseo Pizza in Port Jeff Stations are consistently nice with just as good pizza.