Restaurants in Setauket- East Setauket

“Went last night. 6 of us. We loved everything. Food and drinks were delicious. Our server was great! Can't wait to return.”

“Where do I even begin, Elaine’s might be the best experience we have had at a restaurant, period the end! We had Debbie as our host, who was very kind and attentive, she had top tier suggestions for any kind of food, cigars, and atmosphere we were searching for. We also met a wonderful couple at the bar who were super friendly and gave us some great tips for when we attend the US Open. Isaiah was an awesome waiter who brought us our food and drinks with perfect timing, kudos to the chef for an outstanding meal, the owners who we also got the opportunity to meet and have a familiar conversation with about our home MA, and the bartenders who made amazing drinks to top it all off! What a great environment they have created at Elaine’s, we will be back for another meal tomorrow night!”

“Mo is amazing! Such great energy in here! The food is fantastic and she let me play her acoustic guitar in the dining room. Highly recommend. Thanks Mo! Let's drop some Prince Buster next time! 😎 🇯🇲”

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!”

“Had breakfast with a friend. I can’t say enough about the quality of the food. I will definitely return.”

“Don’t listen to the negative review from people who think they know good food… Chicos tacos and burritos are pretty pretty good. Birria broth is absolutely delicious! I reccomend this spot”

“Food is amazing, Staff is amazing, owner is amazing. the place is a magic experience.”

“I’ve been ordering from/going to Domo for 3 years now and they have been exceptional! Their food is always great, all of the staff are lovely, and it’s been my go to Sushi spot all the is time.

It’s a hidden gem that I cannot recommend highly enough!”

“We absolutely LOVE this gem! Jacqueline makes us feel like family each and every time, and the food is superb! Her wine selection is outstanding and she always picks winners for us! Five stars! 🍷Cheers!”

“Service and food was great. Atmosphere was wonderful. Price is what you expect nowadays. However put it all together it was a 10. Definitely will come back with a bigger group..”

“What a delightful little local deli! We were visiting from out of town and filled up on all types of New York staples - Drake's cakes, Wise potato chips, pumpernickel bread, all the staples that make New York iconic for certain foods. The staff was very helpful and it was overall a great experience”

“Great food and Beer selection! Go with the #6 ! And the Darby wings 🤗”

“this has become my new favorite pizza place, and while I probably shouldn't I've eaten here almost every day last week. their slices and pies are always fresh, delicious and inventive. they even make the kid slices cool which is a huge plus.”

“first time eating here, and it really was good.”

“We got married on 11/21/2025 at Three Village Inn Stony Brook and Rolling Pin Bakery was the bakery in our package and I couldn’t have been happier.
Communication was so easy. From setting up cake testing to placing the order. 10/10. The cake was beautiful and delicious!”

“First time back after 32 years! During my childhood was the place to be for soft ice cream, BIRTHDAY ICE CREAM CAKES!!!, and the chocolate ice cream sandwich’s!!! Owner was very nice and store was very clean. Will definitely be back a lot sooner. Thank you for bringing back the memories!!!!”

“First time and it was excellent. Highly recommend. We will definitely be back.”

“Great food. very fresh. everyone working there is very friendly.”

“The Terryville Fire Department and it’s employees want to thank the Setauket Starbucks for the generous gift of coffee and pastries. God bless your staff & God bless America. 🇺🇸☕️”

“Consistently good taste and portion size, fast, reasonably priced. I love that the house fried rice sometimes has shrimp and pork in it, but be aware of that if you have any allergies.”

“I never heard of Setauket Gourmet until a month ago. I've been back numerous times, and try something new each time. great selection, great specials, and all of their food is delicious.”

“Ate here for the first time yesterday. Food was very good and tasty. The only thing that kept it from 5 stars, they don't deliver locally. I'm not going to pay whatever Uber or door dash charges on top of the food cost. Then it is not worth it.”

“So nice inside and the food is great!! it's about 10-ish bucks for a salad, and it's so worth it. I've gotten salads from the Pop salad section and i just tried a quesadilla with steak (omg soooo good, the steak is soft and juicy and seasoned just right). the salad is always fresh and tasty and the portions are big!! My quesadilla meal was about 13.50 without the drink but i have leftovers and I always have half a salad left so it's like 2 meals for 10-15 dollars...so worth it. The people that prep the food in the back are so nice too. Idk where they found these employees but they are just so genuine and friendly. Love this place. I recommend it to everyone lol”

“New owners, great food and service. Nice atmosphere.”

“I mistakenly placed a catering order with Victor not realizing it was the wrong Luigi’s restaurant in a different state! Victor was kind and told me not to worry and I don’t owe a dime. Thank you!!!”

“18+ Years of Ordering Several Delicious Pizzas , Pastas and Heros — Staff is Always Amazing , Atmosphere is Comforting and Food Top Shelf — They also Welcome in Our Special Needs Children for Work Related Growth Learning in Their Own Neighborhood !!!!!”