Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market

$ • Deli

734 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket
(631) 941-4200

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.6 (47)
Restaurantji Rating

I travel 8 miles for BLT's passing over a half dozen places that are closer... pumpernickels perfected what bacon should taste like and how it is cooked....rare amongst the masses....I have had many other sandwiches as well.... the place is just very very

Restaurantji Rating

I love Pumpernickels’! The food is always fresh, creative sandwiches on a variety of homemade bread. The staff is very polite and friendly, as if they really want to earn your business. They work hard to make their store warm and welcoming. I pass by two other deli’s’ that are closer to my house, to get to Pumpernickel’s. Excellent tuna salad on rye! Ron

Restaurantji Rating

Great deli. We had them cater an office luncheon and everything was delicious with a beautiful presentation. We ordered 5 heroes that they cut into 4’s and served on a platter. They delivered to us at Stony Brook University and were perfectly on time. Everyone enjoyed the food. Will definitely be going back.

More Reviews(47)



Add a Menu
Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market Menu
Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market Menu


Add a Photo
Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market
Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market
View All Photos


Monday 8AM - 4PM
Tuesday 8AM - 4PM
Wednesday 8AM - 4PM
Thursday 8AM - 4PM
Friday 8AM - 4PM
Saturday 8AM - 3PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: