41 Best Ice Cream Shops near Setauket East Setauket

1
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$$
178 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket

“This is not the first time I have stopped for ice cream at this Carvel. I tried a strawberry thick shake and it was very good. I think the next time I'll have them add some strawberries to the shake. The person behind the counter was very nice. I'll be back for more.“

4 Good12 Reviews
Mickey's Ice Cream Kitchen & Space Ice Cream Shop • $$
370 Lake Ave, St James - 4.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mini Mick-Wich Ice Cream Sandwich
Topping - Crushed Waffle Cone
Topping - Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Overload
Shakes & Floats
Icecream Cakes
Cookies 'Cream
Sorbets

“Great venue for a kids party! The staff are very helpful and kind, making the experience easy for the parents. I’d recommend Mikey’s for any parent looking to do a party for up to 15 kids. The fact they have an outdoor area is great for letting the kids run off their sugar rush after the party is over. Thanks to the team.“

4.8 Superb83 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $
623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.4 miles

“There are different kinds of ice cream to get here. I got the hard ice cream to try and I really enjoyed the consistency and the taste. The mint chocolate chip tastes really good. It does not taste toothpastey at all which i enjoy a lot! It tastes very good. I also tried the coffee hard ice cream and it was very flavorful. It had a strong coffee flavor which I liked. I am excited to try new flavors here and new ice cream types. The workers are very kind as well which is memorable.“

4.7 Superb107 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $$
1370 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 5.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Ice Cream
Rainbow Sprinkles
Cotton Candy
Italian Ice
Hot Fudge
Brownie

“This is our favorite icecream and ices place to go! The variety is great. Servers are kind and cost is good . The only 'bad' thing I can say about this place is they close in the winter months.Vegetarian options: All water based ices are vegan“

4.6 Superb138 Reviews
Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar Ice Cream Shop •
2229 Rte 112, Coram - 6.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chunky Monkey Special Swirl
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Ice Cream Swirl
Toasted Coconut
Fruity Pebbles
Cookie Monster
Cocoa Pebbles
Rice Krispies
Silly Rabbit
Strawberry

“Patrick is such an amazing employee and so attentive! He literally stopped everything to take care of what I wanted when my ice cream cone fell, instead of saying “too bad” he made me another cone free of charge! Literally I love this store and their employees! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND “

4.8 Superb68 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices Of Smithtown Ice Cream Shop • $$
316 Maple Ave, Smithtown - 8 miles

“I love this Place. 1st the staff is the nicest you will find. You walk in and everyone is always smiling even when its chaotic and busy and packed. The staff always goes out of there way to accommodate there customers and give them the best service. When there is down time John always takes time to say hello chat and get to know his customers and when you come in you feel not like a customer but a part of the ralphs family.“

4.7 Superb86 Reviews
Mia's Ice Cream Kitchen Ice Cream Shop • $
1315 Middle Country Rd Ste 5, Centereach - 5.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Cookie & Cookies and Dream
Chocolate Chips Dark Choc Sauce
Chocolate Sprinkles Hot Caramel
Large Waffle Cone
Campfire S'Mores
Root Beer Float
Dream Ice Cream
Cherry Amaretto
Caramel Crunch
Whipped Cream

“Fantastic ice cream spot with truly authentic, homemade ice cream, and flavors that I guarantee you have never seen or heard of before.Owner was kind enough to let us sample several options. Kids were happy, we were happy, and we will most definitely be coming back. Be sure to check this place out!“

4.6 Superb94 Reviews
Kilwins Port Jefferson Ice Cream • $$
109D Main St, Port Jefferson - 2.12 miles

“I was visiting Port Jeff for dinner and I saw this very cute chocolate shop. They did such an amazing job with their holiday decor! They have a wide selection of different types of chocolates. The staff were very helpful and knowledgeable about the offerings. They have premade baskets of chocolates that would be ideal for gifts this time of the year!!“

4.5 Superb108 Reviews
Strong Island Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan
Waffle Cone
Strawberry

“They serve sundaes, cakes, shakes, ice cream and so much more. It is family owned and operated and is a very easy going and laid back place. They make you feel like family and the ice cream is to die for. It definitely tastes homemade. $8 for 2 scoops $5 for 1 “

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Cafe Lahooti Bubble Tea •
96 E Main St, Village of the Branch - 6.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate
Cookies & Cream
Smores

“I have tried alot of bubble tea places and this one is REALLY good! My friends and I got the Rose Milk Tea, Taro, and Earl Grey Milk Tea. The Rose & Earl grey were the best in my opinion! The boba was also really well made, soft and chewy. Service was great as well! Overall a great place for bubble tea, I will be coming back soon!!“

4.7 Superb50 Reviews
County Wide Ice Cream Distributors Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
1600 N Ocean Ave, Holtsville - 9.21 miles

“Love everything about this place. From the novelty ice cream to the high end tartufos and gelato. They also sell popular candy and some old school such as razzels. Sparklers , cotton candy. Its like reliving my childhood from the ice cream truck but less expensive. Friendly staff & owners. Highly recommend shopping here.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Supreme Salads Health Food •
2460 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook - 3.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Plant Based Chocolate Protein Shake
Build Your Own Salad
Mediterranean Salad
Mediterranean Wrap
Large Salad
BYO Panini
Southwest

“I just ordered from this place, I used to go to proportions all the time to get my salads, or meals before this place came around. I’m not too sure if they changed things around or if they updated the place but it’s exactly like proportions! The salads were absolutely delicious, and the size portions were massive! Can’t get any better than this place, it’s a little costly but it’s worth it for its size and quality! It’s super fresh, and I love how they give you a lot of options when it comes to toppings making it gluten free, and vegan friendly!I highly recommend!“

4.4 Superb40 Reviews
Arnor Crepes & Bubble Tea Stony Brook Bubble Tea • $
1113 N Country Rd, Stony Brook - 1.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crepe with Condensed Milk and Matcha
Chocolate and Strawberry Crepes
Ice Cream Fruit Cr
Nutella
blt

“A pretty Lil place serving amazing crepes. We had the Nutella and Peanut butter Crepe, it was yumm yummy. The service was really quick inspite of making it from scratch right infront of you. It closes at 8:30 pm , less crowded on weekdays. Great place to go back for delicious crepes and bubble tea.“

4.1 Good89 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
2220 Rte 112, Coram - 6.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hunka Chunka PB Fudge Sundae
A Disaster of French Toast
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Mini Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
Ice Cream Sundaes
Honey BBQ Burger

“They are literally always so friendly when we go there! This time I had submitted a pickup order, and I was literally in and out in 30 seconds. Food is always good. Great place!Vegetarian options: My go-to is the veggie burger but there are other options as well!“

4.2 Good56 Reviews
Swirls & Twirls Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
248 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 7.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt

“Honestly the best frozen yogurt and the best toppings anywhere! Employees are nice and courteous!!!Kid-friendliness: Always come here after my son and daughter's school concerts. Filled with parents and a lot of kids. The owner and the employees are super professional even with 30+ kids running around .“

4.1 Good74 Reviews

16
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
290 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 7.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocochip Double Layer Chocolate Fudge
Birthday Cake

“I love all the ladies that work at this Carvel. They’re so nice whoever’s doing the hiring there is definitely choosing the best candidates for customer service. They always have a smile on their face or a suggestion for when I’m not sure what I wanna get.Parking: There is a parking lot to park in but if you happen to be there on a busy day, there is a side road and a gas station across the street that has plenty of parking that you are allowed to park on for free. There’s no restrictions. But I’ve never had an issue with parking.Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly! What kid wouldn’t love an ice cream shop plus they have like the sweetest staff that works there“

4.5 Superb24 Reviews

17
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
553 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Hauppauge - 9.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone

“I highly recommend this Carvel! Overall they are a great location. I have had 1 small issue and the owner reached out to me personally. I truly appreciate a owner that puts their customers first. The staff has always been super friendly and the store always looks clean. I will definitely be going back for many years to come.“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews

18
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
2195 Middle Country Rd, Centereach - 4.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“I ordered a custom cake for my brothers 16th birthday and it was amazing ! The woman who helped me was so friendly , and honest. When I told her I wanted black icing, she advised that black is difficult because it needs a bunch of different food coloring and doesn't taste good, so we ended up going with red. She really took her time to make sure we were on the same page and had everything correct. I was worried the picture would look tacky or blurry because its printed but it looked like it was drawn right on the cake. Definitely recommend this service !“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews

19
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$
680 Middle Country Rd, St James - 5.47 miles

“The staff here are all great people. The prices at Carvel are still good too! $7 and change for a large sundae with toppings. Hope this review gets people a raise. Always experience great service and the employees here deserve all the positive recognition they get.“

4.6 Superb19 Reviews

20
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
51 NY-25A, Rocky Point - 7.49 miles

“Ordered a small cake for my husbands birthday. Half vanilla, half pistachio with crunchies in the middle. It was delicious, looked so good and the price wasn’t terrible. So many times i get cakes at other places and it’s decorated poorly and the handwriting looks like it’s done from a toddler. We love carvel, rocky point!“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews

21
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$$
400A Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone

“I started going to this location 2 years ago, for a while I thought that the man helping me was rude and hated his job but once I got him to open up I realized he is hysterical and isn’t much for talking haha. He packs the cones with whatever ice cream and topping your taste buds desire( you can tell this is his favorite part), the service is quick and the facility is clean- what more can you ask for! Give this location and it’s staff members a chance and you won’t be sorry!!“

4.4 Superb23 Reviews
Sweet Mama's American • $$
121 Main St, Stony Brook - 2.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Waffle Fries
The Reuben Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Burger and Fries
Southern Fixin
Belgian Waffle
The Big Daddy
Veggie Wrap
OMG Chicken
Toast

“Went here for dinner last night with a group of six. It was a weeknight so it wasn't;t busy and we were sat right away.The waitress was attentive and helpful even when she was unsure of the answer to our questions about the menu, she made sure to follow up.They had St. Patrick's Day drink specials, non-alcoholic and alcoholic. I wanted to try to coffee specials, but I cannot drink coffee at night. We just ordered a few glasses of wine.We placed our order: I ordered the BBQ Bacon Burger and subbed the beef burger for the turkey burger. It came with lettuce tomato and red onion automatically. I also got sweet potato fries instead of normal fries. I have to say I was impressed with the flavor of the turkey patty; A lot of the time turkey patties don't have a lot of flavor. The sweet potato fries were so yummy.Other things that were ordered were French onion soup, crab cakes, the best burger, onion rings, Cobb salad without blue cheese and add feta, and a kids jumbo hot dog and fries.Everyone said their food was yummy.We each also got dessert. Three of us got the toasted coconut ice cream. SO SO SO SO SO GOOD! Another got scores ice cream and it was so different and tasty. Another ordered mint ice cream and the last ordered the chocolate cake.Everything here was great. The vibe was home-y, the service was top tier, and the food was tasty. Would return here again!“

4 Good81 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices & Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
189 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 7.08 miles

“Five stars because I’m a Ralph’s addict and it’s a nostalgic place for me now.ServiceHigh school kids need weekend and summer jobs. The service is more than acceptable. I wish the Ralph’s mascot would make an appearance here though. I’ve always wanted to see a lemon with a top hat in real life.FlavorsIn a good way, this place is a mess. The flavors are plastered everywhere in long lists. New flavors are randomly placed on pieces of paper on the windows. It’s confusing and daunting to pick a flavor but it works for Ralph’s. The cream ices have a good amount of chunks in them, depending on the flavor. I like anything with peanut butter or chocolate chunks in it. Water ices are flavorful. The Ralphie smoothies are incredible too. Big fan of the triple chocolate Ralphie.PriceIt probably costs as much as ice cream but i it’s less expensive than gelato. Ralph’s is an expensive addiction.Recommend?You should try it.“

4.2 Good31 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices of Nesconset Ice Cream Shop • $$
204 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset - 7.02 miles

“This was my first time visiting this Ralph's location. I was greeted with a very pleasant hi, welcome to Ralph's! It's owner was there and she was wonderful. The store was clean and had so many different options. I took my time and ordered something for everyone in my family. The owner was great and I didn't feel rushed and they helped me by recommending some of the wonderful flavors to offer. They offer ices, cream ices, soft serve and sundaes. Would recommend this location to others looking for a cool treat on a hot day!“

4.1 Good41 Reviews
Bubble Waffle Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop •
52 N Country Rd, Smithtown - 6.59 miles

“My family and I are absolutely obsessed with this place. The owner is super friendly, kind and always greets us when he is there. The staff is super nice, and the place is always clean. Outdoor seating and indoor seating is always available. Weather the place is super busy or not so busy the customer service is always on point. My family and I went to bubble waffle at least 10 times this summer and each time the bubble waffles were fresh. I can’t rave about this place enough. The menu is super easy to read. You create your own ice cream or you can order from the pre fixed menu. Either way the ice cream is amazingly perfect. The portions and toppings are also always on point. We will definitely be coming back.“

4 Good50 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
628 Horseblock Road, Farmingville - 7.45 miles
4.2 Good20 Reviews

27
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
386 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 6.97 miles

“I stopped in for ice cream, and my card kept getting declined, despite there being plenty of money on it. I kept asking the girls to scan the card at the top of the POS machine, and they kept telling me they cannot scan the card until the card was entered into the machine three times. I have never encountered this before.I really think there is a mistake, because the scan option was implemented to protect consumers from having to enter or swipe their cards at a POS machine. I never scan my card at retail establishments anymore; I always scan my card at the top of the machine, and my payment is always accepted. I am never told I need to enter my card three times before scanning.It ends up some lovely woman paid for my ice cream anyway, which I am highly appreciative of.“

3.9 Good62 Reviews
5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles Chicken • $
530 Medford Ave, Patchogue - 10.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Lamb over Rice with Salad and Sauce
Fried Chicken and Waffles
Philly Cheese Steak
Sweet Corn Nuggets
Chicken & Waffles
Side Pasta Salad
Onion Rings
Curly Fries
Quesadilla
Cole Slaw

“Good place service is professional lots of choices. The chicken is delicious. The waffles are freshly made as you order. They come in a paper box with syrup. They also give you some kind of red sauce for the chicken I didn't explore. The chicken didn't need anything, in my opinion. Perfect as is. The downside is parking, only two spots, and on a busy road, it's hard to get in. Finding an alternative and walking a few feet for this chicken is my answer. The cost was under $10 for three pieces and a waffle. They have been the for many years and directly across from KFC, so they are definitely doing something right. It's worth a try.“

3.9 Good58 Reviews
Blue Bean Cafe Coffee Shops • $$
52 N Country Rd, Smithtown - 6.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon and Egg Avocado Toast
Ultimate Avocado Toast
Regular Brewed Coffee
Blue Bean Burger
Drip Coffee
Mocha Latte

“I have nothing, but positive things to say about Blue Bean Cafe. When I used to live in the area, I would work from Blue Bean 2-3 times a week. The ambiance is clean and bright, and the staff and owners are so welcoming. Their strawberry matcha tea latte is to die for! Any time I am in the area I stop in to get it. If you're looking for a little snack, definitely get the garlic roll and make sure to have it toasted. Their bacon and egg avocado toast is also a must try! Blue Bean Cafe is a gem.“

3.9 Good58 Reviews
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices and Icecream Ice Cream Shop • $
1191 Grundy Ave, Holbrook - 9.4 miles

“Ralph's is always a delicious treat! Went to this location today for the first time and it was a great experience. The young lady at the counter was very kind and helpful. Remember to tip them...they work very hard! Ralph, can you stay open all year long!? ?“

4 Good27 Reviews
Ralph’s Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
745 NY-25A, Miller Place - 6.78 miles

“Always an excellent treat- my favorites are strawberry Twisters, chocolate milkshakes, and vanilla soft serve cones, but I definitely need to try more flavors of the Italian ice because I love the ones I've had and so many on the menu sound amazing! The staff are friendly and wonderful, and everything I've ordered at this location has been perfect. There's often a line but for good reason, and it's only a short wait because they are able to process the orders very efficiently :)“

3.8 Good76 Reviews
Port Jefferson Frigate Ice Cream Shop • $$
99 Main St A, Port Jefferson - 2.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Shop

“We’ve always liked this place, but we finally got doggy ice cream for Frida Panda which took our experience to the next level! We had a blast taking pictures and videos of her enjoying it. The staff were very friendly and explained how their doggy ice cream is made from safe products like cheese and peanut butter.??♥️Unfortunately, dogs can’t go inside the store, but they have a great selection of dog treats in addition to the ice cream cones.Parking: It’s easy to find parking during the off season. We usually pay for parking near the dog park by the beach and walk over to avoid the crowds when it starts to get busy ?“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor Ice Cream Shop • $$
153 N Country Rd, Miller Place - 5.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
Black Raspberry Truffle
Root Beer Float

“A cute mom n pop ice cream shop that is super kid friendly and popular with everyone in the neighborhood. They are open quite late too, so I can even pick up a pint on my way home. A ton of flavors and options.Parking: Small parking lot and street parking is available. Can get a little crowded during the summer afternoon rush. Have to be a little careful of all the kids in the area.Kid-friendliness: I have seen everything from baseball teams to birthday parties at this venue.“

3.8 Good65 Reviews
Friendly's American • $
553 Hawkins Ave, Ronkonkoma - 6.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own - Medium Sundae
Big Kids' Mozzarella Sticks
Eggs over Easy with Pancakes
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Crispy Chicken Salad
Tossed Garden Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
100 000 Cobb Salad
Ice Cream Sundaes
Kid's Fribble

“This was a great place to take a 1 and 2 year old for a nice lunch. The prices were reasonable, there are a lot of options for kids, and the service was quick and attentive. Not to mention the food was way better than expected. Will definitely be going back.“

3.7 Good90 Reviews
Ralphs of Port Jeff Ice Cream Shop • $
112 Main St, Port Jefferson - 2.09 miles

“After seeing many people, enjoying their ices, we decided we would try it out. Ralph's offered a large variety of flavors that seemed to be full of excessive sugar. The gal at the counter was helpful and efficient. The store could use a good cleaning. The ices were good, but not as good as we are used to having in our local area.“

3.7 Good87 Reviews
Yogomania-Medford Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
2717 NY-112, Medford - 9.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Acai Bowl

“Seems like all of a sudden there is a lack of frozen yogurt spots where I live. This one was really nice. The guy working there is friendly, lots of toppings and flavors to choose from. The pricing is on par with other froyo shops. Expensive but they all are. Figure a large cup with toppings around $8“

3.8 Good29 Reviews

37
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $$
480 Patchogue-Holbrook Rd, Holbrook - 9.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cake

“So I ordered a soft serve that I thought my daughter would want(was made) but as I was in the store she called and asked for a different flavor. So like any dad would do, I told her that flavor wasn't working..yup..deek move...Victoria heard my conversation and said she would make the one my daughter wanted and save the one already made for someone else. She was extremely thoughtful and nice. Glad to see some people are still understandable. Victoria btw, that twist was below average, you were right.“

3.8 Good13 Reviews
YoGoMania Frozen Yogurts, ACAI Bowls, Bubble Teas and Smoothies Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
315 Main St, Holbrook - 8.24 miles

“Went here on a whim during the summer and had an overall good experience. It is your run-of-the-mill suburban yogurt place. They have good yogurt and toppings. The flavors are not overly sweet and the ability to customize it in countless ways, so you could theoretically try something new every time you are here. The place is unique in that it also offers açaí bowls, which I did not expect. The decor is outdated, but also kinda has a nostalgic aspect to it. It is conveniently located in Holbrook. The staff are very friendly and courteous. Plenty of parking in the complex. Pricing is fair.“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Sonic Drive-In Fast Food • $
2900 Middle Country Rd, Nesconset - 4.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Classic Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara
Philly Cheesesteak
Sonic Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger Combo
Tots with Chili
Grilled Cheese
Chilli Cheese
Onion Rings
Sonic Blast

“Sonic is a milkshake paradise! The flavors are amazing, and the shakes are irresistibly tasty. Friendly service and the nostalgic drive-in experience make it a 5-star treat for anyone with a sweet tooth. Sonic's milkshakes are a must-try delight!“

3.6 Good56 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
594 Middle Country Rd, St James - 5.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger Combo & Sundae
Chicken Tenders and Fries
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy Chicken Strips
Vainilla Sundae
Blizzard Cake
Onion Rings
Cheese Curds

“Open on thanksgiving was definitely helpful after a long ride home. McDonald all closed. Daughter had her fries. My wife had chicken strips and me a chili dog. All on point. The dog was the best hot dog in the fast food game next to nathans.“

3.6 Good52 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
1694 Islip Ave, Brentwood - 11.64 miles

“The best thing about this location is that they offer 2 for 1 sundaes. I visited this place after a long time but was disappointed at that all chairs were removed. Can't understand this logic when there are no Covid related alerts on Long Island.“

3.5 Good31 Reviews
Loading...
map Map