New American Restaurants near Setauket East Setauket, NY

Vincents_NYWF_Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $$$
384 Mark Tree Rd, Setauket- East Setauket

Customers` Favorites

Long Island Style Bacon Egg
The Manhattan Pizza
The Brooklyn Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Suffolk Pizza
The Nassau Pizza
The Bronx Pizza
Margarita Pie
Staten Island
The East End

“I’ve done the “One Bite” tour around Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Long Island—I’ve gone to the hole-in-the-wall word-of-mouthers, too. Vincent’s Pizza Truck is undoubtedly up there with the best of them. The plain pie is perfectly dressed; the crust, thoughtfully caramelized with the right hint of char. Expect a crisp bite with great chew and the right balance of sauce to cheese to top a pie as thin as these. Do not skip out on an opportunity to eat here. The staff is always friendly and well-spirited, really rounding out the experience as a whole.“

4.9 Superb80 Reviews
eatMOSAIC New American
418 N Country Rd, St James

Customers` Favorites

Trio of Desserts
Duck Breast
House Bread
Gazpacho
Steak
Soup

“I absolutely adored this restaurant. 10/10.One of my biggest pet peeves with restaurants is their bathrooms. Pleasantly surprised with the decor and cleanliness. I took pictures to share.The staff was patient and helpful, on point with drink refills and everyone had a great additude/tone.Officially one of my favorites in all of New York.“

4.6 Superb212 Reviews

3
Noco

Noco American • $$$
429 N Country Rd, St James

Customers` Favorites

Nuttela Cake with Nuttela Gelato
House-Made Ravioli Florentine
Crescent Farms Duck Breast
Shrimp & Crab Spaghettini
Lemon Ricotta Cheesecake
Wild Boar Meatloaf
Day Boat Scallops
Spanish Octopus
Chocolate Cake
Noco Salad

“I really wish I had taken pictures of the food because it was not only extraordinarily delicious, but played beautifully! I got the filet mignon and my partner got the pork rib roast. Both were out of this world. Our server was so friendly, and all the staff were on top of everything. We had a miscommunication on something and the manager made sure everything was rectified right away. AND they gave everyone long stemmed roses as a token for Valentine's Day. It was honestly the best Valentine's Day dining experience I've had in a long time. I certainly recommend this establishment!“

4.6 Superb255 Reviews
Husk and Vine Kitchen and Cocktails American • $$
655 Middle Country Rd, St James

Customers` Favorites

Tempura Bang Bang Shrimp Street Noodle Bowl
Mediterranian Olive Hummus Appitizer
Asian Style Kobe Beef Meatballs
Bang Bang Shrimp and Noodle
Asian Style Kobe Meatballs
The Wagyu Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Style Pretzels
Giant Meatball
Sea Bass Tacos

“Last night I went to Husk and Vine with my husband and 4 others in our party. We went for a special birthday celebration and Husk and Vine did not disappoint. The food was amazing, the drinks absolutely delicious and the service was like a well orchestrated show. I can’t pick just one favorite dish because so many were just as good as the next! Well done Husk and Vine in making a night one to be remembered for all the right reasons!“

4.4 Superb261 Reviews
Prohibition Port Jefferson American • $$
115 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Waffle
Breakfast Burger
PBJ Wings

“We don't come often because it can be a bit pricey but the food is delicious. Our favorite appetizer is the mac and cheese wonton. They also make it as a mashed potato wonton seasonally. Both are absolutely worth every bite. The cheese sauce is fire.Inside is small and cozy. The staff is super friendly. Sometimes they take a little longer than needed to come back to check in but not a big deal, it could be my concept of time is skewed, haha.Definitely recommend trying Prohibition Kitchen; you won't be disappointed.“

4.4 Superb280 Reviews
Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson New American • $$$
318 Wynn Ln, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Marinated Flat Iron Steak
Roasted Organic Salmon
S'Mores Brownie Sundae
The Old Fields Burger
Blue Point Oysters
French Onion Soup
Mashed Potatoes
Zucchini Chips
Fried Chicken
Skirt Steak

“Visited for dinner on a Saturday night. Started by ordering drinks, Bourb-Berry and their cider cinnamon drink. Both were extremely enjoyable and tasty, a good size drink without been overpriced. For starters we shared the buttermilk fried chicken which was very satisfying and a good portion to share between 2 people. Our main meals were their old fields burger and squid ink linguine. Both meals were great and very tasteful. Service was very good, our waiter was very friendly and visited our table often to ensure everything was up to our liking. I would highly recommend giving this restaurant a try if you are in the area.“

4.3 Superb266 Reviews
Country House New American • $$$
1175 N Country Rd, Stony Brook

Customers` Favorites

Seared Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
Bone in Braised Short Rib
Chicken Cordon Bleu
French Onion Soup
Chocolate Mousse
Chicken Francese
Stuffed Shrimp
Creme Brulee
Surf and Turf

“Went the last day of Christmas decorations. Very nice.Everyone enjoyed their food. Only complaint was the eggplant rollatini. Menu said they had a vegetable plate for vegetarians but it wasn't available.Vegetarian options: Not enough selection“

4.1 Good222 Reviews
Loading...

Setauket East Setauket’s related cuisines

map Map