I love Setauket Gourmet Deli. I eat here at least twice per week and have done so for the last five years I have lived in Setauket. The staff are awesome, friendly, very efficient, and care a lot about their customers. Last week I arrived right after the UNC Lacrosse team and took my place at the end of a very long line. I was absolutely amazed at how productive and friendly they were in feeding so many hungry lacrosse players. I have to say to everyone at Setauket Gourmet Deli, keep up the great work, you are awesome and don't ever change!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Gelberg
The deli help were very rude when he ordered a butter roll in place of the toast thank came with our breakfast. In other words they called him a liar when he was charged for the butter roll replacement. One of the clerks said we never replacethe toast with a roll even though they have done it multiple times in the past. Will not be coming back..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Shady Creek PammyC
Grew up going to this deli, it's always great. Moved away 16 years ago and Have to stop in Every time we are here! Egg sandwiches are always done right, Italian hero and all varieties of heroes are amazing. Friendly attententive staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tara Dreuer
Our office ordered off Uber Eats for Lunch today and the order was never delivered. We reordered and Bill from Setauket Gourmet called to see what happened when he recognized the same order come in again. He apologized (even when it was not their fault) and remade the order right away. Great customer service!! Food was delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Montesano
For the last couple of years now the effort and accuracy of take-out orders have been frequently wrong. Constant mistakes with simple orders. I am sure that I am not the only one.
Fran G.
This deli does excellent catering. We just catered our first party with setauket gourmet deli. The food was delicious. Delivered right on time. We also had a server from this deli for our party and lidia was great. We definitely will plan our next party using setauket gourmet deli again. The staff was exceptional. Thanks for making our party a big success.
Wendy S.
Sandwich just had stale rolls for both of our sandwiches! Very disappointed in this deli. Just moved to the area and was hoping to find our go to deli.
Amy Negri
I highly recommend Setauket Gourmet Deli! Not only is their food (in-person and catering) delicious and fresh, but the staff and owners are incredibly kind and honest. I accidentally left my purse/wallet at one of their tables ?The owner (Lyn) held onto it for over 24 hours and went out of her way to find me. She looked extensively online until she found me and immediately contacted me when she did. When I got there to claim my purse, she and her staff were incredibly kind and generous to me and my 3 little children. It felt like we were with family! What can I say, let’s give them as much business as we can! I am so grateful
Andrew Ambrosio
Awesome staff & service. Ordered a few different trays for our residential apartment community, and the spread was fantastic & fresh!!10/10 Recommend !
Brian
I drive Lyft and stop at many different places for food in my travels. I ordered the Healthy Breakfast Wrap and it was outstanding. The employees were friendly as well. I highly recommend and will keep this place in mind for when I am in the area.
I love these guys. Great food, great attitude, great breakfast sandwiches. The two Bill's are amazing guys. I always visit when I'm in town visiting my dad..Bill knows how I like my Pastami bacon and egg sandwich.See you guys next time I'm in.
Daniel B Grogul
As delis go, this is a premium experience. Great menu and choices. The only con is parking is limited.
Jocelyn Marden
Greeted the guy behind us within seconds but ignored us two women for about five minutes and were rude as hell.
Bob D.
I have been coming here for many years. Always a good experience no matter what time of day. I just had a Protein Bowl for lunch. It was excellent!Kudos to Billy for making this and other meals for me. He always greets me by name and goes out of his way to make sure my meal is prepared on time and the way I like it. Thank you Billy! I encourage you to check them out if you have not done so already. You will not be disappointed. Bob D.East Setauket
Dan
I have been really trying to support them but the new ownership just isn't good. It's gone so far down hill I'm not sure they'll be there much longer.
I love Setauket Gourmet Deli. I eat here at least twice per week and have done so for the last five years I have lived in Setauket. The staff are awesome, friendly, very efficient, and care a lot about their customers. Last week I arrived right after the UNC Lacrosse team and took my place at the end of a very long line. I was absolutely amazed at how productive and friendly they were in feeding so many hungry lacrosse players. I have to say to everyone at Setauket Gourmet Deli, keep up the great work, you are awesome and don't ever change!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The deli help were very rude when he ordered a butter roll in place of the toast thank came with our breakfast. In other words they called him a liar when he was charged for the butter roll replacement. One of the clerks said we never replacethe toast with a roll even though they have done it multiple times in the past. Will not be coming back..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Grew up going to this deli, it's always great. Moved away 16 years ago and Have to stop in Every time we are here! Egg sandwiches are always done right, Italian hero and all varieties of heroes are amazing. Friendly attententive staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our office ordered off Uber Eats for Lunch today and the order was never delivered. We reordered and Bill from Setauket Gourmet called to see what happened when he recognized the same order come in again. He apologized (even when it was not their fault) and remade the order right away. Great customer service!! Food was delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5
For the last couple of years now the effort and accuracy of take-out orders have been frequently wrong. Constant mistakes with simple orders. I am sure that I am not the only one.
This deli does excellent catering. We just catered our first party with setauket gourmet deli. The food was delicious. Delivered right on time. We also had a server from this deli for our party and lidia was great. We definitely will plan our next party using setauket gourmet deli again. The staff was exceptional. Thanks for making our party a big success.
Sandwich just had stale rolls for both of our sandwiches! Very disappointed in this deli. Just moved to the area and was hoping to find our go to deli.
I highly recommend Setauket Gourmet Deli! Not only is their food (in-person and catering) delicious and fresh, but the staff and owners are incredibly kind and honest. I accidentally left my purse/wallet at one of their tables ?The owner (Lyn) held onto it for over 24 hours and went out of her way to find me. She looked extensively online until she found me and immediately contacted me when she did. When I got there to claim my purse, she and her staff were incredibly kind and generous to me and my 3 little children. It felt like we were with family! What can I say, let’s give them as much business as we can! I am so grateful
Awesome staff & service. Ordered a few different trays for our residential apartment community, and the spread was fantastic & fresh!!10/10 Recommend !
I drive Lyft and stop at many different places for food in my travels. I ordered the Healthy Breakfast Wrap and it was outstanding. The employees were friendly as well. I highly recommend and will keep this place in mind for when I am in the area.
Restaurantji Recommends
I love these guys. Great food, great attitude, great breakfast sandwiches. The two Bill's are amazing guys. I always visit when I'm in town visiting my dad..Bill knows how I like my Pastami bacon and egg sandwich.See you guys next time I'm in.
As delis go, this is a premium experience. Great menu and choices. The only con is parking is limited.
Greeted the guy behind us within seconds but ignored us two women for about five minutes and were rude as hell.
I have been coming here for many years. Always a good experience no matter what time of day. I just had a Protein Bowl for lunch. It was excellent!Kudos to Billy for making this and other meals for me. He always greets me by name and goes out of his way to make sure my meal is prepared on time and the way I like it. Thank you Billy! I encourage you to check them out if you have not done so already. You will not be disappointed. Bob D.East Setauket
I have been really trying to support them but the new ownership just isn't good. It's gone so far down hill I'm not sure they'll be there much longer.