Strathmore Bagels

1365-1384 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket
(631) 675-6943

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dan S.

I’ve been getting bagels here since the early 2000s. Their bagels are my favorite, tighter and denser than a lot of other places in the area, which I prefer. Their bagel sandwiches are delicious.Coffee could be stronger and hotter though, and it’s more expensive than the competition. I remember when the bagel sandwiches were like 5+ dollars, now they’re almost 11. I realize everything in the area has gone up, though, so it is what it is.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Kristin Kapp

The bagels aren't shiny and aren't chewy. Enough said.

Kevin D

Good bagels; very weak coffee

Crystina Sorrenti

I’ve been going here for a while because it’s right down the block from my house but I will no longer visit after my most recent experience. Went to pickup my order 15 minutes after I placed it like they asked. I showed up and there was only a couple other in front of me, with about 5 employees behind the counter and I still waited about 15 minutes although I called my order in advance. it was very expensive, and the food was barely warm. The cheese on my egg sandwiches weren’t even melted that’s how cold it was. Food was mediocre and small portions for the price. Most of the young workers are nice but the older women is nasty. Tables looked like they’ve never been wiped and when I tell you this place is FILTHY, I mean it. Crumbs & guck in the track of the sliding doors to the refrigerator & inside the fridge where they store cream cheese, etc. is so built up & close to open containers of cream cheese. The overall atmosphere is rundown, dirty, &cheap. If you take a good look around while waiting you can see just how filthy this place is. I will no longer be bringing my business here. Would give 0 stars if I could

Sonic Race

Overpriced. Took way too long. Weak food. Never going back, and I live right down the street.

Christopher Bowen

Very good bagels and sandwiches with excellent ice tea.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Ricky Kalendarov

They are nice and bagels are decent, but I wish they were more hygienic!!! They use the same gloves to charge you money, touch the cash register and rub their face with the same gloves they will make your bagel with cmon guys, we just got out of COVID. You can do better than that. Disappointing.

Keegan Blaney

Just not that good.

Nobody

I asked for a toasted egg bagel with butter and a chocolate chocolate chip muffin. What i recieved was a cold buttered egg bagel and a chocolate chip muffin. I didnt notice till i got home. The good thing is that my 3 year old only flipped out for 20 minutes. I will def. Be coming back bc I am always impressed by great service.

cameron bosch

Very nice staff, but extremely disorganized and absurdly overpriced. I paid almost $11 for a bacon egg and cheese on a roll! There are much better options right down the street, which charge far less.

Brittany McClung

When you get charged $5 for a bagels and this is what you get...

Kris McCarthy

Great bagels, good prices

Amanda Morris

The bagels and egg sandwiches are very good. The biggest surprise though is the iced tea. Honestly, it's better than Se-Port. The perfect blend of sweet and lemony. Just check the hours before you go because they can be weird.

Joseph Sedlak

All is good matter what you get doesn't burn a hole in your pocket the prices are good everybody is very nice I eat there almost everyday

Carol Spanning

Stopped in early one morning about a month ago. Ordered a bacon, egg and cheese on a sesame bagel. Sandwich was extremely disappointing and tasteless. Place is dinghy. Never again.

Loading...