Horseman bagels
276a N Broadway, Sleepy Hollow
(914) 373-2788
Customers' Favorites
Everything Bagel with Bacon Egg and Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Bagel
Pumpernickel Everything Bagel
Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese
Dulce De Ifche Muffin
Breakfast Sandwiches
Bakers Dozen Bagels
Strawberry Muffin
Cinnamon Raisin
Whitefish Salad
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Highly recommend! We were traveling from VA to ME and stopped by Sleepy Hollow for the night. Picked up bagels the next morning to continue our trip north. We loved them so much, we stopped on our way back to VA. The bagels, cream cheeses, and of course the husband and wife duo make this place a must stop. We will be back to Sleepy Hollow and back to Horseman Bagels. 🥰😋
Bagels were very big, with a crunchy exterior and soft inside. Vegetable cream cheese was delicious and fresh with small crunchy peppers and vegetables in it. This was our first experience having bagels in the Hudson Valley region and exceeded our expectations. Cute town and signage for the bagel shop.
Best Bagels Ever!
As a visitor from Los Angeles, I've eaten a lot of bagels, but this Sleepy Hollow spot is the absolute best! The owner and his son are incredibly friendly, making you feel right at home.
The bagels are amazing – huge, delicious, and so flavorful. You get a ton of food for your money, and the prices are fantastic. The staff are super friendly and quick too. I even brought some back to LA, and I wish I could've brought more to have...
As a visitor from Los Angeles, I've eaten a lot of bagels, but this Sleepy Hollow spot is the absolute best! The owner and his son are incredibly friendly, making you feel right at home.
The bagels are amazing – huge, delicious, and so flavorful. You get a ton of food for your money, and the prices are fantastic. The staff are super friendly and quick too. I even brought some back to LA, and I wish I could've brought more to have...
You May Also Like
J & G Italian Deli - 23 Beekman Ave
![]()
Deli, Coffee & Tea
The taco club - 31 Beekman Ave
![]()
Tacos, Mexican