BAGEL CITY CO.

1209 NY-25A, Smithtown
(631) 257-5670

Recent Reviews

Sort by
William

I ordered through doordash; The custom options I chose for the egg sandwich were on point. The hero roll was just right (fresh and not too hard or dry) Having breakfast food delivered can be iffy (at your own risk) but the Hungryman I ordered from Bagel City Co. was excellent, best I've had since moving to the Smithtown area.

Food: 5

Service: 5

H M

Would eat here again, good bagel sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Sal Mistretta

Excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Linda Mcdonald

Omg this place it clean as a whistle. Most important is excellent food. . I get a mini bagel n egg n sausage and it is excellent. . Cravable

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Guardado

The daily bagel spot! Very polite and great service overall. The drive thru is a game changer. Always consistent.

Nicholas Baldassarre

Love this spot! We call it “The Bagel Bank”. They make great egg sandwiches and their bacon is well done. Call-ahead for drive-through-service which is super cool! Bagels and their chicken salads are great!

Adulteducation8

Everyone there is so nice, their sandwiches are the best! I’m in there almost every day, as I call my order in - 3 egg whites made dry, with ketchup, on whole wheat bread. And when I get there maybe 20-30 minutes later, it’s there, waiting for me. And if I order it before 11am, it comes with a small coffee Monday-Friday. Their tuna is very good too. No attitudes, very nice, friendly, and accommodating. Very clean inside, the bathroom shines as well. Highly recommended!- Ronn D. from Kings Park, NY

M Henigman

Nice renovated store. Used to be two be banks actually. Some bank story, final bank got robbed and property went up for sale. Bagel shop was a good choice and a good location for people commuting West for work. My only real problem is cost. $10 for a bacon, egg, and cheese is STEEP, no matter how well made. There are other bagel shops on the same route that make better bagels and are cheaper, but I won't take away from a good effort at a reasonable start up. They deserve support and while it's unlikely their pricing will go down, local shops deserve business rather than the Starbucks monster that is killing all morning business.

Joseph Hessel

Awesome place

Holly Bruno

BEC is delicious. Clean bathrooms. Friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel Sandwich, Egg Sandwich

Jeffrey Fountain

I usually got a sandwiches from here and they're okay. But today I got a veggie omelet with a side of bacon. After I paid for my meal The guy that took my order comes back and says oh I think she rang you up wrong. So I said double check and make it's right, I don't want a free lunch. He then proceeds to tell me that he wasn't worried about it. But then feels inclined to tell me how I should tell the cashier what I ordered after I told her exactly what I got.
I don't know where this person got the audacity to tell me the customer what I need to do. If anybody should get reprimanded is the employee after I leave not in front of me.
Answer for the price of 1979 I got a bottle of water and I'll let that had hardly any eggs in it and some bacon. Instead of giving me towellets and a fistful of napkins put some food on the plate.

Emma

Saves me many of mornings when I didn’t have time to make breakfast

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flavored Cream Cheese on a Bagel

David Goddard II

It got better

D

Great spot. Just the tipping screen is unnecessary

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Joseph Burgarello

Food is always delicious and fresh …

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...