Elegant Eating

739 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown
(631) 360-2211

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sara Lutterbie

Excellent service both before and during the event. The food was delicious and attractively presented. I would definitely recommend Elegant Eating, and would use them again in a heartbeat.

Joanne Budah

Perfection! Neil was extremely helpful and knowledgable. The food was outstanding!!! Our guests could not get over how delicious everything was. The service was amazing, Barbara and her team could not have been better. She anticipated some of the needs of our guests who were vegetarian and remembered who they were! I cannot say enough about the quality and service we experienced. I would highly recommend.

Kai Wong

They do a weekly cater for my work. The quality of their food is consistently outstanding. My only wish is that they would use paper-based food packaging for individual meals.

Racine Salon & Spa

I had the pleasure of experiencing Elegant Eating Caterer’s exceptional service at the Racine Salon and Spa’s 30th anniversary celebration, and I can’t recommend them highly enough! From start to finish, their team went above and beyond to ensure every detail was perfect.

The food was nothing short of spectacular—each dish was a beautiful presentation and a burst of flavor. They offered a delightful variety of options that pleased every palate, and the quality of the ingredients truly shone through. The staff were professional, courteous, and attentive, ensuring that every guest felt pampered and well taken care of.

The level of organization and attention to detail demonstrated by Elegant Eating Caterer made the event seamless and stress-free. Their creativity and dedication to excellence were evident in every aspect of the service. If you’re looking for a caterer who will elevate your event to the next level, Elegant Eating Caterer is your go-to choice!

Diana Gallo

Elegant Eating catered our Thanksgiving this year. The food came with easy to follow directions heating, etc. and was delicious. We are very satisfied customers. Highly recommend… Thank you Neil and Myra Sincerely, Diana & Mike Gallo

Michael Donahue

I’ve been hiring Elegant Eating for my catering services for over the past 15 years since I’ve moved back from NYC to my LI roots. Their food, presentation and staff are outstanding. Irreplaceable attention to ALL details ! I now consider Neil (the owner) a friend and he continues to surprise and impress me with their newest menu selections and details! My standards are high and Elegant Eating continues to impress me year after year !

Kat Ciocia

Just had my daughters bridal shower this weekend. Everything was so delicious and Barbara and Linda were amazing waitresses. I highly recommend Elegant eating.

Olivia Gassner

Amazing experience. They were so incredibly helpful, helping our family during a tough time with a quick turnaround. Food was beautiful. The sample menus really helped. Thank you!

Kathy D

Words cannot describe how perfect my daughters shower turned out in large part to your amazing food and even more so your amazing staff! Guests were wowed with the passed items and then the crepe station was just beyond! The ladies,I think Linda,Diane and Heidi were like old friends! So many guests remarked on how they just loved them! I’m attaching some photos but just want you to know I will never use another caterer!! Kathy Ditta

Rachel & Evan Lewis

Elegant Eating did a marvelous job catering my rehearsal dinner! We wanted to host it at home and they made it so easy. Their team brought the food in, set it up, served, and cleaned up seamlessly so that we could relax and enjoy it. All of the food and drinks were excellent and the entire experience was exactly what we were looking for and Linda, Kevin, and Magdalena were especially professional and wonderful.

Lisa Minuto

Elegant Eating is simply the best for catering! I hosted a bridal shower at my home, and I could not have been happier with the total experience. Their guidance on food selection and professional expertise helped make hosting the party so easy. The food was presented in beautiful displays of my choices, and everything was so delicious!!! They are my go-to resource for catering!

Rachel Liebert

Elegant Eating did a marvelous job catering my rehearsal dinner! We wanted to host it at home and they made it so easy. Their team brought the food in, set it up, served, and cleaned up seamlessly so that we could relax and enjoy it. All of the food and drinks were excellent and the entire experience was exactly what we were looking for and Linda, Kevin, and Magdalena were especially professional and wonderful.

Rachel Liebert Lewis

Elegant Eating did a marvelous job catering my rehearsal dinner! We wanted to host it at home and they made it so easy. Their team brought the food in, set it up, served, and cleaned up seamlessly so that we could relax and enjoy it. All of the food and drinks were excellent and the entire experience was exactly what we were looking for and Linda, Kevin, and Magdalena were especially professional and wonderful.

Diana Gallo

This past Saturday, August 27th our family and friends enjoyed a wonderful backyard party. Thanks to Neil and his amazing staff at Elegant Eating our guests were treated to the best and most delicious display of food we could have hoped for. To start we enjoyed a tastefully done grazing platter. The main course; an artful display of grilled chicken and crusted beef tenderloin, pasta salad, mozzarella and tomato platter and a garden salad. Dessert was a fresh fruit salad along with mini cakes. Thank you so much Elegant Eating, wonderful people, excellent service and awesome food. Sincerely, Diana and Mike Gallo

Jeannine Carlo

I cannot say enough wonderful things about Elegant Eating!! They catered by sister’s 50th birthday, and it was absolutely OUTSTANDING!!! From the beginning, with the planning, Cary was joyful, helpful, and soo knowledgeable!!! The food was beyond EXCELLENT and the STAFF WAS EXCEPTIONAL!!! I couldn’t have done this without them. They were highly professional, efficient and friendly. By the end of the night, I felt as if they were family. Impressive is an understatement. Bravo Elegant Eating!! Bravo!!!!

Loading...