Pietro Cucina Italiana
404 N Country Rd, Smithtown
(631) 862-6129
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
One of our favorite restaurants. Food is outstanding, cocktails are delicious and service is great. Pietro welcomes all his customers with a smile. Highly recommend this gem of a place.
Excellent happy hour, offered not only at the bar but at tables on their covered terrace as well. The happy hour menu had a baked Rigatoni with sausage meat that was wonderful with a glass of Montepucciano , Both were delicious . Every time we come here, it ie a wonderful experience. Don't miss their home made Lemoncello after dinner.PERFECTO! My new fave!
Delicious food, excellent service, and just a lovely place to relax and enjoy a great evening. The outdoor space is so pretty too.
Delicious food; thoughtfully prepared. Sean was our waiter and we would rate him a 10 out of 10. We can't wait to return to try other items on the menu.
Absolutely wonderful!! Everything was perfect. The food was delicious! The outdoor seating was beautiful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always delicious. We come here all the time. Authentic Italian Food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful food and service. Drinks were spot on. Bartender was very nice and took care in making a delicious drink. The pancetta appetizer, short rib ragu, and the fish were all so delicious. A delightful evening. We will be back.
It is always an exceptional experience at Pietro Cucina, Staff is wonderful, food is amazing and we always have a l memorable dining experience.
Amazing food and sery as always! I do hope they would bring back the truffle gnocchi to the new menu! It was a family favorite
The owner needs to be more attentive to the service. The food is very tasty but the mixed drinks are poorly made.
Restaurantji Recommends
Had dinner last Saturday night. Upon arriving I was offered an inside table or outside. Ask the owner what he suggested and he said summer short eat outside and how right he was.Nice breeze. Relatively quiet since the sound was not confined. Music was soft and relaxing and of course the star was the food and the service that we received. He's done a great job in running his restaurant
Always a great dining experience here. Food and atmosphere are great. Especially in summer when you can sit outside.
My family and I have eaten at Pietro many times over the past 10 years. We've slowly seen the decline with hopes things would change but our last visit will be our last. While the staff is always pleasant, the food was just not edible. Starting with drinks, a simple aperol spritz had a smidge of aperol and was mainly seltzer. As I asked our waiter to add more Aperol, I watched the bartender and another waiter fish out food particles from another customers martini that was about to be served. We always order the fritto misto, this time it was barely cooked and so oily when you bit into each piece. Rice balls, we're good and consistent to what we expected. I had the pasta special - troffa with butternut squash. It was swimming in oil and I was so turned off. I'll add the menu seemed off season and no effort to update to spring or summer at this point. My daughters each also had different pasta dishes; the papperdalle, which we've had many times but again overly oily tasting masking the meat flavor and the tortelloni in a “light” cream sauce. The sauce was so thick and heavy and again, not edible. My husband had the NY strip steak and he liked it and it was prepared well. We left very disappointed, especially for the amount we spent. Quality and preparation are seriously lacking - and I'm surprised because the owner is always there, very engaged and seems like her cares. Pietro, please take a hard and honest look at how these dishes are prepared and served. While other quality Italian establishments are opening in the area at the same price point, there is a big difference.
My husband & I went for dinner last night and had the specials: shrimp ceviche it was delicious! The watermelon salad was delicious also! They need to put both dishes on the regular menu, I would have that everyday it was so good… also had the buccatini ala americana it was very good also jut too much tomatoe sauce for me but still very good.. would come back again & again and tell all my friends about the food😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and drinks were outstanding!!
Loading...