Pietro Cucina Italiana

404 N Country Rd, Smithtown
(631) 862-6129

Recent Reviews

Tom Morganelli

The food here is excellent, the staff is very friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

P B

Great. Definitely more like a 4.6-4.7…

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Engels

The type of real Italian atmosphere from a family run restaurant you're looking for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rick Woods

Have been there several times, every time I return it seems to get better and better

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Cutlet Parmesan, Pappardelle Bolognese

Karen Smith

We had a wonderful time last night at your restaurant! The food was delicious and service was impeccable thank you!

Pete Smith

Went here for the first time last night with my family. Food was pretty good and the staff was friendly. Only complaint I have is the prices are ridiculous for the portion sizes in my opinion. $30 for ~dozen gnocchi with some mushrooms and truffle sauce is kinda crazy. I left still feeling hungry. I don't think I'd come

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Joseph Picarello

?Parking: ?Wheelchair accessibility: ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Burrata Salad with Prosutto, Veal Cutlet Parmesan, Veal Chop

SilviaB

Not sure if it was because they were booked for Valentines Day but I felt completely rushed and dismissed and the whole meal. When we got in and waited for someone to seat us (we had reservations) another couple came in that everyone seemed to know. Not one person greeted us and when they did finally see us, they told us to wait and took the other couple to their seat. When we sat down and took a look at the menu, the waiter came and said we had to put in both apps and entrees at once. So we felt very rushed because we only wanted to start with apps. Everything we had looked like they had been cooked earlier and then heated up, so it came out semi warm and not hot, probably due to assuming they'd be busy. I was so disappointed because I had def been looking forward to trying it and just felt let down.

Foodie

What a disappointing meal. Started out great because I loved my white Sangria and the bread was hot and delicious. Then had delicious artichoke salad. So we were excited. Caesar salad was very fishy and I like anchovies. But this was over the top. My husband got the short rib pasta with pappardelle. There was ZERO short rib in it. And I mean ZERO. I got the linguini in a “light” sauce with fresh tomatoes. It was the same thick red sauce like the short rib sauce, very few tiny clams. And was so salty that I couldn't even eat it. We did not eat our pasta at all. The waiter was embarassed and felt so bad. He offered to have us order something else but we just got the tiramisu and asked for cappucino, which they don't have!!!! They did the right thing and didn't charge us for the pasta or dessert. Left the waiter a nice tip, but we will not be back.

liketodineout

Loud, hot and crowded! Such a disappointment. Reservations were for 7pm and we waited until 8:00 to be seated while shuffling around a crowded bar area between servers running around and propane heat lamps! The owner himself knocked into me more than once causing me to spill my drink. Never again will I waste my Saturday on such a stressful, expensive experience!

Annalisa Fasano

I have to say that I was higly disappointed. Although the food wasn't bad, the prices didn't justify the quality or the service. Our waiter was neither knowledgeable nor attentive. He paid attention to I guess regulars than to be customers.We had the fried polenta which was a $20 appetizer. Don't try to pass grits as polenta. They are not the same.We were told upon making reservations that they are very accommodating towards food allergies, which is not true. I would think that a restaurant with those prices be able to prepare a meal made to order. This is something that I'm able to get at restaurants that aren't as nearly as expensive. This is very disturbing.I cross an Italian restaurant off my list when I try to order something although I have a particular allergy and the waiter says "what do you expect from an Italian restaurant?" What do I expect? I expect to be accommodated. Poor service.Very disappointed to say the least. Would not go backAlso. The bill didn't seem to correct but by that point we just wanted to get out.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Rita Fasano

The restaurant didn't really accommodate my allergy even though I was told when I made the reservation that there would be no problem. I ended up ordering the NY strip which was fair at best. The Outback does it much better.There are certainly many regulars who go here and the owner and wait staff are very attentive to them, comping them dessert and limoncello. We, first time guests, were offered nothing. We will not be second time guests

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Lisa Paradiso

I'm Italian and I can confirm that I ate really well, the arancini were really excellent as was the pappardelle with ragù. The owner is Italian and the staff were professional friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant, I will definitely return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

bgarcia171

Wish I had found this place sooner! What a wonderful dining experience, and the food was delicious. Staff was so attentive from the owner to the waiter to the wait staff, all top-notch! This will be our new go-to for romantic just-us dinners and special occasions. Leave the kids at home and treat yourselves. You will not be disappointed!

Tony Pollina

Bit noisy..but it was Christmas Eve. Dises sizable..service very goodKid-friendliness: Server very good with kids in spite of being busy, croweded and having hot coffee spilled on her in the kitchen!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veal Chop

Load More