I love Freddy and the bagels are amazing, colin did a great job!
Steven Halem
Nice place. Very happy customer. Great food too.
Richard
05/18/20 Ordered two bagels & egg sandwiches. Server was freindly but did not fulfill order accurately. Both bagels were not toasted as requested and the sandwiches were not hot when brought to us. Coffee was mediocre also. First and last time I will be there. It was a Sunday mornng and not crowded. We should have taken that as a warning sign. I do not recommend.
Beth Jilkins
I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and when I got my order, there was a huge circle in the middle just gone. Thought I was getting my moneys worth here but clearly they decided to cut me short by putting a circle in the middle. Not sure who decided this would be a funny prank but I want at least 72 cents worth of store credit for this issue. Hopefully next time I come back this issue wont be present.
Brett Smith
Very good had a lot of fun
John Hap
Bagels are too salty
Elizabeth Torbenson
A favorite of mine when I’m traveling through Smithtown. Egg sandwiches are tasty and conveniently located in the heart of Smithtown on Main St
Kristen Cronheim
These bagels may actually be the best in the world. Their rye bagel with caraway seeds is my favorite but I’ve never had a bagel I didn’t like there.
Theo Thinky
Went to my favorite breakfast place for my favorite meal. Everything bagel with cream cheese and catnip. Place is great with the crazy amount of catnip they can put on them bagels
Grant Maffei
Very pleased with my trip due to the kindness of the workers and the taste of the food. Would recommend!! 💛
I have been going to Smithtown bagels for 24 years. The staff has always been welcoming and helpful. Bagels are delicious. Their egg sandwich’s are always cooked perfectly. So happy they are still in business after all this time.
Danielle Zimmerman
Have tried many of the spots around town and this is definitely our favorite. Great service, and always fresh food! Highly recommend the bagel twists and salads - our favorite choices for daily breakfast and hosting brunch!
Robert Dondiego
I can’t say enough good things about Smithtown Bagels!! Every visit is a great experience, from the welcoming atmosphere, to the incredibly friendly and efficient staff. You can tell their place takes pride in what they do. The bagels are consistently fresh with the perfect balance of crispy exterior and the chewy, flavorful interior. They also serve delicious breakfast sandwiches, wraps and coffee. If you are anywhere near Smithtown, this place is a must!! Highly recommend!!
Ceedee HQ
If you want to eat a dirty bagel come here! I ordered a plain bagel and took a bite in it and there looked to be something dark in it which I didn’t know what I was but I threw it away
Mahnaz Cavalluzzi
I get bagels here almost every Saturday after my daughters’ dance class. They are one of the most consistent bagel places I’ve ever been to - everything is delicious and they’ve never messed up an order, whether I’ve called it in or ordered in person. The staff are always so friendly, helpful, and patient. Smithtown Bagels has been around for 20+ years and are a staple on the heart of Main Street.
I love Freddy and the bagels are amazing, colin did a great job!
Nice place. Very happy customer. Great food too.
05/18/20 Ordered two bagels & egg sandwiches. Server was freindly but did not fulfill order accurately. Both bagels were not toasted as requested and the sandwiches were not hot when brought to us. Coffee was mediocre also. First and last time I will be there. It was a Sunday mornng and not crowded. We should have taken that as a warning sign. I do not recommend.
I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and when I got my order, there was a huge circle in the middle just gone. Thought I was getting my moneys worth here but clearly they decided to cut me short by putting a circle in the middle. Not sure who decided this would be a funny prank but I want at least 72 cents worth of store credit for this issue. Hopefully next time I come back this issue wont be present.
Very good had a lot of fun
Bagels are too salty
A favorite of mine when I’m traveling through Smithtown. Egg sandwiches are tasty and conveniently located in the heart of Smithtown on Main St
These bagels may actually be the best in the world. Their rye bagel with caraway seeds is my favorite but I’ve never had a bagel I didn’t like there.
Went to my favorite breakfast place for my favorite meal. Everything bagel with cream cheese and catnip. Place is great with the crazy amount of catnip they can put on them bagels
Very pleased with my trip due to the kindness of the workers and the taste of the food. Would recommend!! 💛
Restaurantji Recommends
I have been going to Smithtown bagels for 24 years. The staff has always been welcoming and helpful. Bagels are delicious. Their egg sandwich’s are always cooked perfectly. So happy they are still in business after all this time.
Have tried many of the spots around town and this is definitely our favorite. Great service, and always fresh food! Highly recommend the bagel twists and salads - our favorite choices for daily breakfast and hosting brunch!
I can’t say enough good things about Smithtown Bagels!! Every visit is a great experience, from the welcoming atmosphere, to the incredibly friendly and efficient staff. You can tell their place takes pride in what they do. The bagels are consistently fresh with the perfect balance of crispy exterior and the chewy, flavorful interior.
They also serve delicious breakfast sandwiches, wraps and coffee. If you are anywhere near Smithtown, this place is a must!! Highly recommend!!
If you want to eat a dirty bagel come here! I ordered a plain bagel and took a bite in it and there looked to be something dark in it which I didn’t know what I was but I threw it away
I get bagels here almost every Saturday after my daughters’ dance class. They are one of the most consistent bagel places I’ve ever been to - everything is delicious and they’ve never messed up an order, whether I’ve called it in or ordered in person. The staff are always so friendly, helpful, and patient. Smithtown Bagels has been around for 20+ years and are a staple on the heart of Main Street.
Loading...