Smithtown Pasta House

65 E Main St, Smithtown
(631) 979-9700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andrew Lertora

Highly recommend! Loved the food and wine! Alexandra and Joe provided excellent service. Definitely will be a returning customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Maiorino DDS

First time here and will return. Alex was our server and she is fantastic. Honest and very helpful with menu decisions. Dont usually go out for Italian because qe cook it at home very well but the food was great. Had the chicken parm vodka style and it was done very well. not dry. very tasty. Will be back. Hopefully we will get same server as well. Once again she was great.

PAUL

Great food, great service, at a reasonable price. I appreciate a good experience that I can afford for my whole family. Thank you.

effie

The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. I had ravioli in albedo sauce. Often this sauce can be heavy, but this wasn't the case. It had the perfect consistency and was delicious. My friend is vegan and it is often challenging finding a restaurant with options for her. They had a separate vegan menu with a good number of choices. I'm looking forward to returning.

Doug Robinson

This place is awesome. Food is excellent.

Leslie

Great flatbread and pasta dishes. Wonderful wine special on Thursday nights. Don't appreciate paying extra for credit card use, especially with prices this high for pasta. A very nice experience, though, overall. Our service was amazing!

Elaine

It was one of the worse restaurant experience I have ever had. Started with serving us warm water. I ordered baked rigatoni with marinara sauce. Came with meat sauce. I sent it back by the time it came back everyone had finished eating. The worse part was the redelivered my meal with the same meat sauce. I had them take it back - I had no dinner. You would think the manager would have compensated us in some way. Nothing. It was a horrible experience I will never go back.

Billy Ford

The staff was very pleasant and very professional. Our waitress, Alex was outstanding. The food was to perfection and the ambiance was amazing. I will definitely be going back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Geri

Food was very good but the service was just fair. There were no salt or pepper shakers on the table, difficult to get grated cheese, hot pepper after dinner served as there was no wait staff. It took 30 minutes to take our order. That being said, everyone was very pleasant, the food was delish and the atmosphere was nice. I would give it another try to see how service is next time.

Billy

Awesome!! This was our first time visiting. We were a party of 11 We were celebrating Father's Say and my son's 5 th Birthday and the experience was special. We were greeted at the bar while waiting for our entire party to arrive. Alex the bartender was great . He made great recommendations and provided excellent service. We were greeted by our server. Her name was also Alex. She was thorough in her menu presentation and her discussion of the specials. She answered all questions and she was very attentive to details. The food and wine were amazing and very reasonably priced.

Kelly

Our waitress for your 3:30pm reservation was wonderful. She was thoughtful and very sweet throughout our entire dining experience on Father's Day.

Absolute Electric

Place is always busy because the food and service is awesome!

Barry

The place is clean with one waitress on a Tuesday night which was fine. Well decorated and while they tout how delicious their food is, it was not our experience. My wife had the Carbonara which she said was good. The problem is their marinara sauce which it is not. I go to Italian restaurants for the gravy, I love a great marinara sauce. While it is fresh, it is nothing more than diced tomatoes. Imagine throwing fresh tomatoes in a cuisinart for 5 minutes and pouring it on your pasta - that is what I got for my pasta dish Alla Mama as well as the appetizer fried zucchini. It is more like a salsa rather than a sauce. For that we will not be returning.

Richard

Food is delicious, great service, the only issue I would ask management to address is the tables are sticky because of the fading finish on them. It's the first experience you have when you sit down and it's not good. 

Maria

Food was mediocre. Drinks too sweet. Kitchen got entree wrong and he's to send back. Service was great and attentive but never acknowledged our anniversary

Loading...