South Dayton Hotel

203 Pine St, South Dayton
(716) 988-5008

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Frank Kelley

Good food , Fair prices,great prime rib. Liquor bar, package store, Wines family atmosphere Good all round

John Capanyola

The room was empty at 4pm they sat us in the main hallway by the bar
The table was dirty,greasy,
And silverware was disgusting. Second table there and couldnt get an end cut, the meat came rare and was toughest
Primerib I ever had,
It was my 3rd visit in less than 2 yrs...
Ive heard it changed sence my 1st visit, now i beleave it has ,not sure it was even prime rib no marble,and tougher than strip from a microwave.
My frinds that turned us on to S.D. hotel wont be back ,and i wont be bringing mom back for anymore birthday dinners.
Its sad (wash your silverware) at least.

Sara Tolsma

Prime Rib was delicious! Loved the fries. Service was great and had a great atmosphere! Will definitely go back

Howard Ross

Always good food, great staff, and quick service.

I had the pan fries Walleye, with real homemade fries and coleslaw.

Julie Sticek

Always great

Peyton Stoltenberg

Love this place! Try the prime rib

Nikki Marie

We came in around 7pm last night, full house. Service was still excellent and our food was delish!! Thank you! 😊

Sally Truong

We visited the Amish community and stores in the area, and the South Dayton Hotel turned out to be the best spot for both lunch and dinner. The sandwiches and burgers are absolutely delicious β€” fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. it’s probably a family-owned business. Service is quick and friendly, which makes the dining experience even better. Whether you’re stopping by after exploring the local Amish shops or just looking for a great place to eat, this restaurant is a must-visit. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys good food, great service, and a charming small-town vibe!

Steven Royce

Food made fresh to order drinks cold. Rooms clean and smell fresh

Frank Komo

Food was above and beyond.
Great price

George Watson

Great food ,nice people

SP Reception

staff =horrible , food sub par- too expensive , bad quality . did not stay in hotel section probably as dirty as the restaurant and bathrooms

Gretchen Horth

Stopped in for mother's Day brunch fabulous hope they do it next year

Gary Crispin

Great food! Quiet setting.

David Bolen

I ate at the restaurant; did not stay at the hotel. The food was tasty and the staff were friendly. It was a little chilly inside and a sulphuric smell permeated the restroom area.

Loading...