Cafe Crust

850 County Rd 39, Southampton
(631) 259-8880

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ahmir Vang

We met with friends at this place for lunch. we heard about this restaurant from quite a few people. Well, we were not disappointed. we were warmly welcomed by the staff members and we felt excellent. The food was just great. We enjoyed every moment and we will visit this place again. Highly recommended.

john wynne

Closed since January 2020. It’s now March. So there’s that.

Brandon Patrick

great pizza and great people

Mike Single

Food was excellent. Service not so much. Understaffed on a Saturday night when there was an event in town. Multiple large tables waiting to eat over an hour. We had our dinner before we even received our drinks. Not sure if I would go back

Jean-Pierre Uys

Food was good to great. Staff was very friendly. The service was slow, but they made up for that with free coffees. Its a sit down service not a deli with pre-made pies as an fyi.

Lisa McMahon

This used to be my favorite pizza place out East, but apparently a few changes have been made a few months ago, only 12” personal pies now, for the same price as their old larger ones. I literally paid $19.55 for a 12” margarita pizza that was essentially all sauce, barely ANY cheese. Very disappointed when compared to their old pies....

Doug Johnson

Loved coming to this place whenever I was out east. Recommended to so many people. Recent experience, horrible slow service. Apparently no longer serving regular size pies. Had a table of four and a personal pie came out. What a let down. Will be looking elsewhere as the price of the pie was high for a 12" pie.

Grey Ward

The restaurant is wonderful and spacious, the food was delicious and the prices were very economical. fast, effective service and very amiable waiters. I highly recommend this place.

Keith Ellis

I've had lunch and dinner several times. The food has always been tremendous and their staff is fantastic. I dont write reviews often, but the place was amazing.

matthias musterman

Food was good, the service was friendly but was horribly slow and got almost everything wrong, even though there was only one other table being served. By the way, the other table had the same problems.

Keith S

I love pizza, and I rarely get to have it because of diet, so when I came here it was a well-deserved meal. But the pizzas we ate were not that good really. It was somewhat burnt, and not enough sauce. It's hard to really say how to make it better but the only reason I'd say for someone to go here really, is to Supercharge your car.

Erika Gonzalez

Can I give no stars? Everything excluding my two basic salads were wrong. I spent almost 12 minutes on the phone with incompetence. I'm the last to complain, knowing it may just be someone's first day but after speaking with the “supervisor” totally realized it's the establishment and not HER! I pray for these people. Now waiting on my second time around hoping for them to deliver the rightful forgotten orders. Unreal. Never again. And not for nothing I love this place ...

Jeffery Hyde

Excellent pizza and paninis!! They have a 750° wood fired pizza oven that turns out some killer pies. The dough, red sauce and mozzarella are all made in house. They also offer great salads and serve Puck's sodas which are great. The black cherry and cream sodas are fantastic!

BETHANN CUCCURULLO

Good food need better service but food is great. Not a great atmosphere

Cole Phelps

I used to build wood fire ovens and train cooks on how to use them and I gotta say, this was the best wood fired pizza Ive ever had. Just as good cold the next day too! Really glad we found this place. Oh and you gotta try their gelato too! 🍕🍨

Loading...