Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza

801 County Rd 39 #2, Southampton
(631) 283-6770

Recent Reviews

Thomas John

Plenty of variety on the menu, and really great prices for the Hamptons.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Rich Gherardi

They have all kinds of delicious dishes. Nachos , chicken parm and fajitas completed this order. Large portions as well!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Geneva Trotman

This place is always so good. Whoever cooks the food truly loves to cook. Best food in Southampton for a great price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Monica Murphy

This place is my go to…My family loves it. The food is great and the staff is exceptionalI eat here frequently and they never disappoint. . Highly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Evann Perry

Pizza sucks service sucks wish could give 0

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

David Dottin

Good food, warm atmosphere. Wide variety of dishes.

Owen Kaminsky

Food was good, we ordered pizza and a burger. Portion sizes vs price was very solid. Fast time from ordering to service.Very nice staff and good restaurant atmosphere. Definitely recommend for lunch or a quick pizza stop.Parking: Parking lot was small and traffic plus parkinglot size made leaving the lot very difficult.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eileen Alterbaum

Pleasant casual place and great value. Pizza looks delicious. Teriyaki salmon is awesome!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Mike Noe

15 dollars for two specialty slices and a drink and it’s not even good

Niki AK

I will place the order on the Slice app the day before and its never been on time. It's always late!! By at least 15 mins. Won't be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Amy P.

I'm giving this restaurant three stars for the pizza only. Service was terrible. We went in person to the store and ordered two pizzas and 18 piece wings with sauce on the side and a chicken Parm wedge. We waited 25 minutes and came back to pick up the food. When we got home we noticed the chicken Parm wedge was missing and the wings they had given us were burnt The plastic lid on the tin container was melted on top of the wings! We called back and were told that the chicken Parm wedge was never put in the order and we hadn't paid for it either. They had sent over one small 3 inch container of wing sauce for the wings and one blue cheese. For 18 wings! Ridiculous. I told them we wanted new wings delivered to the house. They did oblige and the new wings that we got were so much better! They even gave us the correct amount of sauce for 18 wings! The carrots and celery they gave us the first time we're brown and old. The new carrots and celery were perfect and crisp. It should've been that way the first time! The pizza was really good, so there's no complaints there. This place could be really good if they just get their acts together. There was nobody in the restaurant when we went in and ordered and the girl at the register read back the order. I'm giving the third star because they actually cared to get it right. Thank you for that.

Ralitsa Georgieva

The food is excellent, the quantity is more than enough, but the service could use a little help. We ordered some chicken pasta from Uber eats and after an hour we saw that our order is cancelled. When we called they explained that they had called us and notified us, which is not true at all. We had to order again and wait another hour for the new dishes. This was not a pleasant experience.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Ginoveva P.

Ummm excuse me but the food is 10/10 for me! It's in Southampton and the prices are more than affordable, portions are more than enough to eat 2 times lol and come on now, the food is better than some of the expensive restaurants located in the village. I usually order Uber Eats at least 2 times a week from them and they never disappoint! Forever customer!

Sean

The slices must have been over a week old and inedible. Would not

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Mallory Raymore

I ordered one pasta dish to-go and was told it would take 20 minutes. It took over an hour with no updates from the staff, and it wasn’t packaged well for transport home. It was also oddly flavored, and not what I expected. I’m pretty disappointed because when I ate there in person a few weeks ago, that same dish only took 10 minutes and was amazing - I was really looking forward to eating it again! Huge bummer. Based on the other reviews, it’s normal for them to be this inconsistent. Save your money

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Load More