Pizza Shack I

5008 W Ridge Rd, Spencerport
(585) 352-5005

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Large Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
American Assorted Sub Medium
Pepperoni Pizza with Sausage
Delicious Homemade Pizza
Perfectly Cooked Pizza
Small Pepperoni Pizza
Hard Salami Sub Large
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Assorted Cheese Sub
Two Large 32 Slices

Menu

Delicious Homemade Pizza
Delicious Homemade Pizza
With cheese and your choice of extra toppings.

Meal Deals
Pizza (Large) with Cheese & Wings or Boneless
Pizza (Medium) with Cheese & Wings or Boneless
Pizza (Small) with Cheese & Wings or Boneless (5 pcs)
2 Large Pizzas with Cheese & 24 Wings or 24 Boneless
2 Large Pizzas & Bucket of Wings

Chicken Wings
Wings
Celery and blue cheese included.
Boneless Wings (12 pcs)
Celery and blue cheese included.

Jumbo Calzones
Build Your Own Calzone
Ricotta, mozzarella, cheese and 1 pizza topping. Comes with two sides of marinara.

Munchies
Potato Skins (5 pcs)
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs)
Garlic Knots (15 pcs)
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Macaroni Salad (½ lb)
Fried Dough
Chicken Finger Basket
4 breaded chicken fingers Served with French fries and your choice of sauce.
Cheddar Jalapeño Poppers (5 pcs)
Pizza Logs (½ lb)
Mozzarella or pepperoni.
Tossed Salad
Chicken Fingers (¾ lb, 4 pcs Extra Large)
Julienne Salad
Salad that comes with salami, turkey, and tomatoes topped with cheddar cheese and comes with your choice of dressings.
French Fries
Onion Rings
Deep Fried Mushrooms (½ lb)
Potato Salad (½ lb)

Plates
Boneless Wing Plate
Boneless wings, fries, mac salad, and meat hot
Steak Plate
Comes with 8oz of steak, fries, mac salad, and meat hot
Pizza Plate
Comes with a slice of pizza, fries, mac salad, and meat hot.
Chicken Finger Plate
Comes with chicken fingers, fries, mac salad, and meat hot

Hot Subs
Hearty Steak Sub
Meatball with Mozzarella Sub
Meatball sub which comes with cheese. 5 0z for medium 8oz for larges! Choose any and all toppings!
Chicken Finger Sub
Chicken finger sub. Choose any and all toppings!
Eggplant Parmesan with Mozzarella Sub
Eggplant parmesan sub. Choose any and all toppings!
Pizza Sub with Mozzarella & Pepperoni Sub

Cold Sub
Italian Style Sub
Classic Italian assorted with Salami, pepperoni, and ham. Choose any and all toppings!
Turkey sub
Turkey sub. Choose any and all toppings!
Tuna Sub
Tuna sub. Choose any and all toppings!
Ham Sub
Ham sub 6 oz for medium 8 0z for large. Choose any and all toppings!
American Assorted Sub
American Sub with ham, turkey, and salami. Choose any and all toppings!
Hard Salami Sub
Salami sub. Choose any and all toppings!

Platters & Dinners
Shack Platter (1½ lb)
Chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, jalapeño poppers, deep fried mushrooms, and pizza logs.
Steak Sandwich Platter
8 0z of shaved steak served on a 6" sub roll, served with mac salad and French fries. Choose any and all toppings!

Sauces
Blue Cheese
Ranch
sweet and sour Mild
Marinara
Buffalo - Medium
Buffalo - Hot
sweet and sour Medium
Buffalo - Mild
Garlic Parm
sweet and sour Hot
BBQ
Honey Mustard
Italian Dressing

Drinks
2 Liter Bottle of Soda
12 oz Can of Soda
20 oz Bottle of Soda
Powerade
20 oz
Bottle of Water
Monster

Friday Beer Battered Fish Fry
Friday Beer Battered Fish Fry
Fish Sandwich
Comes with fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+22 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+21 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Hidden gem for sure! First time trying this place based off a recommendation and the fact that they are open 2 hours later than neighboring pizza shops was an immediate plus! The pizza and wings did not disappoint, superior than our normal go to. This will 100% be our new go to spot! Customer service was also more than exceptional! I always prefer to support mom & pop shops over anything, you can tell they take pride in their craft! You won’t regret showing support to this...
August 2025
I came around late last night to pick up a doordash order. While waiting for the generous man to finish preparing the food for the doordash customer, I asked him if I could buy a soda and some mottzerella sticks… so once he rang me up, he told me it’s cash only. I don’t carry cash. Nor did I have my ATM card to take money out. This guy hooked me up with the food for free. Also did I forget to mention, growing up, they would always drive the extra couple miles to deliver...
August 2025
Finally got to try the fish fry’s that sell out every Friday night. 10 out of 10! Fish was light and fluffy, breading was crunchy/crisp. Generous portions. Reminded me of getting fish fry’s in the good old days with my parents.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Alla's Bakery - 5010 W Ridge Rd
Bakery
Dunkin' - 5017 W Ridge Rd
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
Perri's Pizzeria - 1835 N Union St
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian

Pizza Shack I

5008 W Ridge Rd, Spencerport, NY 14559
(585) 352-5005