3 Brothers Pizza

6270 NY-82, Stanfordville
(845) 723-4139

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tamra Harris

We have been here twice and have been very happy with our food both times. Pizzas are loaded with toppings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thom Rose

The worst pizza establishment that I have ever come across !! 3 times absolute mess up . DONE

Bill Eighmie

The calzone was the biggest I have ever seen. And it was cooked perfectly!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew

We have consistantly ordered and it always messed up and would take a long long time even if it was right. So we took a break after they couldnt get our pizza right 3 different times and fave me buffalo wings with no sauce. Wrong orders would result in a 2 hr to 2.5hr wait. We just did door dash 10/24/2025 and waited 1.5hrs for an order they agreed to take and ended up 2 plus hrs later learning they arent doing the order they accept thru door dash and keep updating. We were also charged, now we are 3 hrs later no food and i have to get my money back. Not again 3 bros... you suck!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Heidi Ho

Great pizza! Super nice waitress!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robin Whittenberg

The Grandma's pizza was burnt on the bottom. When I pointed this out to the woman at the register she became argumentative and defensive. She said it was supposed to be crispy. I said it wasn't crispy...it was burnt..black on the bottom. No offer to leave it off the bill. Asked for a medium rare hamburger ...it was well done and hard to chew. Lots of flies everywhere...non existent service. Do yourself a favor....skip this place. IN RESPONSE TO THE OWNER MESSAGE....... I'm sure you know who the woman was that was at the register yesterday afternoon, she had just come in for her shift. She should have asked someone else to help me if she couldn't handle the situation without literally standing there arguing with me and my 89 year old mother. (Although it wasn't much of an argument because I couldn't get a word in edgewise) We have been to your restaurant before and have had no complaints. I was extremely polite when I asked about the burned pizza but she was immediately defensive and clearly angry at me even though again... I was extremely polite about it. When I think back on it I should have gone back to the table for the pizza with the top of it that we scraped off in order to eat it and the crust turned upside down exposing the black bottom, brought it up to the register and put it in front of her... Maybe she wouldn't have been so quick to call it crispy ....maybe she would have called it what it was ...burnt. It was bad enough that we spent over $23 on a pizza that was burnt and inedible, but I had to get yelled at by that awful woman at the register. To add insult to injury, I was also given a hamburger that was inedible.. as a matter of fact my husband asked for a slice of onion... What he received on his hamburger was a chunk of onion clearly the heart of the onion... I mean really , the chef couldn't see that the pizza was burnt and the hamburger that we requested medium rare was well done? And what was he thinking putting a chunk instead of a slice of onion on the burger? The woman at the register kept saying that we should have let someone know... which would have been fine and dandy if anybody had come to our table to check on us after we got our meals ... Which by the way they did not. Quite frankly we should not have had to pay for that meal. And let me make it clear I was not asking for anything to be taken off the bill it should have been offered to me to begin with, instead I stood there being berated and publicly embarrassed by that woman who would barely let me speak. Again we have been to your restaurant many times and you can blame her for the fact that we will never set foot in there again. She publicly humiliated me and my 89-year-old mother and it made me sick to have to hand over my credit card and pay for that mess that we were served. Someone needs to clue that woman that in this day and age there are things called Google reviews which can damage your business. She needs to learn how to control herself!!! Unbelievable!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Paul Gallaspy

I love this place. Food is always good. Attitude is always nice. Have become a very awesome part of the community. I appreciate yall

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

robert castellano

Best pizza around! Quality ingredients! Asked for well done, it was perfect!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

maria farias

Every time we order take out, they never disappoint! The pizza is delicious and I always get the eggplant Parm. The eggplant parm is super big and is equivalent of 3 meals; I’m usually able to get 3 meals out of it. The cannolis are pretty good too! As always, the owners are so so nice and attentive as soon as you walk-in the door. They also thank you for supporting their business. I will keep coming back for more food and telling others about this gem!😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

cindy damon

Once again a fantastic meal! Husband had Stromboli that was amazing with enough for about 3 other meals. I had pasta Bolognese also delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chet Damon

My wife and I love going here. They make you feel like family. Great Italian food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Rugar

We ordered delivery on a night when it was too hot to cook. Chicken bacon ranch pizza was a huge hit with everyone in my house. Mac and cheese (which I can’t say I’ve ever seen on a pizza place’s menu before!) was in desperate need of salt, though the kids didn’t mind. Delivery time ran about half an hour later than I was told it would be, which was a little disappointing. I probably won’t get delivery from here again but would definitely consider picking up. Absolutely recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza and the penne ala vodka— both were delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Hannah B

Came here at the recommendation of a local. This pizza was shockingly bad. Our slices had literally NO flavor. Even the sausage didn’t taste like anything! It was also coldish and hard/stale even though we dined in. The server was kind, but didn’t know what pepper flakes are. That should have been a tipoff. The wings were just okay. We had to go somewhere else to restore our faith in pizza!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Dennis Kaczynski

Great people! Great customer service. Awesome food

Krista M

Excellent food! Super friendly staff. Highly recommend. Also should note that I have a severe gluten allergy and they were amazing at accommodating my allergy and helping me to choose the best options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...