Amici Bakery

758 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island
(718) 967-1155

Recent Reviews

Marilyn Rotondella

Great Italian

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Ramos

For the price you’re paying for pasties and goods, the very least they can do is actually fill the cannoli all the way thru and not just the ends. Better places.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Lisa Wood

Literally one of the worst bakeries I've ever been too. All of the baked goods tastes like old refrigerator.

Aggie Cruzz

Aweso.e staff!! I Went to the bakery today didn't know what kind of cake I wanted the wonderful sales person Samantha help me out tremendously she told me each and every Cake flavor and filling she had she also wrote an a beautiful name for me. I highly recommend this beautiful beautiful and amazing bakery 5 star

Steven M.

Excellent pastries and cookies but the Italian Cheesecake was Awesome!!Go out of your way to grab a piece...it's Dynamite!

Santino C.

Terrible service. Workers were extremely disrespectful and rude. They had no respect and were extremely unprofessional.

Karen B.

Bad experience. Asked to write Happy Birthday on a cake and was told no. Then I asked for a little sign and they didn't have so she reluctantly wrote Happy Birthday. Doesn't thank me when I'm leaving or give me a receipt. Ok so we now have the cake. No taste and 2 strands of hair. Went right to the garbage .. Never again. Always heard great things but realize that was many years ago

Roseann Pellegrino

Very bad customer service sakes girls very disrespectful.Asked for French bread gave regular bread.Called and was very nasty asked to speak to owner but was told not available will not be going there anymore.

Joseph Caputo

Never had a bad experience here. Everything I've ever ordered was fresh. Pastries are pretty good. Service was good.

Nicolle Gambardella

Appalling! I just bit into their apple turnover, purchased yesterday and there is MOLD inside of it. Not only are they heavily overpriced, but have a slow turnover. BEWARE and if you feel sick after eating their goods, you aren't crazy, you're most likely POISONED.

Zuri Ali

You need to keep in check of your pastries. First you need to put an expiration date on your products. Every time I from Key food on Bay St. Your products are are wickedly stale. I'm sending you this email first before taking it higher to report you. Let's keep everyone happy with FRESHLY baked goods. I wasn't allowed my refund again from Key food. ?

Chris B.

Great place if you want dirty looks from the staff, pastries are average but overpriced. workers definitely need a lesson on how to treat customers properly. made me never to go back

Geno PIC

A nice small place I picked up a valenrines cake it was fresh and it wasn't overly sweet

Shawn Dwyer

Tasty St Joseph pastries and good Italian bread.

M Garay

Amici nice bakery, extremely expensive for a bakery. Almost $5.00 for a cupcake is absurd! 1 lbs of cookies is $19.95, are you insane! Butter cookies are $9.95 go figure. Personal requests are a no, no!

Load More