Pizzaioli of Staten Island

I grab a pie from this place every week and it's always great. The staff are great also and very friendly. Pictured is an ai approximation of me enjoying!

Their pizza and other food is excellent. This is my go-to place for half tray specials, penne vodka with chicken is great! All their food that I've had so far is really good.

Had a slice here today it was a 7. Crispy sauce was good in flavor just a bit too much. Overall place is clean staff is friendly.

Okay so i ordered the pizzaioli special hero. Yesterday was the first time ordering it. I LOVED IT. very filling and packed with ingredients which made me not think twice about purchasing the $17+ hero again today. Oh how disappointing... if the quality of the hero is going to vary like this it's not worth purchasing. Very very disappointed.

D I S G U S T I N G !!! The white pie was DRIPPING with oil and the only taste was from the raw garlic. The wings were so soggy and mostly flats...$19 for flats!??? Spent $52 on 12 wings, a SMALL white pie and 1 slice of pepperoni pizza??? NEVER AGAIN!! SAVE YOUR MONEY!

Sicilian upside down pie is absolute delicious.Sauce is very good.. I also had the spaghetti and meatballs and it was delicious and nice size. I recommend both . Louis

Went the other night paid for the pie stepped out side while it was cooking. Came back in to get it as it was being giving to me some lady behind the counter was like did he pay? Of course I did dummy no one wants your free mediocre pizza

I go to this place sometimes and the food is good. Today what bothered me was the person who was handling the food had an open wound scabby wound on his hand and his hands were dirty. I'm disappointed I did like coming here to eat
Not good.
If you're going to handle food you should have that covered up and have clean hands. Putting on a latex glove does not help you're supposed to cover the wound when handling food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

The food is good, counter staff is good, delivery is terrible. This is the 3rd time I'm waiting an hour and 40 minutes for a sandwhich and a slice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Love Pizzaoli. Been ordering from them since they opened. The food is always fresh the delivery is quick and the food is always delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I wish I could give zero. The service is super slow and the food that we ordered was horrible tastes bland. Well I would take my business somewhere else

Great staff great food only place i get my pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Chicken Roll

Had a wonderful dinner Saturday evening with friends. I ordered chicken rollatini with pasta and my spouse had the shrimp Frances with pasta. Both dishes were outstanding. 2 large pieces of chicken with a rich mushrooms sauce covering both the chicken and the pasta. The shrimps were large and cooked to perfection being tender after reheating the leftovers. The service, by Lisa Marie, was excellent and caring. Definitely a restaurant to have a great meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

So expensive...not worth it. $3.50 for a snapple. $9.00 for a roll. Prices are insane.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Excellent food and service! First time there for anything other than pizza and very pleasantly surprised! Extensive menu and BOGO entree special every day. Wife and I had 2 different shrimp entrees and both were excellent. With 2 sodas, I can not have alcohol for awhile and my wife won't indulge for fear of tempting me, paying a little more for a change in her entree, with tax the bill was less than $50! Of course this did not include tip. I think we found a new local favorite eatery! Definitely recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5