Angry Lobster Rolls Staten Island

This is for the forest avenue location. It is not on Google, so let your sister-establishment know.I decided to give this place a try even with the subpar reviews. I don’t complain too much about the price of things especially post covid because I know things are getting difficult to sustain. The fact that this roll was so bland, and smelled like they put chemicals in it is very disturbing. I was only able to take two bites. One I chewed and threw out and the other I tried using the butter sauce they gave. The butter sauce is pretty good but it didn’t change the lobster they gave me. I really looked forward to trying this out and it was an epic fail. Angry Lobster Rolls, you surely lived up to your name because I was Angry after trying this.Please figure something out because this cannot be real. The prices are way to high for subpar, tasteless food. I really want you all to be great so please figure out your management, get new a chef(or train the one you have—even a little old bay would do the trick), try samples of the food you serve. Do something…

I paid 17 dollars for a grilled cheese with lobster . Money isn’t the problem the problem was there was literally 2 pieces of lobster . Like I can’t even see the lobster from the outside OF THE SANDWICH I literally paid 17 dollars for 2 pieces of bread and a slice of cheese . A biiiiiiiiiiig rip off . I feel robbed. Disgusting cheap owner I shoulda took a photo.. wasn’t even worth 5 dollars, I don’t see this place lasting long

Absolutely delicious lobster but the servings are small and the price is high for the amount you get.

Love, Love, Love the Angry Lobster Rolls. The Lobster Roll with lettuce, mayo and lemon was absolutely delicious. Would definitely recommend this roll to everyone. This is the best!!

Came at 715pm on Thursday and place was closed. Drove 30 minutes to kiss the door. Thanks

I am a big lobster roll fan and was super excited when I saw this place opened. Very good quality lobster. I would definitely give it try! Make sure you get the Mac and cheese with whatever you get!

I have mixed feelings on this place. I felt the lobster rolls were delicious and I would 100% get them again. I thought the mac and cheese and lobster bisque were okay not the best I have ever had. The portions are also not the biggest and I feel like if they gave more of a portion for the amount of money you spend it would have bettered my experience. Overall, I am looking forward to seeing anything new this place adds to the menu but the prices have to go down if they want this place open more than 5 months max. I get this is Staten Island but people become very cheap around here when it comes to food. I would come back again though I did enjoy it overall.

It's a very good lobster roll but not worth $25! Also they give you a giant PICKLE in the box with the roll and the pickle juice LEAKS into the bun. When we mentioned that they looked at us like we had three heads LOL. Bad move, beware if you don't like pickles. They corrected the mistake and gave us a fresh bun. We would come back.

$26 for one sandwich on something that looks like a hot dog bun just a little bit longer but not much and sogged in butter with maybe a quarter pound of lobster meat on it with one pickle spear and a $0.50 bag of chips. Just my opinion but I don't think they'll be around that long other people had told me before I went there but I'm the type of person that had to see for myself so I guess I can't complain about wasting money. Lol live and learn

I’m starved…. Major disappointment. Bought 3 lobster rolls for me and my family. Cost $78 and that’s without drinks. When we got home and opened it I was shocked at the size. The pictures online make it seem like your getting a big hero. This is a child sized sandwich with just a little bit of lobster. Tiny side of coleslaw(about 2 tablespoons) and 1/4 wedge of a pickle. For almost $80 this is not worth it. It’s a novelty. Something you try once and that’s it. Went on a Friday night and no one was there. It’s unaffordable. Especially for the amount of food you get.

Firstly, the lobster roll I got (New England) was beyond delicious. It came with cole slaw, chips & a pickle. I enjoyed the meal A LOT. Secondly, this business just opened up, so I expect their menu to increase in size in the next couple months or so. I don't want to say that their menu is limited because with time it will get larger for sure. Also, some may say it is pricey. But keep in mind--the lobster they serve comes as early as that morning. The claw meat was what they put in my roll and it is delicious, yet the most expensive. Love this place. I will be back for sure. Can't wait to see the business grow.

Real dirt bag of a man. Steals other businesses ideas His dad must be real proud of what he raised

A coworker pointed out this new Tottenville Lobster roll place off of Page Ave.I am a big Lobster Roll fan and just had returned from Point Pleasant, NJ, where I lived on them!Another coworker and I headed out immediately for lunch. They do not have inside dining as of yet, but a picnic table in the front. I ordered four Lobster Rolls to go, along with two bottles of water, and we ate lunch at the opposite end of Page Ave., overlooking the ocean at the start of Conference House Park.The Lobster Rolls were good. They are claw-meat only, and with that in mind, just a little pricey. We spent $105 for lunch for two, but they did come with a bag of potato chips, a small Coleslaw, & a pickle wedge.We did not try the lobster mac & cheese. The menu was a bit limited, but they did have a few variations on the Rolls, like the buttered-roll New England or the Californian, with avocado. They also have a spicy sauce to add into the roll, to give it a bit of heat & bite!They were flavorful and we will return again. I would like to see more specials including the waters or other drinks, or a discount built in for ordering 2,4, or 6.They are also opening-up another place on the North Shore, where there are not many Lobster Roll options on menus.

Maine roll was DELICIOUS!!!

Delicious and good quality lobster. Worth the wait and price!