Anthony's Paninoteca
3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
(914) 458-5645
Customers' Favorites
Calabrian Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich
Ella's Chick-N Sandwhich
Anthony's Hot Sandwich
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Ciro Combo w Fries
Panino Mortadella
Sicilian Arancini
Do It for Johnny
Prosciutto Balls
Potato Croquette
Cold Sandwiches
#20THE GODFATHER
Prosciutto, soppressata, hpt capicola. mortadella, sharp provolone, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, oil & vinegar dressing
#19 FREDO
Ham, yellow American, shredded lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar dressing
#18 BIG STEVE
Turkey, yellow American, bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli
#17 HOW YA DOIN HENDRY
Grilled chicken, bacon, yellow American, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, garlic aioli, oil & vinegar dressing
#16 2 GUNS TOMMY
Grilled chicken, soppressata, hot capicola, sharp provolone, sundried tomatoes, balsamic glaze
#15 JIMMY THE GENT
Ham, fried eggplant, sharp provolone, balsamic glaze
#14 LUIS
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, sundried tomatoes, pesto
#13 MARIA
Imported mortadella, fresh mozzarella, sharp provolone, fried eggplant, roasted peppers, pesto, oil & vinegar dressing, balsamic glaze
#12 NEVER FORGET HERO
Ham, turkey, yellow American, swiss cheese, bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar dressing
#11 BIG REECH
Chicken cutlet, ham, yellow American, shredded lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli, sweet peppers, oil & vinegar dressing
#10 A.G.V.
Chicken cutlet, imported prosciutto, hot capicola, fresh mozzarella, chopped giardiniera salad
#9 ROSANNA
Chicken cutlet, imported prosciutto, sharp provolone, eggplant caponata, balsamic glaze
#8 LAURA
Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze
#7 BOBBY BACALA
Italian tuna, fresh mozzarella, hot peppers, balsamic glaze, mayo, oil & vinegar dressing
#6 ANALISA
Italian tuna, sharp provolone, eggplant caponata, olive oil drizzle
#5 MUFFULETTA
Imported Mortadella, soppressata, ham, swiss, sharp provolone, chopped giardiniera salad, oil & vinegar dressing
#4 THE PERRI
Imported mortadella, sharp provolone, eggplant caponata
#3 STA MINCHIA
Soppressata, sharp provolone, hot capicola, hot peppers, spicy hot honey, olive oil & vinegar dressing
#2 TESORO
Prosciutto di Parma, soppressata, sharp provolone, sundried tomatoes, balsamic glaze, oil & vinegar dressing
#1 LUIGI
Prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze, oil & vinegar dressing
Hot Sandwiches
#21 ANTHONY'S
Thin sliced homemade roast pork , fennel seasoned , sharp provolone, garlic bread, cup broth for dipping, hot peppers
#22 GINO
Esposito cheese & parsley sausage, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone
#23 LUCIA
Esposito cheese & parsley sausage, peppers & onions
#24 JOEY MUSCLES
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, broccoli rabe
#25 DO IT FOR JOHNNY
Roast beef, fresh mozzarella, caramelized onions, gravy
#27 GREAT KILLS
Turkey breast, swiss cheese, bacon, gravy
#28 PHIL LEOTARDO
Thin sliced ribeye, sharp provolone, hot cherry peppers, broccoli rabe
#29 BROTHERLY LOVE
Thin sliced ribeye, yellow American, caramelized onion, sweet or hot cherry peppers
#31 STATEN ITALY A LA VODKA
Chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, grated Grana Padano cheese
#32 FA-NAPOLI
Fried eggplant, vodka sauce , fresh mozzarella, grated Grana Padano cheese
#30 SCARFACE
#26 DOUBLE D
CHICKEN PARM HERO
thin chicken cutlets , housemade marinara sauce , fresh mozz , grated grana padano cheese
EGGPLANT PARM HERO
Fried eggplant , housemade marinara sauce , mozzarella
Salads
SEASONAL SALAD
Arugula , watermelon , goat cheese, fennel, red onion with a side of citrus blood orange dressing
CHICKEN MILANESE SALAD
Thin fried chicken cutlet, Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, shaved parmesan, balsamic dressing
X1/4 LB PASTA SALAD
X1/4 Lb Classic Potato Salad
classic potato salad with hard boiled egg
STEAK SALAD
Sliced ribeye, lettuce, croutons, ricotta salata, tomatoes, olives, shaved red onion, house made vinaigrette
HOUSE SALAD
Lettuce, ricotta salata, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, shaved red onions, house made vinaigrette
CAPRESE SALAD
Fresh mozzarella, thick sliced tomatoes, house made pesto, balsamic glaze
CAESAR SALAD
Lettuce, croutons, Grana Padano cheese, caesar dressing
Drinks
DR BROWNS
Stewarts Soda
Canada Dry Seltzer
SNAPPLE 16OZ
PLEASE SELECT FLAVOR CHOICE
Canned 7UP
Canned Diet Coke
Poland Spring
Canned Coke
Hawaiian Punch (CAN)
CANADA DRY GINGER ALE
YOOHOO
Gatorade
SUNKIST CAN SODA
MYSTIC
Housemade desserts
CHOCOLATE TRUFFLE TART
(MAY CONTAIN NUTS)
BROWN SUGAR PUMPKIN COOKIE
Italian pudding
Flavors :
Vanilla chai
Pumpkin spice latte
Panna cotta
topped with a winter fruit compote
Pumpkin Chai Tiramisu
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip loaf
Classic Pumpkin Loaf
SWEET TREATS & MORE
TWIX BAR
HERSHEY BAR
KIT KAT
PEANUT M&MS
M&MS
SNICKERS
MILKY WAY
TRAIL MIX
KIND BAR
TRIDENT GUM
ORIGINAL PRINGLES
CHEDDAR PRINGLES
TRUFFLE CHIPS
Voodoo Chips
Sides
MINI MINCHIA BALLS ( SPICY PROSUCITTO BALLS )
X1/4 LB PASTA SALAD
X1/4 LB GRILLED MARINATED VEGGIES
MEAT, PEAS , CHEESE RICEBALLS
CHEESE RICEBALL
X1/4 LB ROASTED PEPPERS
Prosciutto Balls
Hand rolled prosciutto balls
X1/4 Lb BROCCOLI RABE
X1/4 Lb Classic Potato Salad
classic potato salad with hard boiled egg
Meat Riceball Parm
Potato Croquette
Potato Croquette Parm
Cheese riceball parm
X1/4 Lb Fried Chicken Cutlet
Chips
Fried Ravioli
DELI CASE
X1/4 Lb Grilled Chicken
X1/4 lb Grilled veggies
X1/4 Lb Pasta Salad
pasta , ricotta salata cheese , sundried tomatoes , herb oil and vinegar dressing
X1/4 Lb Classic Potato Salad
classic potato salad with hard boiled egg
X1/4 Lb BROCCOLI RABE
X1/4 LB ROASTED PEPPERS
PREMIUM CHIPS
TRUFFLE CHIPS
QUESO CURADO
HAMON IBERICO
HAM FLAVORED CHIPS
APPS & FRIED BITES
CHICKEN FINGERS (4pc)
4 Pc Chicken Fingers w choice of sauce
Potato Croquette
MEAT, PEAS , CHEESE RICEBALLS
CHEESE RICEBALL
Prosciutto Balls
Hand rolled prosciutto balls
Meat Riceball Parm
Potato Croquette Parm
Cheese riceball parm
MEDIUM DRY BUFALLO WINGS
HERB AND CHEESE FRIED POTATO WEDGES
Fried raviolis
6pc w vodka or marina sauce
THURSDAY SPECIAL
CUZ
Spicy sausage split & crisp, fresh mozzarella, whipped ricotta & honey drizzle
PORCHETTA
On a roll with salsa verde
Porchetta platter
housemade porchetta with broccoli rabe & house made steak fries
BUILD YOUR OWN (3pd)
BUILD YOUR OWN (3PD )
COMBO DEALS
#1 COMBO
ANY 2 MEATS 1 CHEESE UNLIMTED BASIC TOPPINGS
* DRIZZLE , PREMIUM MEATS & SPECIAL TOPPING NOT INLCUDED . SUBJECT TO UPCHARGE *
#2 COMBO
ANY 4 MEATS 2 CHEESES ULIMITED BASIC TOPPINGS +1 SPECIAL TOPPING
* DRIZZLE , PREMIUM MEATS & MORE THEN 1 SPECIAL TOPPING NOT INLCUDED SUBJECT TO UPCHARGE *
ANTHONYS "BALLS"
Meat Riceball Parm
Cheese riceball parm
Rice Ball (meat, peas, cheese)
Rice Ball (cheese)
Prosciutto Balls
Hand rolled prosciutto balls
Potato Croquette
PLATTER
Chicken Parm Platter
Fried Chicken cutlet topped with marinara, mozzarella, grated cheese, basil pesto, served with potato croquette.
Eggplant Parm Platter
Fried Eggplant topped with marinara, mozzarella, grated cheese, basil pesto, served with potato croquette.
SOUP OF THE DAY
Tuscan kale & white bean soup
With sausage
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Visiting Staten Island we stopped at Paninoteca and I gotta tell ya the Porchetta Sandwich blew my mind. Roasted Italian pork, smoked mozzarella, broccoli robe and a delicious crusty roll made this one of the best sandwiches I’ve eaten in quite a long time. If I’m ever in Staten Island again I’m gonna visit this shop and bring my friends and family cause it’s that Good!
January 2026
I catered from Anthony’s for my families Christmas party and it was outstanding!
The mini sandwich platter was a hit with its assortment of savory combos for everyone and the potato croquettes and rice balls were the perfect side dish.
Love this place and look forward to catering from them in the future.
The mini sandwich platter was a hit with its assortment of savory combos for everyone and the potato croquettes and rice balls were the perfect side dish.
Love this place and look forward to catering from them in the future.
December 2025
This place has the absolute best sandwiches you will ever have in your life. The mortadella and Burrata sandwich is to die for. I cannot say enough good things about this sandwich shop and the owner Anthony is one of the nicest guys you’ll ever meet.
November 2025
You May Also Like
Village Maria Pizzeria - 3995 Amboy Rd
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian
Chinese Kitchen - 3981 Amboy Rd
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Poke, Bubble Tea, Chinese
Arirang Hibachi Steakhouse - 23A Nelson Ave
![]()
Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegan, Vegetarian