Bagels By the Bay

1231 Bay St, Staten Island
(718) 815-4447

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

It's one of the best bagel spots around. They are fresh, chewy, and made right. The tuna salad is on point, and the staff keeps things moving. Real New York vibes. I'm definitely coming back.
Known for their bagels, but don’t sleep on the sandwiches—this place nails both! The Monte Cristo is my usual favorite, but the Reuben totally surprised me with how incredible it was. Plus, the owners are super friendly. Definitely worth a visit!
My favorite bagel place in Staten Island and I’ve been everywhere - the bagels are fresh are made on premises, all the ingredients are always fresh and good quality too, the prices are good and the bagels are always loaded.

I also love their customer service, they’re attentive and really funny. Roy will go above and beyond for you.

Highly recommended to anyone, stop by and you will love it!

More Reviews