Absolutely delicious and perfect! We ordered a simple, elegant three-tier white cake for our wedding and it could not have been better. The top tier was raspberry with vanilla sponge, the middle was Nutella cannoli with chocolate sponge, and the bottom was vanilla sponge with lemon custard. Every layer was incredible, and our guests couldn’t stop talking about how good it was. Our florist added fresh flowers, which made the cake look beautifully simple and timeless. The tasting experience with the bakery was just as wonderful, everything was fresh, flavorful, and very reasonably priced. We’re so grateful for how seamless and special they made this part of our wedding day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Martin Barretta
Best jelly donuts on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jimbo69
PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD BAKER. BRING BACK THE OLD INGREDIENTS TO THE 7 LAYER COOKIES. AND STOP BURNING THE BREAD STICKS. AND PUT THEM BACK IN THE PLASTIC CONTAINERS. I SEE WHY YOU PUT THEM IN PAPER BAGS SO NOONE SEE’S HOW CRAPPY AND BURNT THEY ARE. STOP BEING CHEAP WE PAY GOOD MONEY AT YOUR STORE
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Nikki
Apparently grammar took the day off, right along with quality control. The cake itself was fine, but every time I looked at ‘Happy 33th Birthday,’ I was reminded I paid full price for something that flunked 3rd grade English. Sure, I should’ve checked before leaving, but silly me for expecting accuracy from a bakery whose entire job is to put words and numbers on cakes. Talk about embarrassing.
Teresa Caccese
I can’t get over how beautiful this cake came out! Belli Baci did an amazing job. The girls behind counter were super sweet and even walked the cake out to my car because they had to put it in a really big box. Service was amazing and the cake was delicious. I will be ordering from them for every occasion now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thurya Ismail
Hi, As I saw the last review I actually have the same issue. 3 days ago I went to get a cake and wanted to write on it too The women who were helping me out was nice I can tell she even let others know that i came first and she need to help me first however maybe because she was on a rush but I was trying to decide what cake I should get and the cakes were looking so bad I can tell they have been there for 2 weeks I was so hesitating but I ended up choosing one but the cakes was so unprofessional i can make a better cake than that it looked like it was done so fast the cream was not clean and the fruits were old. Tgere was another cake of tge same look so I asked to see it too because I was short to reach it but she was like its the same thing . !! I KNOW :) I was trying to see if the cream is a little bit more cleaner . Okay whatever I ended up paying 37dollars for a cake that was so old away from that. the cake was for my dad and it was chocolate squared cake she wrote on it IN PINK pinkkkk please was there no other options I was sooo disappointed I asked if we can change it she was like noo I give ideas she was like no okay thats not my problem you should offer another cake ? The cake was so bad I didn’t even want take picture of it it taste SO BAD and old nothing was fresh in that cake my stomach started hurting from one bite everyone literally took one bite and we threw all of the rest.
Its so sad how you don’t do your job with love when you’re sharing happy times like cakes are for happy times be a part of it let your customers remember you in those happy times and come back again and again and talk about you .
Thank you anyway.
Food: 1
Service: 2
william cilenti
Best bakery on Staten Island no one comes close best doughnuts best cakes and the food is better then your favorite restaurant 🔥🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
eleonora randazzo
I never leave reviews (this is my first one), but my recent visit to Belli Baci was so disappointing that I felt the need to share my experience. We spent around $80 on a cake and assorted pastries, and unfortunately, the quality was far from what we expected. The cannoli filling tasted sour, almost as if the ricotta had gone bad, and it actually gave me a stomachache afterward. The cake we tried was dry, stale, or just lacked flavor, definitely not worth the price. To make matters worse, the staff seemed uninterested and unmotivated, barely engaging with customers and giving off the impression that they didn’t want to be there. For a bakery charging premium prices, I expected much better in both quality and service. I won’t be returning and wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone looking for a good bakery experience. Save your money and go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brianne Meyer
I ordered a catering order for my housewarming party which included the hot antipasto, sandwich trays and penne vodka with grilled chicken. For sandwiches I chose the Belli baci special, drunken chicken, sauceeeech, and the eggplant special. Placing the order was quick and easy and the receptionist was friendly and accommodating. Delivery was on time and again the delivery person Michael was also very friendly and accommodating. While I was unable to eat most of it as I have a gluten allergy, my guests absolutely raved over the food. In particular the sandwiches which were especially convenient for an outside pool party. I will probably be picking up orders to deliver to my mom who lives 1.5 hrs away she loved it so much. Overall this was a great catering experience and I will definitely be using Belli Baci again in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
abd yousuf
Unfortunately, I had a disappointing experience here. There are several other bakeries in Staten Island that consistently deliver higher quality and better service. The staff was surprisingly rude during my visit, and the cake I purchased did not taste fresh — the strawberries in particular seemed overripe or going bad. I wouldn’t recommend this place when there are better options nearby that offer both better products and a more pleasant customer experience.
Seven layer cupcake, cannoli, bagels, pizza everything is outstanding!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Iacono
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Hidden Gem in Staten Island!
Belli Baci Bakery is hands-down one of the best bakeries I’ve visited in Staten Island. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh-baked bread and pastries wraps around you like a warm hug. Their chocolate bread is absolutely divine—rich, soft, and unforgettable. And don’t even get me started on the PB&J donut… it’s a nostalgic twist with a gourmet flair!
The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the vibe is cozy and inviting. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee and pastry or picking up treats for a special occasion, this place delivers every time. You can tell they put love into everything they make.
Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area—you won’t regret.
Todd Doren
Website says closes 8pm. Traveled to this bakery to order a birthday cake at 7:00 pm and was told they are closed by the girl sweeping. I called she said their new hours are 7pm. I told her why we came there, she said sorry can't help. I asked when the owner was in and she said he is here. I asked to speak she said hold on and he never came on the phone. How cowardly can you be to disrespect a customer. I have shopped here for years.
Jimmy Jiang
Super longtime wait by food for delivery
Susan Ally
Rainbow donuts most amazing donut i ever had. Thank you!!!
Absolutely delicious and perfect! We ordered a simple, elegant three-tier white cake for our wedding and it could not have been better. The top tier was raspberry with vanilla sponge, the middle was Nutella cannoli with chocolate sponge, and the bottom was vanilla sponge with lemon custard. Every layer was incredible, and our guests couldn’t stop talking about how good it was. Our florist added fresh flowers, which made the cake look beautifully simple and timeless. The tasting experience with the bakery was just as wonderful, everything was fresh, flavorful, and very reasonably priced. We’re so grateful for how seamless and special they made this part of our wedding day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best jelly donuts on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD BAKER. BRING BACK THE OLD INGREDIENTS TO THE 7 LAYER COOKIES. AND STOP BURNING THE BREAD STICKS. AND PUT THEM BACK IN THE PLASTIC CONTAINERS. I SEE WHY YOU PUT THEM IN PAPER BAGS SO NOONE SEE’S HOW CRAPPY AND BURNT THEY ARE. STOP BEING CHEAP WE PAY GOOD MONEY AT YOUR STORE
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Apparently grammar took the day off, right along with quality control. The cake itself was fine, but every time I looked at ‘Happy 33th Birthday,’ I was reminded I paid full price for something that flunked 3rd grade English. Sure, I should’ve checked before leaving, but silly me for expecting accuracy from a bakery whose entire job is to put words and numbers on cakes. Talk about embarrassing.
I can’t get over how beautiful this cake came out! Belli Baci did an amazing job. The girls behind counter were super sweet and even walked the cake out to my car because they had to put it in a really big box. Service was amazing and the cake was delicious. I will be ordering from them for every occasion now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hi,
As I saw the last review I actually have the same issue. 3 days ago I went to get a cake and wanted to write on it too The women who were helping me out was nice I can tell she even let others know that i came first and she need to help me first however maybe because she was on a rush but I was trying to decide what cake I should get and the cakes were looking so bad I can tell they have been there for 2 weeks I was so hesitating but I ended up choosing one but the cakes was so unprofessional i can make a better cake than that it looked like it was done so fast the cream was not clean and the fruits were old. Tgere was another cake of tge same look so I asked to see it too because I was short to reach it but she was like its the same thing . !! I KNOW :) I was trying to see if the cream is a little bit more cleaner .
Okay whatever I ended up paying 37dollars for a cake that was so old away from that. the cake was for my dad and it was chocolate squared cake she wrote on it IN PINK pinkkkk please was there no other options I was sooo disappointed I asked if we can change it she was like noo I give ideas she was like no okay thats not my problem you should offer another cake ?
The cake was so bad I didn’t even want take picture of it it taste SO BAD and old nothing was fresh in that cake my stomach started hurting from one bite everyone literally took one bite and we threw all of the rest.
Its so sad how you don’t do your job with love when you’re sharing happy times like cakes are for happy times be a part of it let your customers remember you in those happy times and come back again and again and talk about you .
Thank you anyway.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best bakery on Staten Island no one comes close best doughnuts best cakes and the food is better then your favorite restaurant 🔥🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I never leave reviews (this is my first one), but my recent visit to Belli Baci was so disappointing that I felt the need to share my experience. We spent around $80 on a cake and assorted pastries, and unfortunately, the quality was far from what we expected.
The cannoli filling tasted sour, almost as if the ricotta had gone bad, and it actually gave me a stomachache afterward. The cake we tried was dry, stale, or just lacked flavor, definitely not worth the price. To make matters worse, the staff seemed uninterested and unmotivated, barely engaging with customers and giving off the impression that they didn’t want to be there. For a bakery charging premium prices, I expected much better in both quality and service. I won’t be returning and wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone looking for a good bakery experience. Save your money and go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered a catering order for my housewarming party which included the hot antipasto, sandwich trays and penne vodka with grilled chicken. For sandwiches I chose the Belli baci special, drunken chicken, sauceeeech, and the eggplant special. Placing the order was quick and easy and the receptionist was friendly and accommodating. Delivery was on time and again the delivery person Michael was also very friendly and accommodating. While I was unable to eat most of it as I have a gluten allergy, my guests absolutely raved over the food. In particular the sandwiches which were especially convenient for an outside pool party. I will probably be picking up orders to deliver to my mom who lives 1.5 hrs away she loved it so much. Overall this was a great catering experience and I will definitely be using Belli Baci again in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unfortunately, I had a disappointing experience here. There are several other bakeries in Staten Island that consistently deliver higher quality and better service. The staff was surprisingly rude during my visit, and the cake I purchased did not taste fresh — the strawberries in particular seemed overripe or going bad. I wouldn’t recommend this place when there are better options nearby that offer both better products and a more pleasant customer experience.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Seven layer cupcake, cannoli, bagels, pizza everything is outstanding!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Hidden Gem in Staten Island!
Belli Baci Bakery is hands-down one of the best bakeries I’ve visited in Staten Island. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh-baked bread and pastries wraps around you like a warm hug. Their chocolate bread is absolutely divine—rich, soft, and unforgettable. And don’t even get me started on the PB&J donut… it’s a nostalgic twist with a gourmet flair!
The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the vibe is cozy and inviting. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee and pastry or picking up treats for a special occasion, this place delivers every time. You can tell they put love into everything they make.
Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area—you won’t regret.
Website says closes 8pm. Traveled to this bakery to order a birthday cake at 7:00 pm and was told they are closed by the girl sweeping. I called she said their new hours are 7pm. I told her why we came there, she said sorry can't help. I asked when the owner was in and she said he is here. I asked to speak she said hold on and he never came on the phone. How cowardly can you be to disrespect a customer. I have shopped here for years.
Super longtime wait by food for delivery
Rainbow donuts most amazing donut i ever had.
Thank you!!!
Loading...