Cold Stone Creamery

2508 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
(917) 791-5018

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David Garcia

I love this place. Service is fast and on point, the place is kept clean and the ice cream is top notch as always. I usually always get chocolate devotion or cheesecake fantasy. But today I got Oreo overload, let’s just say I got a a newfound love for cold stone again. Always hits the spot!

Abbot Heltsner

Great ice cream, I love their toppings!

S A

Chocolate Devotion from Cold Stone is super tasty! It has chocolate ice cream, fudge, brownies, and chocolate chips all mixed together. Every bite is full of chocolate and so fun to eat. If you love chocolate, you will really enjoy this!

Pretty Boy

I was Waiting for 15 minutes the store was empty but it was still open, so I waited for 20 Minutes I yelled “is everyone there” nothing but Silence and I heard talking so there were goofing around not taking it seriously, just because there’s not a lot of people in your store, you still shouldn’t slack off , Disappointed Cold stone now that idk should I ever return or not

Joseph Buro

Premium ice cream or cakes, which you should expect to pay premium prices. Everything is good, and I do love their cakes. The staff is helpful in ordering and has never made an error with us. It is not a matter of choosing the best versus other places. Sometimes you are in the mood for Coldstone, Carvel, fro-yo at Yogurt City, or some delicious homemade ice cream at Something Sweet. You make your choice and get what you expect to get. Coldstone is for big, tasty, and pricey.

Natalya Pigulskaya

Got an ice cream birthday cake for hubby! We got a small one, coffee flavor, with writing. The service here was exceptional. The guy took my order over the phone when my credit card wouldn't go through on the website and said I could pay when I was picking up the cake! And the cake was delicious!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Juan Roman

Amazing ice cream cakes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mohamed Nametalla

It's an ice cream store! Nothing much to say about that other than how pricy it is. For three kids size (one scoop) and one regular small size (two scoops) I paid close to $40!That's insane for ice cream in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Colon

Great selection of ice

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Cristina Galofaro

I came in to purchase a premade cake and asked for “happy birthday” written on the cake. I was the only customer in the store and waited 20 minutes for the writing to be done, just for it to look completely sloppy. Normally I wouldn’t say anything but it seemed like this employee had no experience doing this. I then asked him to fix it and waited another 15 minutes for the cake. 35 minutes to write “happy birthday” ??? Not to mention another customer walked out during this…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Jesse Fung

Great food and environment. Everyone has great energy and makes their ice cream so good.I even love their ice cream cakes in the fridge up front.Recommend !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dominique Cullen

This place is really nice. The owner is super cool. I had an issue a while back with a milk shake not being made properly. I called to complain, and the owner called me back personally. He was apologetic and extremely accommodating and nice. Mistakes happen, and he made it right for me and my husband. We've been several times since with no issue.

Vicky

First-time bear would definitely go back the young man at the counter explained everything he was going to do and it was fun watching him a little pricey but it was good

Bourteney Love

I just ordered from here guy completely messes up my order so i have to dispose of it instead of reimbursing me or making it again I had to pay again just for him to make it wrong again… it can’t be that hard to put ice cream on a cone like seriously

Lena Chka

Delicious ice cream, open late on Friday amd Saturday.

Loading...