Cookie Jar
1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island
(718) 448-3500
Customers' Favorites
2 lb Rainbow Petit Fours Aka 7 Layer Cookies
1 Dozen Red Velvet Cupcakes
1 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes
2 lb Assorted Cookies
Cookies & Cup Cakes
Chocolate Explosion
Feeling Nutty
Cookie Jars
Cookie Trays
Sandwich
Menu
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We travel 191 miles each way to visit friends and procure a shipment of exceptional cookies from Cookie Jar. Although we are originally from New York and now reside in the South, we maintain that their product is unmatched. Attempts to replicate their cookies have proven unsuccessful, as their unique quality is attributed to the distinctive New York water and the expertise of their bakers.
I love this place I've been hooked on their dubai ice latte but the last 2 times it was terrible so disappointed and for almost $8! guys plz train everyone that works there should know how to make them
The Red Velvet Whoopie was incredible — so soft and moist, with delicious cream! 🤤 Everything is homemade, and the jar collection is wonderful 😊