Cookie Jar
181 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island
(718) 979-4500
Menu
Photos
+28 photos
+27 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
So cute inside and the staff is soo friendly! Came with some friends over the weekend and we had to make a return trip the next day. Cookies are about $16.50/lb, so quantity per price is very much based on what you buy. For us, prices came out to about $1/cookie/ I preferred some cookies to others, but none were bad. Faves: Elephant ear, twix pretzel, adult chocolate chip, and pb&j.
Fantastic owners and staff at both locations (Forest Ave and New Dorp) I was blown away at the level of customer service.I fell in love with every cookie I tried. The batter is light and buttery in a special way that makes me want to return again and again. I tried at least a dozen. And they all had something different to offer but they all were consistently delicious.There is a wide variety, so there is something for every taste at a reasonable price.I loved the decor at both...
Love this place. Interesting options and flavors. Try and stop by when I’m in the area to bring treats home. Favorite was the peanut-butter and jelly cookie and the homemade Oreos.
You May Also Like
Piece-A-Cake - 177 New Dorp Ln
![]()
Cafe, Bakery, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Brioso - 174 New Dorp Ln
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian