Cutest Cookies

1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
(718) 966-2883

Recent Reviews

Sort by
nicole porcelli

Thank you so much, Cutest Cookies, for the amazing cookies! It was such a pleasure meeting you the night of my event. I truly appreciate your help with decorating the candy table — you did an amazing job. Your talent and kindness made the event even more special.

Elina Gerts

The cookies are delicious! I love ordering customized cookie kits for when my kids' friends come over. I place the order on Facebook Messenger, and the kit is always correct and exactly how I want it. The kids enjoy decorating them and take them home as party favors. They're not too sweet, and the kids always tell me how much fun they had working on the kits together and how great they taste.

S A

Brought my sister here to attend a birthday party and I was so impressed with how well-ran and adorable it was! The kids had a great time making their own pizzas and decorating a bunch of different cookies. The two girls who supervised were super nice and worked very efficiently. Definitely recommend!

Cait Castellano

The Best! Absolutely Deliciously Fresh! Always a treat! Thank you!!

Viktor and Ksenia Barengolts

Our local gem for all party needs! Thank you for wonderful customer service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Mariah Alimossy

Had my daughter’s birthday party here! So cute, clean, amazing staff, such a great atmosphere. Good cookies. Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sabrina LoPorcaro

The custom cookies for my daughter's surprise proposal were perfect. Christine guided me through the details over the phone and via messenger, quickly, efficiently, and on very short notice. Our guests were impressed that they tasted as good as they looked. Highly recommend.

Maria Ramirez

Ordered cookies for my niece's bridal shower. They are beautiful. Cutest cookies always exceeds my expectations. The staff is very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Rose Of Sharon

Cozy little bakery ( nut free establishment)
Decorate your own butter cookies. They last about a week. Nice staff, require 12 people to have a party there.

Parking: Parking on premises

Kid-friendliness: Kids are most definitely welcome

Wheelchair accessibility: Small wheelchair will fit

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Tiffany Hong

The only place that i go to for custom cookies. It’s been years now and every order comes out perfect/exactly to my description. And their prices are super reasonable/affordable. Their cookies are also nut-free so i don’t have to worry about anyone being allergic. I’ll never order cookies from anywhere else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gift Basket, Cookies

Joyce Venezia Suss

I had a vision for "bead" cookies to match the theme of a jewelry beading party, and Christine not only made it happen (making sure the size and the hole in the middle of the cookie fit the display board), but she also did it with a tight deadline. Our guests LOVED the cookies - especially because they are delicious! I love this shop and the dedication of the owner and her employees. :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aishe Isa

My son’s class went on a field trip there and the whole class setup to allowing the children to decorate their own cookies to take home was adorable! I loved how clean and organized everything was and the smell in the shop is Amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Aflak Marucci

The owner Christina has come in clutch for me so many times party after party. The reality is: the cookie is just too damn good. No reason to make anything else when you can win with such a perfect recipe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Martire Juarez

Great place for a party! Staff is wonderful and they offer a great party package including pizza ( that the kids make) and the birthday cake plus all the kids make 6 cookies.

Jymmy Garcia

Great service

Loading...