Cutest Cookies

1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
(718) 966-2883

Recent Reviews

Tiffany Hong

The only place that i go to for custom cookies. It’s been years now and every order comes out perfect/exactly to my description. And their prices are super reasonable/affordable. Their cookies are also nut-free so i don’t have to worry about anyone being allergic. I’ll never order cookies from anywhere else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gift Basket, Cookies

Joyce Venezia Suss

I had a vision for "bead" cookies to match the theme of a jewelry beading party, and Christine not only made it happen (making sure the size and the hole in the middle of the cookie fit the display board), but she also did it with a tight deadline. Our guests LOVED the cookies - especially because they are delicious! I love this shop and the dedication of the owner and her employees. :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aishe Isa

My son’s class went on a field trip there and the whole class setup to allowing the children to decorate their own cookies to take home was adorable! I loved how clean and organized everything was and the smell in the shop is Amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Aflak Marucci

The owner Christina has come in clutch for me so many times party after party. The reality is: the cookie is just too damn good. No reason to make anything else when you can win with such a perfect recipe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Martire Juarez

Great place for a party! Staff is wonderful and they offer a great party package including pizza ( that the kids make) and the birthday cake plus all the kids make 6 cookies.

Tiffany H.

Surprised that this bakery doesn't have more reviews! It is the only place that i go to to order cookies for events! Great customer service and the cookies always turn out beautiful + delicious. Whenever i need customization, they always adhere to the photos that i send to them and the colors/fonts that i request. They are also 100% nut free for those who have nut allergies. Super affordable as well. Usually a dozen cookies for just $50 or less, and they always give a few extra. I will continue to support this business for all future big occasions

Joseph DiSanto

Excellent service and the cookies came out beautiful and delicious

Irish D

We had a lovely time for my kid’s schools field trip and the cookies were yummy ?I’d consider buying cookies from them for special occasions.

Irish De Marco

We had a lovely time for my kid’s schools field trip and the cookies were yummy ?I’d consider buying cookies from them for special occasions.

Concetta Porcelli

The very best.. been having these delicious cookies for all occasions and every one raves love the and great owner. Thanks ?

CHULE Y AB

Place great for kids but the cookies are nasty ?

Happy

It was a school trip with my great grand-daughter. She had a great time and the parents enjoyed watching the kids. The staff is so patient with the kids, they keep everything in order and clean. It was a pleasure being there.

Nawal Elsokary

My kids and I attended a cookie decorating class today, 10/23 and had a great time! thank you so much for this fun-filled opportunity! we will be back soon ☺️

Anony Mous

The cookies are great, but I do have to take off a point for an unprofessional attitude.

Andrew Bienstock

The Cookies are great to get when invited somewhere and don’t know what to bring and always have a ton of fun holiday options. They also have great classes that my daughter has taken and loved precovid and looking forward to their return.

Load More