Bay Street Tavern
1384 Bay St, Staten Island
(718) 720-3254
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Blue Cheese Burger
Shrimp Parmagiana Platter
Buffalo Wings of Fire
Grilled Chicken Hero
Mac and Cheese Bites
Iceberg Wedge Salad
Crispy Wing Zings
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Filet of Sole
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Went here after a long long bike ride with my friends. The service was amazing and everyone was so friendly. The food was delicious. Especially love the touch of pasta salad and the way it was spiced. Incredible french fries. They gave me an extra pickle for my burger. Additionally, they put on a fresh pot of coffee for us! It was nice to see the Mets game on the screen, even though they lost. I wonder what team this institution roots for.
Lively place on a Thursday!! Definitely a local spot but everyone was nice, service was good. Got mozzarella sticks, cheeseburger and blt. Food was better than expected for a dive bat, I REALLY like the burger it was cooked well and was good quality. The drink was nice and STIFF (just how I like it)
Best part of the night was Elvis!!! What a nice surprise and it was fun to watch him sing and dance. Attaching a calendar as they seem to have events almost every night.
Best part of the night was Elvis!!! What a nice surprise and it was fun to watch him sing and dance. Attaching a calendar as they seem to have events almost every night.
We had such a nice time here. What a surprise that we coincidentally showed up on a Wednesday night at 9 PM right when they were having a band. The atmosphere was great. The service was fantastic and the food was delicious. We had the grilled cheese with French onion soup And it tasted so good.
You May Also Like
Island Garden - 1364 Bay St
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Bella Beans Cafe - 1371 Bay St
![]()
Cafe, Bakery, Gluten-Free