I love this pizza place! I ordered a cranberry salad with grilled chicken, vodka chicken wrap, vodka pizza pie, Buffalo chicken slice...each time the food was amazing and the portions were generous. The soups are tasty too.
J K
The pizzas always really good, but hot damn this white pie is good!
Food: 5
Michael C Fleschner
Great food! Would highly recommend!.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ham Calzone, Grandma Pizza
Stacie Stewart
Ordered for the first time to try somewhere new. Disappointed with the sampler box. Was all 7/11 style put in and reheat stuff. Ordered the Neapolitan pizza. It wasn’t a Neapolitan. Was expecting pillowy soft charred dough and it was thin and flat. Not sure if they got the order wrong as they do regular pies too. Toppings were good. Overall it wasn’t terrible but it wasn’t great either. Wouldn’t go back. Too much choice on SI for great pizza
A Riv
It’s a shame that I go there as always on my break from the hospital. The girl even before I order told me that I have to wait 10m for a slice of pizza. There were all kind of pizzas in the counter and she told me that I had to wait and I couldn’t get any of the ones in there. When you’re on break you don’t have 10 m to wait. It could be longer than that. Wasted my time and btw tell those girls to have better customer service skills because the only one that’s been very friendly is the Afghan guy but he’s not there at nighttime.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
lee jin
Some of the best pizza and service I ever experienced. We get pizza from domenico almost every week. It’s a bit of drive from my place but very well worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Rogin
Wasn’t going post but 40$ down the trash. Absolutely disappointing…. That’s a chicken roll soaked, can’t even hold it had to eat it with fork and knife until I gave up and ordered again from Amici down the block. Personal pie that came with it also down the trash. SMH
John Caroccia
Gentlemen that owns the place takes pride in his business and they have the best wings on Staten Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Brittany Ferone
This is my first time ordering from here. I got the Eggplant arugula and peppers hot hero, my partner got the ham calzone...both are EXTREMELY delicious. The food was delivered faster than expected also. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina
Every single time I order sauce on the side I never ever ever get it.. and I always ask twice because I don’t trust that they’ll give it and without fail I’ve never gotten my extra sauce that they charge me for. Honestly I let it go the first couple times but now it’s just kind of annoying.
The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every bite was a delight, and the ingredients tasted top-notch. If you're a pizza enthusiast, this place is definitely worth a visit for its outstanding food quality. Also has a fantastic Gluten-Free personal pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rice Ball
Michele Sedita
We ordered 4 catered meals for 100 people each meal for the Tottenville marching band. The owner was wonderful to work with. He took care of us 100%. The food was delicious and we will continue ordering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Memon
I've had food from Domenico's to varying degrees over the last decade. I specifically remember finding the place to be decent to lower quality. I specifically stopped going there in person when I got the hottest slices of my life. It was so hot the entire slices themselves were nearly completely melted with much of what composed the slices sliding off the slices like water and scalding me multiple times. Eating it was just as much of a struggle. Occasionally, my friends ordered from here. My impression of it from those experiences was that everything was excessively greasy. I would go as far as say that Domenico's has the greasiest pizza I ever tasted. The buffalo slices were serviceable but kind of subpar, like a 4/10 I would rate it. From my memories and later experiences the pepperoni and generic slices were either decent or kind of undesirable something between a 6/10 to a 3/10 at times I found. The garlic knots were pretty good but again, were excessively greasy which could occasionally jeopardize the experience of having them. I should also warn that if you intend to eat there, that it's an extremely small pizzeria, one of the smallest I ever been to from my memory.Ultimately, I think of Domenico's as a pizzeria that could be described as either decent or subpar. The greasiness and that one experience I had with the hottest slices on the planet are what caused me to round what would be a 2.5 out of 5 to just a 2 here. It has the potential to be a pleasant experience, it's just sometimes it genuinely is an unpleasant experience.Parking: There's parking as it's in something of a strip mall. It's not the biggest strip mall parking lot but definitely one should have the space to be able to park in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Sean
Dominic's Best All-around pizzas & Speciaties and the Bow OWN Bagel Place Next Door & Deluvery From their also Freat People
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Francese
Xavier Rogers
Not bad for a quick slice, I wouldn't say its anything amazing but it was definitely good. Biggest complaint was the place is super small. A group of 5 or 6 people was there ordering when I walked in and took up pretty much the entire front of the counter. Delivery boy had to squeeze past and rub up against me and everyone else just to walk by. Guy working the counter was nice though and made sure I got my order heard and put in fast though.
I love this pizza place! I ordered a cranberry salad with grilled chicken, vodka chicken wrap, vodka pizza pie, Buffalo chicken slice...each time the food was amazing and the portions were generous. The soups are tasty too.
The pizzas always really good, but hot damn this white pie is good!
Food: 5
Great food! Would highly recommend!.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ham Calzone, Grandma Pizza
Ordered for the first time to try somewhere new. Disappointed with the sampler box. Was all 7/11 style put in and reheat stuff. Ordered the Neapolitan pizza. It wasn’t a Neapolitan. Was expecting pillowy soft charred dough and it was thin and flat. Not sure if they got the order wrong as they do regular pies too. Toppings were good. Overall it wasn’t terrible but it wasn’t great either. Wouldn’t go back. Too much choice on SI for great pizza
It’s a shame that I go there as always on my break from the hospital. The girl even before I order told me that I have to wait 10m for a slice of pizza. There were all kind of pizzas in the counter and she told me that I had to wait and I couldn’t get any of the ones in there. When you’re on break you don’t have 10 m to wait. It could be longer than that. Wasted my time and btw tell those girls to have better customer service skills because the only one that’s been very friendly is the Afghan guy but he’s not there at nighttime.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Some of the best pizza and service I ever experienced. We get pizza from domenico almost every week. It’s a bit of drive from my place but very well worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wasn’t going post but 40$ down the trash. Absolutely disappointing…. That’s a chicken roll soaked, can’t even hold it had to eat it with fork and knife until I gave up and ordered again from Amici down the block. Personal pie that came with it also down the trash. SMH
Gentlemen that owns the place takes pride in his business and they have the best wings on Staten Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
This is my first time ordering from here. I got the Eggplant arugula and peppers hot hero, my partner got the ham calzone...both are EXTREMELY delicious. The food was delivered faster than expected also. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every single time I order sauce on the side I never ever ever get it.. and I always ask twice because I don’t trust that they’ll give it and without fail I’ve never gotten my extra sauce that they charge me for. Honestly I let it go the first couple times but now it’s just kind of annoying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every bite was a delight, and the ingredients tasted top-notch. If you're a pizza enthusiast, this place is definitely worth a visit for its outstanding food quality. Also has a fantastic Gluten-Free personal pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rice Ball
We ordered 4 catered meals for 100 people each meal for the Tottenville marching band. The owner was wonderful to work with. He took care of us 100%. The food was delicious and we will continue ordering!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've had food from Domenico's to varying degrees over the last decade. I specifically remember finding the place to be decent to lower quality. I specifically stopped going there in person when I got the hottest slices of my life. It was so hot the entire slices themselves were nearly completely melted with much of what composed the slices sliding off the slices like water and scalding me multiple times. Eating it was just as much of a struggle. Occasionally, my friends ordered from here. My impression of it from those experiences was that everything was excessively greasy. I would go as far as say that Domenico's has the greasiest pizza I ever tasted. The buffalo slices were serviceable but kind of subpar, like a 4/10 I would rate it. From my memories and later experiences the pepperoni and generic slices were either decent or kind of undesirable something between a 6/10 to a 3/10 at times I found. The garlic knots were pretty good but again, were excessively greasy which could occasionally jeopardize the experience of having them. I should also warn that if you intend to eat there, that it's an extremely small pizzeria, one of the smallest I ever been to from my memory.Ultimately, I think of Domenico's as a pizzeria that could be described as either decent or subpar. The greasiness and that one experience I had with the hottest slices on the planet are what caused me to round what would be a 2.5 out of 5 to just a 2 here. It has the potential to be a pleasant experience, it's just sometimes it genuinely is an unpleasant experience.Parking: There's parking as it's in something of a strip mall. It's not the biggest strip mall parking lot but definitely one should have the space to be able to park in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Dominic's Best All-around pizzas & Speciaties and the Bow OWN Bagel Place Next Door & Deluvery From their also Freat People
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Francese
Not bad for a quick slice, I wouldn't say its anything amazing but it was definitely good. Biggest complaint was the place is super small. A group of 5 or 6 people was there ordering when I walked in and took up pretty much the entire front of the counter. Delivery boy had to squeeze past and rub up against me and everyone else just to walk by. Guy working the counter was nice though and made sure I got my order heard and put in fast though.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5