EatItalian NYC

655 Rossville Ave, Staten Island
(718) 966-4186

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Gromkoski

Great staff and great food. Highly recommend.

Laura Cutillo

I came to eat here for my birthday and I was sick right after getting home. I had food poisoning or something of the sort. I called the next day to just let them know what I ate so they could be aware. I didn’t expect anything from them just to be courteous. The female person in charge who I spoke to was very rude and at first refused to even have me speak to the person in charge. I asked for a call back and after 2 attempts I got no return call. After that I stopped going there and advised people I know to do the same. I feel you should care as much about the customers as you do the money.

Annie D

This really is a great restaurant. The food is delicious, the staff are awesome and the atmosphere is fun. I love coming here for dinner. Check it out. You won’t be disappointed.

Joe Quercia

Food coma!👍

Antonio Almeida

The food was fantastic! Tables are on the small side and very close to each other.

Vito Lepore

Panzerotti delicious this restaurant brings you back to puglia

RAFAEL BONET

Food was delicious and served exquisitely… Service was on par also. Would recommend highly.

Vito Perrotta

They seriously need to do something about their bread. It’s white bread with a crust. Serve semolina. The dining room is very tight, but warm and cheerful.

john deangelo

Best Donuts I've had in a long time 🍩 great bread !
.What a bakery is supposed to be.

John

Ordered a panini Rustico... for a place called EatITALIAN, you'd hope they made fresh chicken cutlets. Gross, chewy, rubbery, definitely not FRESH. First and last time

Hugh Eng

a great neighborhood restaurant. excellent service and great food.

Jean Riv

Excellent food, service, and atmosphere.

Lin Xu

This is hands-down the best Italian restaurant in New York! The pork chop is insanely good—juicy, flavorful, perfect. And the risotto with fish? Absolutely flawless. I’m honestly at a loss for words. Just go try it—you won’t regret it!

George Pringle

Food is always outstanding!

Patsy Messina

Went with a family of 4 on new years eve just for dinner. Excellent experience and easy to make same day reservation with an early phone call.

Loading...