Second time in last 2 weeks tried to call and phone doesnt work ?? Busy for hours now just says bad #… Cant get through cant make $$$
J Oli
Delicious and great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Oliveras
Delicious and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
StealthyMax
I have been going to Goodfellas for about 6 years now, and I have great memories from this place. The pizza is spectacular, and has only improved. Not to mention, the calamari is just exquisite. Love this place, easy 5 stars.Vegetarian options: Goodfellas has vegetarian options and you can customize your order to fit your preferences.
Always good food. Never disappoints. In this particular Goodfellas location you can actually hear yourself talk...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike healthy life -
This place and Joe and Pats is the best on the island. The pizza is really good. The entrées are great. Try a specialty pizza. It’s fantastic in the brick oven. These guys been here a little while
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jessica Avent
This is considered Italian!!!! Shame on you the worst chicken parm i have ever had. It had a burnt dirty oil taste with non authentic sauce. Funny when my husband, and I walked up to the restaurant it looked closed we should've walked
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Vee Zee
My husband ordered from Goodfellas and upon delivery we got the wrong pizza and the fried calamari was cold. The weird part was that the calamari wasn’t just cooled down it was literally cold as if someone just took it out from the fridge. Couldn’t chew through the calamari pieces either. We contacted the restaurant. They said that a manager would call us back. It’s been a while now and no one called us. Dinner was ruined for us.I few years back Goodfellas was our go to place. It’s probably been 6 months since we ordered from there last time..and now I remember why we stopped.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Grace Mascialino
The staff is wonderful! food was done fast and had amazing flavor. My kids loved the raviolis. Definitely coming back.Kid-friendliness: They had Crayons and markers for my kids!
Came here on a Friday night with family. The bar was was busy with great music playing. We placed our orders and my daughter who has celiacs disease asked for gluten free penne a la vodka. The waitress asked if gluten free was a preference or celiacs in which she responded celiac disease.They serve delicious warm bread with olive oil and herbs. Our food was well prepared with no complaints (everything was delicious) except that my daughter took a few bites of her gluten free pasta and was immediately sick.I really wish restaurant owners and employees would be more educated on cross contamination and gluten allergies and sensitivity.The service here is great and the portions are generous. We all took food home (leftovers). For good Italian food with that "just like home flavor" Goodfellas is a great place to eat! Hoping to find more gluten free restaurants in Staten Island because sadly my daughter could not enjoy her meal.
Erich G.
Jesus Christ did this place go down hill quick. $35 for a barely edible pizza, and they really skimp on toppings. No thanks!Sure - the dining area was renovated and looks great --- but its about the pizza, not the ambiance.Its Staten Island - there are literally a hundred better places to get a pie within a mile radius.
David Alvarez
Place use to be so good, they're slacking off. Ordered a meatball parm got a veal parm.Ordered chicken parm in vodka sauce with penne pasta, the chicken was burnt, also spaghetti and meatballs,hardly any pasta in both dishes and three slices of bread. Also ordered crabcakes, tasted like the kind you buy at the frozen section of the supermarket.
Dominique Carillo
Amazing place. Come and order from here weekly. They have amazing specials and deals for rewards members. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam C.
This is a bad name for a restaurant that was not good. Went there with my sister for $12 luncheon special. Special comes with soda or water. You get a side salad too. Our $12 each was upcharged. My sister had a soda that was charged $3.00. Should have been inclusive. I had a Snapple for $3.00. Waitress, who was still in high school. explained that we did not state we wanted the Special. Of course we did, right off the bat and ordered from that menu. We ended up taking our FREE waters to go. Food was thawed out and served cold lasagna and salmon. Overall, a place to never return to.
Second time in last 2 weeks tried to call and phone doesnt work ?? Busy for hours now just says bad #… Cant get through cant make $$$
Delicious and great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been going to Goodfellas for about 6 years now, and I have great memories from this place. The pizza is spectacular, and has only improved. Not to mention, the calamari is just exquisite. Love this place, easy 5 stars.Vegetarian options: Goodfellas has vegetarian options and you can customize your order to fit your preferences.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Smoking Goodfella Int'l Pizza
Always good food. Never disappoints. In this particular Goodfellas location you can actually hear yourself talk...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place and Joe and Pats is the best on the island. The pizza is really good. The entrées are great. Try a specialty pizza. It’s fantastic in the brick oven. These guys been here a little while
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is considered Italian!!!! Shame on you the worst chicken parm i have ever had. It had a burnt dirty oil taste with non authentic sauce. Funny when my husband, and I walked up to the restaurant it looked closed we should've walked
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My husband ordered from Goodfellas and upon delivery we got the wrong pizza and the fried calamari was cold. The weird part was that the calamari wasn’t just cooled down it was literally cold as if someone just took it out from the fridge. Couldn’t chew through the calamari pieces either. We contacted the restaurant. They said that a manager would call us back. It’s been a while now and no one called us. Dinner was ruined for us.I few years back Goodfellas was our go to place. It’s probably been 6 months since we ordered from there last time..and now I remember why we stopped.
Food: 1
Service: 1
The staff is wonderful! food was done fast and had amazing flavor. My kids loved the raviolis. Definitely coming back.Kid-friendliness: They had Crayons and markers for my kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala
Just might be the worst chicken parm I've ever had-lovely server thoughEggplant parm deserves 2 stars
Restaurantji Recommends
Came here on a Friday night with family. The bar was was busy with great music playing. We placed our orders and my daughter who has celiacs disease asked for gluten free penne a la vodka. The waitress asked if gluten free was a preference or celiacs in which she responded celiac disease.They serve delicious warm bread with olive oil and herbs. Our food was well prepared with no complaints (everything was delicious) except that my daughter took a few bites of her gluten free pasta and was immediately sick.I really wish restaurant owners and employees would be more educated on cross contamination and gluten allergies and sensitivity.The service here is great and the portions are generous. We all took food home (leftovers). For good Italian food with that "just like home flavor" Goodfellas is a great place to eat! Hoping to find more gluten free restaurants in Staten Island because sadly my daughter could not enjoy her meal.
Jesus Christ did this place go down hill quick. $35 for a barely edible pizza, and they really skimp on toppings. No thanks!Sure - the dining area was renovated and looks great --- but its about the pizza, not the ambiance.Its Staten Island - there are literally a hundred better places to get a pie within a mile radius.
Place use to be so good, they're slacking off. Ordered a meatball parm got a veal parm.Ordered chicken parm in vodka sauce with penne pasta, the chicken was burnt, also spaghetti and meatballs,hardly any pasta in both dishes and three slices of bread. Also ordered crabcakes, tasted like the kind you buy at the frozen section of the supermarket.
Amazing place. Come and order from here weekly. They have amazing specials and deals for rewards members. Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a bad name for a restaurant that was not good. Went there with my sister for $12 luncheon special. Special comes with soda or water. You get a side salad too. Our $12 each was upcharged. My sister had a soda that was charged $3.00. Should have been inclusive. I had a Snapple for $3.00. Waitress, who was still in high school. explained that we did not state we wanted the Special. Of course we did, right off the bat and ordered from that menu. We ended up taking our FREE waters to go. Food was thawed out and served cold lasagna and salmon. Overall, a place to never return to.