J's On The Bay

1189 Bay St, Staten Island
(718) 720-0922

Recent Reviews

Melissa C.

Food was amazing in the beginning now they went way below the must simple thing can't be accomplished ask for sunny upside eggs brings me burnt eggs disappears never return to the table and never apologized and in top of that made me pay for the crap

MadameX Y.

Chef and staff KUDOS for your dedication to our time and dinner. We had leftovers, also! Kudos!!!

Frosso J A.

OMG this is the BEST place to go with kids! Food was very tasty and the staff was BEYOND nice. Here's the best part- on Wednesdays they have a character who comes and hangs out with the kids! My kids had a blast and ignored us while we enjoyed great food, great drink, and great service! 100/10 parents recommend!

Kurt K.

Our server George was a gentleman. He truly wanted to make our dining experience pleasant. We went to J's for my wife's birthday. She is gluten and dairy free. She had pizza with/ cheese and pepperoni. She said it was good. Dinner consisted of short rib. It was tender, like butter. I also had roasted Brussel Sprouts. I enjoyed them. For dessert George brought outa flourless chocolate cake w/ a candle (that was kind). I had pistachio crème brûlée, very nice. We would recommend J's on the Bay!

Rhea Z.

Dropped in on a Friday for lunch with my daughter and bestie. We got seated in the back room which was great. Our server was amazing! Such good service. He was a gentleman with curly brown hair and glasses. Soo friendly and had so many suggestions. Just great service from Him. Ambiance is very nice. The back is like a patio and the pizza oven is back there. The complimentary croissants were Soo good. Cheese pizza for my kid--she ate 3 slices lol. I had the J's BEC--the spinach, bacon and spicy aioli was delish--however wasn't a fan of everything else with it. Drinks were great--my fave was probably the espresso martini my server had made and it was delish! I would def come back to try more of the menu plus great service! He needs a raise that kid lol

Lisa Maniscalco

We had a very nice brunch frittata and stuffed zucchini blossom served with a small salad. Everything was wonderful. We will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad

Thomas Miller

I came for Easter brunch with my family. We enjoyed the food and the service was ok. I received the bill for $393.08 (a 20% was built in). I paid $393 exactly. I didn’t notice the $.08 but since I had no input into how much tip I should leave I did not think the $.08 would be an issue Considering that I had just spent nearly $400. I was mistakenThe waitress returned and told us we owed $.08. We laughed thinking she was joking, but it quickly became clear she was not. She requested the $.08 rather sheepishly knowing it sounded ridiculous. When we told her it was ridiculous she said she didn’t make the rules. We gave her a dime and told her to keep the $.02 change.In all my years going to restaurants, I’ve never experienced anything like this. Asking a customer for $.08 when they’ve given you nearly $400 worth of business is absurd. We left the restaurant with a real sour taste. We will not return to J’s on the Bay.

Dominick D.

J's features inventive cuisine served in a cozy setting near the water front. The meat loaf, short ribs, quinoa salad, and bread pudding are highly recommended. The restaurant is also open for daily brunch which is greatly sppreciated.

Stephanie B.

Delicious brunch, excellent bloody mary! A real gem of a spot, high quality, gourmet food, casual vibe & friendly service

Ahmed

Raw burger and pizza wasn’t fresh. This spot is really good when they get it it right but they get it wrong so much I’m done with it, especially as the prices they charge.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Dona F.

Where have I been???? J's is about 10 min from me and I've never been there. Finally!!! The breakfast menu isn't humongous but what they offer is very different from the usual fare. Good coffee A few mini croissants with chocolate butter are put on the table. I could have chowed down on just that and have been happy. The pistachio stuffed French toast with pistachio mascarpone was to die for. My friend had the banana fosters French toast which was also amazing. Had to get the crispy potatoes as a side. Just fantastic . I'd go back in a second and will also try lunch. The lunch menu looks fantastic as well.

Jessica Love

I never had such terrible food in my life! I’m a local that can honestly say never been and never will go back. Ordered the chicken parmigiana pizza and it was beyond DISGUSTING. My husband and I didn’t notice it was no crust pizza until actually picking up the order. The meat tasted soo processed I literally gagged. Between us two we had a total of 3 -4 bites and throw the entire meal in the trash. The calamari was also terrible they throw a few pieces of jalapeño peppers and called it firecracker but basic. Waste of $55. I hate to put thiskind of review but I have to be honest. Friendly staff but the food is a hard NO!

Molivo Olivo

There idea of lasagna and mine are two different things if I wanted lasagna soup I would have asked for it that's how the lasagna was soupy and seemed like waiter was a little forgetful. Also what is generic coke ?Parking: Good luckKid-friendliness: Very nice on Wednesday they have cartoon character grandson enjoyed mickey once he got comfortableWheelchair accessibility: Tight

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Steak

chris tosto

Spectacular dishes and atmosphere. A must try location you have to taste to belive how good it is!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sesame Root Beer-Braised Short Ribs

Pamela Yamel

The creators/creator of this menu I must say merci beaucoup ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: J's Famous Chicken and Waffles

Load More