Justinos Pizza

89 Guyon Ave, Staten Island
(718) 668-2020

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nick Rizzo

Same quality every time. Personally i go for a well done pie, but either way good pizza all around!

Lauren D

A family member orders from here when we visit and not once was the pizza good. The white slice I found to be inedible, honestly. It has an awful after taste.

Agata Catalano

Very dirty

Annie M

I ordered chicken wings and they were rubbery. The chicken caesar salad. I think they gave me ranch dressing because that was NOT Caesar salad dressing and the chicken tasted like it was old.

Elizabeth De Paris

If you want the best Grandma Pie then you need to get it from Justinos. We ordered it tonight and they prepared they way we wanted it. We have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered.

Alecia Clark

Delicious pizza. Friendly staff who help me with the pizza if my hands are full. My favorites are the regular pie, Grandma pie, and vodka pie. Order almost weekly 👌🏼

Nora Dattilo

Just ordered a half pepperoni pizza and they got the order wrong. Then they said they cannot correct unless we send the pizza back? What are they doing recycling pizzas?

LAURA MITTENZWEI

Delicious food, great delivery and not as pricey as most pizza/Italian restaurants!! My go-to was the rice ball parm, pasta fagioli soup and grilled eggplant, veggie wrap with side salad...the added delicious Italian bread put this whole order over the top!!

Vegetarian options: Veggie wrap with salad

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Special

maggie dynak

Very good food . Always fresh and amazing workers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Justino's Special Pizza, Grandpa Sicilian, White Pizza, Justino's Special Sicilian

Paul Matteo

EXCELLENT PIZZA AND GREAT SERVICE !!!!
THE ITALIAN GRILLED CHICKEN WRAP WAS AMAZING !!!!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oasis O

Excellent white pizza. I ordered a quick slice to go and I took the first bite and then I had to order a full pie to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Hayden

Understated neighborhood pizza shop but they mostly put a lot of love into their pizza. Their L&B style grandpa Sicilian is spot on with a nice outer crust crunch and their grandma definitely delivers as does the vodka Sicilian. Keep up the good quality guys.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mario De Leon

Magharita pizza is great
L&B Delicius
Regular slice excellent
Vodka

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza, Justino's Special Pizza, Hot Antipasto Catering, Cheese Pizza, Spinach Alfredo Pizza Specialty, Justino's Special Sicilian

Nicole Ortiz

Ordered from them on slice ordered two vodka slices among other things and they gave me one marinara and one vodka my fault for not checking the order before I got home. They refused to refund the wrong slice when I got home and contacted Slice. They claimed they gave both vodka slices I mean are you kidding me like I don’t know how they taste and besides the fact, they looked completely different. I even sent a picture one is red and one is an orange colored.

Nick Vasile

Pizza is great, and catering is fantastic. You would never think from a pizzeria.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...